Current version

Posted December 09, 2025 14:09 · last edited December 09, 2025 14:11

Elemenop
Also Garbett above McCowatt. That can't be right! McCowatt scoring regularly in a much better league. 

I love Piney's work. But this list just feels a bit rushed to me.

People don't seem to say it here but as much as Piney loves his football (like us) he's a poor judge of ability and a poor commentator to boot. I'm sure he's great crack on a beer at the pub, but then so are most of us here too.

I take that list with an ocean's grain of salt. We all know know who the top 15 odd players are without the need of some random list.

Previous versions

3 versions
Unknown editor edited December 09, 2025 14:11
Elemenop
Also Garbett above McCowatt. That can't be right! McCowatt scoring regularly in a much better league. 

I love Piney's work. But this list just feels a bit rushed to me.

People don't seem to say it here but as much as Piney loves his football (like us) he's a poor judge of ability and a poor commentator to boot. I'm sure he's great crack on a beer at the pub, but then so are most of us here too.

I take that list with an ocean's grain of salt. Me st of us know who the top 15 odd players are without the need of some random list.
Unknown editor edited December 09, 2025 14:11
Elemenop
Also Garbett above McCowatt. That can't be right! McCowatt scoring regularly in a much better league. 

I love Piney's work. But this list just feels a bit rushed to me.

People don't seem to say it here but as much as Piney loves his football (like us) he's a poor judge of ability and a poor commentator to boot. I'm sure he's great crack on a beer at the pub, but then so are most of us here too.
Unknown editor edited December 09, 2025 14:10
Elemenop
Also Garbett above McCowatt. That can't be right! McCowatt scoring regularly in a much better league. 

I love Piney's work. But this list just feels a bit rushed to me.

People don't seem to say it here but as much as Piney loves his football (like us) he's a poor judge of ability and a poor commentator to boot. I'm sure he's great crack of a beer, but then so are most of us here too.