Paulsen is easily good enough to start in the A-League. That's not even a question in the slightest. We should focus on bringing in a backup rather than stunting the growth of likely the greatest goalkeeping prospect New Zealand has ever seen - zero hyperbole. Would much rather he leave if he's not guaranteed the starting role
Can't say I agree. I think he's alright and has potential, but not starting-level quality. I think his height is actually a factor too, he's quite small for a goalkeeper. But hopefully he goes through a bit of a growth spurt.
2. He was hands down the best domestic keeper in New Zealand at 18 years old
3. He was extremely impressive in the pro games he played this season
He’s definitely not on the same level as Sail yet but he’s way better than some of the keepers (e.g. Italiano, Velaphi, Smith, late career Moss) that we’ve had in recent years
All of this. He's definitely taller than listed, too. I'd guess 6'1", even discounting the hair. I'd say he's a top 10 goalkeeper in the league - comfortably in the top 15. Better than guys like Glover, Duncan, Heward-Belle, either of Victory or Roar's keepers, maybe Margush, etc etc.
Sail's meteoric, no doubt about that - it'll take some time for Paulsen to reach his level. However, if it becomes a tossup between blooding our one-of-a-kind young talent or taking a punt on an experienced Aussie being better than him, I know what option I'm taking.