Post history

History for mrsmiis

ISPS Handa Premiership

Back to topic

Current version

Posted November 19, 2020 00:10 · last edited November 19, 2020 00:16

I see a lot of people rubbishing Vuksich's statements as if he's deadset on the current system continuing. His arguments are valid and there are certainly much better ways to solve regional representation (which seems to be the main grievance many people have, apart from being sick of ACFC), which he recognises. Can't understate just how much of a detriment that slashing the player pool via a Superclub model is - logically that provides a much weaker league, facilitates many more unneeded transfers and hugely inflates the prices of mediocre talent as El Grap suggests.

For me, the previously suggested four-year pro/rel model works in theory, putting aside its convoluted nature for a second. I'd like to see that idea developed more in the wake of COVID before we jump the gun on a model that provides regional representation, and ruins everything else.

Previous versions

2 versions
Unknown editor edited November 19, 2020 00:16

I see a lot of people rubbishing Vuksich's statements as if he's deadset on the current system continuing. His arguments are completely valid and there are certainly much better ways to solve regional representation (which seems to be the main grievance many people have, apart from being sick of ACFC), which he recognises. Can't understate just how much of a detriment that slashing the player pool via a Superclub model is - logically that provides a much weaker league, facilitates many more unneeded transfers and hugely inflates the prices of mediocre talent as El Grap suggests.

For me, the previously suggested four-year pro/rel model works in theory, putting aside its convoluted nature for a second. I'd like to see that idea developed more in the wake of COVID before we jump the gun on a model that provides regional representation, and ruins everything else.

Unknown editor edited November 19, 2020 00:12

I see a lot of people rubbishing Vuksich's statements as if he's deadset on the current system continuing. His arguments are completely valid and there are certainly much better ways to solve regional representation (which seems to be the main grievance many people have, apart from being sick of ACFC), which he recognises. Can't understate just how much of a detriment that slashing the player pool via a Superclub model is - logically that provides a much weaker league, facilitates many more unneeded transfers and hugely inflates the prices of mediocre talent as El Grap suggests.