Post history

History for AucklandPhoenix

Who do we want to see in a white shirt?

Back to topic

Current version

Posted December 09, 2025 02:12 · last edited December 09, 2025 02:17

The one which is very difficult to fathom is Luke Brooke-Smith inside a 26 man squad.

At the moment he can’t make the Nix’s first team and only got 13 mins of the bench in the last game. 

There is currently no reason to take him at all unless you want to offer him the experience and hoping at the age of 17 he will blossom, but with the Smiths of this world likely in the squad, you can’t take two passengers.

Would likely have him well behind Piper at this stage.

Would have Piper any day crashing of the bench in the last 10 minutes then LBS.


Previous versions

4 versions
Unknown editor edited December 09, 2025 02:17
The one which is very difficult to fathom is Luke Brooke-Smith inside a 26 man squad.

At the moment he can’t make the Nix’s first team and only got 13 mins of the bench in the last game. 

There is currently no reason to take him at all unless you want to offer him the experience and hoping at the age of 17 he will blossom, but with the Smiths of this world likely in the squad, you can’t take two passengers.

Would likely have him behind Piper at this stage.


Unknown editor edited December 09, 2025 02:16
The one which is very difficult to fathom is Luke Brooke-Smith inside a 26 man squad.

At the moment he can’t make the Nix’s first team and only got 13 mins of the bench in the last game. 

Apart from him being 17 there is currently no reason to take him at all unless you want to offer him the experience but with the Smiths of this world likely in the squad, you can’t take two passengers.

Would likely have him behind Piper at this stage.


Unknown editor edited December 09, 2025 02:15
The one which is very difficult to fathom is Luke Brooke-Smith inside a 26 man squad.

At the moment he can’t make the Nix’s first team and only got 13 mins of the bench in the last game. 

Apart from him being 17 and experience, there is currently no reason to take him at all.

Would likely have him behind Piper at this stage.


Unknown editor edited December 09, 2025 02:14
The one which is very difficult to fathom is Luke Brooke-Smith inside a 26 man squad.

At the moment he can’t make the Nix’s first team and only got 13 mins of the bench in the last game. 

Would likely have him behind Piper at this stage.