Post history

History for Smoodiver

Grading Games & Honest Discussions

Back to topic

Current version

Posted June 26, 2014 01:06 · last edited June 26, 2014 01:10

Crespo9 wrote:

Along the lines of what Feverish said. If clubs ranked their teams better then mis matches in lower grades would be less likely to happen.

Not true. Wests 3rds had been smashing other sides for years by 10 goal margins, but were probably never as good as their reserve side at any stage. Therefore they have been correctly ranked the whole time. They asked to move up, and I recall other sides in their leagues supporting this as well. CF however didn't move them. So it's taken about 5 years of hidings to get to the grade they asked to be moved to.

Previous versions

2 versions
Smoodiver edited June 26, 2014 01:10
Crespo9 wrote:

Along the lines of what Feverish said. If clubs ranked their teams better then mis matches in lower grades would be less likely to happen.

Not true. Wests 3rds had been smashing other sides for years by 10 goal margins, but were probably never as good as their reserve side at any stage. Therefore they have been correctly ranked the whole time. They asked to move up, and I recall other sides supporting this as well. CF however didn't move them. So it's taken about 5 years of hidings to get to the grade they asked to be moved to.

Smoodiver edited June 26, 2014 01:09
Crespo9 wrote:

Along the lines of what Feverish said. If clubs ranked their teams better then mis matches in lower grades would be less likely to happen.

Not true. Wests 3rds had been smashing other sides for years by 10 goal margins, but were probably never as good as their reserve side. At any stage. Therefore they have been correctly ranked the whole time. They asked to move up, and I recall other sides supporting this as well. CF however didn't move them. So it's taken about 5 years of hidings to get to the grade they asked to be moved to.