WSW, keeping it fresh every season
If that's what it takes to get WSW to the Grand Final year in year out, he has my vote as their coach.
Strangely enough, the same does not work for me for the Nix. I would rather have a solid established WPX squad that performs well (I am modest and say - the team gets into final top four) but does not get into GF, than have a WPX team full of newcomers every year that get to GF every year.
Says something about the need to relate to the team? I know it probably sounds woolly, and I am sure your mileage may vary. However, having guys like Siggy, on the park (with all their shortcomings) year in year out was part of that relating (and not just because Siggy is ChCh born).