Sinclair's biggest battle was with himself. He was the most thin skinned batsmen around but if he managed to get on top of the demons in his head he was outstanding. While Gup has a better head on him he still doesn't quite cut it technically. And you're right buffy, a lot of our players have technique issues - Ryder is suffering right now - but Gup hasn't shown he can improve in the right areas even at Plunkett Shield level.
Sinclair's biggest battle was with himself. He was the most thin skinned batsmen around but if he managed to get on top of the demons in his head he was outstanding. While Gup has a better head on him he still doesn't quite cut it technically. And you're right buffy, a lot of our players have technique issues - Ryder is suffering right now - but Gup hasn't shown he can improve in the right areas even at Plunkett Shield level.