Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
over 17 years

sucks to be in the group of death

Listen here Fudgeface
3.7K
·
15K
·
over 14 years

shame no Wellington United there.

the other top wellington clubs are all there bar this one that has a long history of Youth coming though to top level.

All the Wellington United kids are either playing ASB Youth League or will be playing  ASB Prem.

No offence to the Napier tournament, but playing national league is a much better idea than a nothing tournament held over a weekend.

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
almost 15 years

I would not say it's a nothing tournament, just that there is a league (and let's be honest NYL is rubbish) that is better

Trialist
89
·
140
·
almost 13 years

The top four teams from Wellington seem to be Wests, Karori, Petone and Lower Hutt.

They are all in different groups and have a good chance of progressing to the quarters.

Hopefully the weather doesn't get too nasty up there.

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
over 17 years

patrick478 wrote:

shame no Wellington United there.

the other top wellington clubs are all there bar this one that has a long history of Youth coming though to top level.

All the Wellington United kids are either playing ASB Youth League or will be playing  ASB Prem.

No offence to the Napier tournament, but playing national league is a much better idea than a nothing tournament held over a weekend.

showing your greenness calling Napier a nothing tournament

Listen here Fudgeface
3.7K
·
15K
·
over 14 years

Feverish wrote:

patrick478 wrote:

shame no Wellington United there.

the other top wellington clubs are all there bar this one that has a long history of Youth coming though to top level.

All the Wellington United kids are either playing ASB Youth League or will be playing  ASB Prem.

No offence to the Napier tournament, but playing national league is a much better idea than a nothing tournament held over a weekend.

showing your greenness calling Napier a nothing tournament

Fair call. I'll retract that statement but stand by my comments about Wellington United.
Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
over 17 years

Reportsare wrote:

The top four teams from Wellington seem to be Wests, Karori, Petone and Lower Hutt.

They are all in different groups and have a good chance of progressing to the quarters.

Hopefully the weather doesn't get too nasty up there.

depends what sort of Wests team is going given the Ole philosophy of not actually wanting to win football games. Wharf are in the group of death. Petone aren't that flash - so LH might be the favs to push through - especially when they can rest their whole team v UH :)

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
over 17 years
patrick478 wrote:
Feverish wrote:
patrick478 wrote:

shame no Wellington United there.

the other top wellington clubs are all there bar this one that has a long history of Youth coming though to top level.

All the Wellington United kids are either playing ASB Youth League or will be playing  ASB Prem.

No offence to the Napier tournament, but playing national league is a much better idea than a nothing tournament held over a weekend.

showing your greenness calling Napier a nothing tournament

Fair call. I'll retract that statement but stand by my comments about Wellington United.

most of the Lower Hutt team (for example) do both. 

WeeNix
43
·
640
·
almost 13 years

There are no N.Y.L games this week

Trialist
15
·
94
·
over 10 years

Feverish wrote:

Reportsare wrote:

The top four teams from Wellington seem to be Wests, Karori, Petone and Lower Hutt.

They are all in different groups and have a good chance of progressing to the quarters.

Hopefully the weather doesn't get too nasty up there.

depends what sort of Wests team is going given the Ole philosophy of not actually wanting to win football games. Wharf are in the group of death. Petone aren't that flash - so LH might be the favs to push through - especially when they can rest their whole team v UH :)

Don't think many of the 'good' kids from Ole are going as these tournaments only produce injury according to Edge, so Wests could be weak but they do have tawa in their group who aren't very good

Phoenix Academy
170
·
290
·
about 11 years

It's not going to be the greatest start to the Tournament weather wise.   Has been raining steadily since about 6am and no signs of it easing off for the next hour or so.

Not much fun lying in bed listening to the rain and thinking "oh $%^#@!"

WeeNix
43
·
640
·
almost 13 years

Oratia 2.1 Bays

Petone 3.0 Mirramar

Birkenhead 5 .0 Island Bay.

Phoenix Academy
170
·
290
·
about 11 years

Results on http://www.cityrovers.co.nz/

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
over 17 years
Phoenix Academy
65
·
270
·
almost 16 years

Why is there a bye in Group G? Did someone pull out at the last minute?

Phoenix Academy
170
·
290
·
about 11 years
Phoenix Academy
65
·
270
·
almost 16 years

ol'sole wrote:

Yes

Which team?

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
over 17 years

would have been an interesting convo. Think I can guess how it went. Lots of arm waving from DE

Listen here Fudgeface
3.7K
·
15K
·
over 14 years

Feverish wrote:

would have been an interesting convo. Think I can guess how it went. Lots of arm waving from DE

If it was anything like Edge and Calcott a couple of weeks back at NYL Tee Dubs game, it would have been very entertaining.

Split Personalities
57
·
520
·
over 10 years

NiceToMichu wrote:

Feverish wrote:

Reportsare wrote:

The top four teams from Wellington seem to be Wests, Karori, Petone and Lower Hutt.

They are all in different groups and have a good chance of progressing to the quarters.

Hopefully the weather doesn't get too nasty up there.

depends what sort of Wests team is going given the Ole philosophy of not actually wanting to win football games. Wharf are in the group of death. Petone aren't that flash - so LH might be the favs to push through - especially when they can rest their whole team v UH :)

Don't think many of the 'good' kids from Ole are going as these tournaments only produce injury according to Edge, so Wests could be weak but they do have tawa in their group who aren't very good

if this is true why go at all????

Split Personalities
57
·
520
·
over 10 years

ol'sole wrote:

It's not going to be the greatest start to the Tournament weather wise.   Has been raining steadily since about 6am and no signs of it easing off for the next hour or so.

Not much fun lying in bed listening to the rain and thinking "oh $%^#@!"

soft grounds could be a blessing as some years it has been hard grounds and lots of injuries…

Legend
2.5K
·
17K
·
over 17 years

Birko in to the semis for the 6th straight year. Pretty remarkable record, can't think of any other club that can go close to matching that in recent years. If they beat Waitak tomorrow it will be 5 finals in 6 years as well.

Starting XI
900
·
2.5K
·
over 12 years

Buffon II wrote:

Birko in to the semis for the 6th straight year. Pretty remarkable record, can't think of any other club that can go close to matching that in recent years. If they beat Waitak tomorrow it will be 5 finals in 6 years as well.

I wondered when you would chime in, regardless it is an amazingly consistent record. 

First Team Squad
13
·
1.7K
·
about 17 years

chopah wrote:

Buffon II wrote:

Birko in to the semis for the 6th straight year. Pretty remarkable record, can't think of any other club that can go close to matching that in recent years. If they beat Waitak tomorrow it will be 5 finals in 6 years as well.

I wondered when you would chime in, regardless it is an amazingly consistent record. 



Without being from that end of the country - is Birko a massive junior club with the sheer volume of players creating success at this level or do players gravitate there for other reasons?
Starting XI
900
·
2.5K
·
over 12 years

gings wrote:

chopah wrote:

Buffon II wrote:

Birko in to the semis for the 6th straight year. Pretty remarkable record, can't think of any other club that can go close to matching that in recent years. If they beat Waitak tomorrow it will be 5 finals in 6 years as well.

I wondered when you would chime in, regardless it is an amazingly consistent record. 

Without being from that end of the country - is Birko a massive junior club with the sheer volume of players creating success at this level or do players gravitate there for other reasons?

I would say it's more about their programs than sheer volume. I don't know their exact numbers but certainly not one of the biggest clubs in Auckland

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
over 17 years

patrick478 wrote:

Feverish wrote:

would have been an interesting convo. Think I can guess how it went. Lots of arm waving from DE

If it was anything like Edge and Calcott a couple of weeks back at NYL Tee Dubs game, it would have been very entertaining.

He didn't go up there to watch Wests - just to slag off anything or anyone that isnt Ole

Starting XI
300
·
4K
·
about 17 years

Birko win 1-0 And Manurewa won 5-4 on pens

Trialist
15
·
94
·
over 10 years

The two best teams from the group stages making it to the final was good to see. Springs and Birkenhead dominated the whole way through their groups and contested a very tight and close final. Birkenhead's record is amazing in the last 6 years. Not an easy tourney to go back to back in and playing in 5 of the last 6 finals is crazy

Legend
2.5K
·
17K
·
over 17 years

Birko have an unreal record from 2010-2015. 3 championships, 5 finals, 6 semis. One group stage loss in 30 matches (vs Hamilton in 2013). Unbeaten in 16 matches and counting now.

I know Birko have had some very strong squads in those years which always puts them among the favourites but to maintain that level year in year out when there is always a few decent sides from both Auckland and Welly any given year is pretty impressive.

Lots of credit has to go to Hobbo for that tbf.

Trialist
11
·
53
·
almost 11 years

Birko certainly not one of the biggest clubs around.  Current membership  is just over 1000 i think.  And yes people do gravitate there - Hobbos track record at the tournaments is one of the main reasons.

Trialist
15
·
94
·
over 10 years

Has any team ever done the three-peat?

Phoenix Academy
39
·
230
·
over 10 years

Congrats Birko on the repeat, 3peat in 2016?

Starting XI
1.3K
·
2.8K
·
about 9 years

NiceToMichu wrote:

Has any team ever done the three-peat?

No, Miramar came closest winning in 1988 & 89 but lost to Mt Wellington in 1990

here is list of champions

Trialist
20
·
66
·
over 11 years

bun1 wrote:

ol'sole wrote:

Yes

Which team?

Havelock North pulled out around a month ago. Confirmed that no replacement would be found last week.

Onehunga defaulted all their games too. However, competition operators didn't feel the need to tell the other teams in the group as they still played with ineligible players - just got no result.

NW/Satellite the door mat here

Legend
2.5K
·
17K
·
over 17 years

Tournament team is weird this year. Only one from each team and satellite players included. Any tournament team with Thompson Nkoy in it has something wrong with it.

WeeNix
43
·
640
·
almost 13 years

It's always pretty weird but to put the satellite players in there is a bit of a joke......

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
almost 15 years

Why? Just cause the team is at a lower tier, does not mean there is the opportunity for stand out players. 

In the years that the Phoenix came last, were all their players shark?

Phoenix Academy
24
·
240
·
over 14 years

Jeff Vader wrote:

Why? Just cause the team is at a lower tier, does not mean there is the opportunity for stand out players. 

In the years that the Phoenix came last, were all their players shark?

BIG difference in quality between some of the satellite teams and teams in the main draw. 

Make more sense to have a separate satellite 'Team of Tournament'.

WeeNix
130
·
810
·
over 16 years

Where is the list of players selected in tournament team?

Phoenix Academy
24
·
240
·
over 14 years

http://www.cityrovers.co.nz/

'Under 19 Tournament'

'2015 Winners'

You’ll need an account to join the conversation!

Sign in Sign up