Post history

History for aitkenmike

The man in the middle - Referee Admiration/Angst/Appointments thread

Back to topic

Current version

Posted December 05, 2018 10:03 · last edited December 06, 2018 00:38

zonknz wrote:

Is this the ultimate "but I got the ball ref" challenge? https://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/a2d7st/sc...

Answers on a postcard please.

Wow, that was bad.

Question for Chris - The commentators (I know, don't listen to commentators on rule issues) made it seem like the main issue was whether the keeper had a hand on the ball and had it under control. For me, it looked like a red card even if the keepers hand came off the ball the way the attacker went through the ball and into the keeper dangerously? Am I wrong there.

Previous versions

1 version

Unknown editor edited December 06, 2018 00:38

zonknz wrote:

Is this the ultimate "but I got the ball ref" challenge? https://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/comments/a2d7st/sc...

Answers on a postcard please.

Wow, that was bad.

Question for Chris - The commentators (I know, don't listen to commentators on rule issues) made it seem like the main issue was whether the keeper had a hand on the ball and had it under control. For me, it looked like a red card even if the keepers hand off the ball the way the attacker went through the ball and into the keeper dangerously? Am I wrong there.