Post history

History for theprof

Sin bins?

Back to topic

Current version

Posted November 28, 2023 23:28 · last edited November 28, 2023 23:28

The enforcement of any new rule is always going to be the issue. Everytime FIFA brings a new directive to the game to protect players or remove abuse or diving etc it all comes down to how the referee interprets the ruling on the day - which leads to inconsitencies and the same angst and pain for the fans that we have now just moved to a new subject. The easiest and fairest is to take the referees out of the decision making process. Do what the NRL do, if the incident doesnt meet the red card threshhold then yellow card and put on report. Then an impartial review committee looks at the incident and assigns the appropriate penalty. Whether that's financial or a number of missed games doesnt really matter. It punsihes the player for wahtever they said or did, it doesnt ruin the game day experience for the paying fans, and hopefully you get consitent punishments handed out for simlar offences.

Previous versions

1 version
Unknown editor edited November 28, 2023 23:28
The enforcement of any new rule is always going to be the issue. Everytime FIFA brings a new dirfective to the game to protect players or remove abuse or diving etc it all comes down to how the referee interprets the ruling on the day - which leads to inconsitencies and the same angst and pain for the fans that we have now just moved to a new subject. The easiest and fairest is to take the referees out of the decision making process. Do what the NRL do, if the incident doesnt meet the red card threshhold then yellow card and put on report. Then an impartial review committee looks at the incident and assigns the appropriate penalty. Whether that's financial or a number of missed games doesnt really matter. It punsihes the player for wahtever they said or did, it doesnt ruin the game day experience for the paying fans, and hopefully you get consitent punishments handed out for simlar offences.