Post history

History for Nelfoos

Local womens football (incl. W League)

Back to topic

Current version

Posted March 19, 2019 19:59 · last edited March 19, 2019 20:04

Nelfoos wrote:

Nelfoos wrote:

WATP wrote:

wasn't meant to be a complaint ,just adding to the thread, maybe CF could think about it next year,Kelly Cup is Saturday and plate is Sunday,  i know CF have been approached and there response to Sundays was no we promised clubs WLeague would always be Saturday.

Its now been split into a top and bottom half and from what I can tell all top half teams are W-League (apart from KCU) and all bottom half teams are Prems (except Wairarapa). Little reason not to let us play Sundays (if the grounds are available) although obviously travel a factor for Rapa and KCU.

The winners from Saturday play the next round of the Kelly Cup, the losers are now playing for the Executive Plate (actually how the Kelly Cup used to work quite a while ago). I'm also guessing that you're not aware that if the game finishes in a draw it goes straight to pens.

Grounds would probably be an issue on Sunday as the Hilton Petone is on then (although I'm pretty sure they could make it work if they really wanted to)

Travel also a factor for Palmy Marist - they have a "home" draw but the game is at Alex Moore

I'm aware of the rules of the league and also well aware that penalties may be needed. Not sure what bearing that has on rolling subs though? We had them in the Executive Plate last year. We also played the Executive Plate on Sunday last year.

sorry I read that as you seemed unsure as to why there was a split etc

doesn't have anything to do with rolling subs

in all honesty, If you are playing premier league you should have a team fit enough to be able to play without rolling subs

 

We will have a team fit enough, however we only had trials a week ago (students have just come to Wellington) and we'd had one training session together before the game - some players have had a full preseason but a good number have only just arrived in Wellington.

I only found out we'd been entered in Kelly Cup 5 days before the games (that ones not on Capital Football though, that's my/the clubs fault). There's a solid chance we'll be defaulting on Saturday at this point because my team have other commitments on Saturdays that they can't change with a week's notice (and I can't expect them to forgo Homegrown tickets they've paid hundreds for before they knew we were playing, among other reasons players can't make it).

The point of preseason is to build fitness, work on combinations and assess players in different roles, all of which are harmed by non-rolling subs.

I actually think Prems should be non-rolling but if they're going to have rolling then preseason should be changed to match.

Previous versions

2 versions
Unknown editor edited March 19, 2019 20:04
The JourneyFan wrote:
Nelfoos wrote:
The JourneyFan wrote:
Nelfoos wrote:
WATP wrote:

wasn't meant to be a complaint ,just adding to the thread, maybe CF could think about it next year,Kelly Cup is Saturday and plate is Sunday,  i know CF have been approached and there response to Sundays was no we promised clubs WLeague would always be Saturday.

Its now been split into a top and bottom half and from what I can tell all top half teams are W-League (apart from KCU) and all bottom half teams are Prems (except Wairarapa). Little reason not to let us play Sundays (if the grounds are available) although obviously travel a factor for Rapa and KCU.

The winners from Saturday play the next round of the Kelly Cup, the losers are now playing for the Executive Plate (actually how the Kelly Cup used to work quite a while ago). I'm also guessing that you're not aware that if the game finishes in a draw it goes straight to pens.

Grounds would probably be an issue on Sunday as the Hilton Petone is on then (although I'm pretty sure they could make it work if they really wanted to)

Travel also a factor for Palmy Marist - they have a "home" draw but the game is at Alex Moore

I'm aware of the rules of the league and also well aware that penalties may be needed. Not sure what bearing that has on rolling subs though? We had them in the Executive Plate last year. We also played the Executive Plate on Sunday last year.

sorry I read that as you seemed unsure as to why there was a split etc

doesn't have anything to do with rolling subs

in all honesty, If you are playing premier league you should have a team fit enough to be able to play without rolling subs

We will have a team fit enough, however we only had trials a week ago (students have just come to Wellington) and we'd had one training session together before the game. I only found out we'd been entered in Kelly Cup 5 days before the games (that ones not on Capital Football though, that's my/the clubs fault). There's a solid chance we'll be defaulting on Saturday at this point because my team have other commitments on Saturdays that they can't change with a week's notice (and I can't expect them to forgo Homegrown tickets they've paid hundreds for before they knew we were playing, among other reasons players can't make it).

The point of preseason is to build fitness, work on combinations and assess players in different roles, all of which are harmed by non-rolling subs.

I actually think Prems should be non-rolling but if they're going to have rolling then preseason should be changed to match.

Unknown editor edited March 19, 2019 20:02
The JourneyFan wrote:
Nelfoos wrote:
The JourneyFan wrote:
Nelfoos wrote:
WATP wrote:

wasn't meant to be a complaint ,just adding to the thread, maybe CF could think about it next year,Kelly Cup is Saturday and plate is Sunday,  i know CF have been approached and there response to Sundays was no we promised clubs WLeague would always be Saturday.

Its now been split into a top and bottom half and from what I can tell all top half teams are W-League (apart from KCU) and all bottom half teams are Prems (except Wairarapa). Little reason not to let us play Sundays (if the grounds are available) although obviously travel a factor for Rapa and KCU.

The winners from Saturday play the next round of the Kelly Cup, the losers are now playing for the Executive Plate (actually how the Kelly Cup used to work quite a while ago). I'm also guessing that you're not aware that if the game finishes in a draw it goes straight to pens.

Grounds would probably be an issue on Sunday as the Hilton Petone is on then (although I'm pretty sure they could make it work if they really wanted to)

Travel also a factor for Palmy Marist - they have a "home" draw but the game is at Alex Moore

I'm aware of the rules of the league and also well aware that penalties may be needed. Not sure what bearing that has on rolling subs though? We had them in the Executive Plate last year. We also played the Executive Plate on Sunday last year.

sorry I read that as you seemed unsure as to why there was a split etc

doesn't have anything to do with rolling subs

in all honesty, If you are playing premier league you should have a team fit enough to be able to play without rolling subs

We will have a team fit enough, however we only had trials a week ago (students have just come to Wellington) and we'd had one training session together before the game. I only found out we'd been entered in Kelly Cup 5 days before the games (that ones not on Capital Football though, that's my/the clubs fault).

The point of preseason is to build fitness, work on combinations and assess players in different roles, all of which are harmed by non-rolling subs.

I actually think Prems should be non-rolling but if they're going to have rolling then preseason should be changed to match.