Post history

History for JonoNewton

Contracted Players - Return of the Long Pins

Back to topic

Current version

Posted August 03, 2014 22:52 · last edited August 03, 2014 22:55

mjp2 wrote:

valeo wrote:

To be fair, it kind of balances out considering we can sign kiwis and aussies as locals and no one else can.

just a quick squiz at population bases

Melbourne (4.1m), Sydney(4.6m), Brisbane(2m), Perth( 1.7m), Adelaide(1.2m) populations; amongst 7 teams = 1.94m per team

vs NZ (4.43m)

but hey, they nicked Smeltz, Rojas, Roux, Barbarouses

and they have a full Youth League and three more players

nah, you are not being fair

Mariners (?) and Newcastle (0.55m) I can maybe feel sorry for

Besides, this is football, who said it had to be fair?  Ask the bottom half of the EPL. And everybody that bid against Quatar as a WC venue.  

Go Ernie.

How about this

Queensland = 4.7m/1 team = 4.7m per team

NZ = 4.4m/1 = 4.4m

Victoria = 5.8m/2 = 2.9m

WA = 2.5m/1 = 2.5m

Australia = 22.7m/9 = 2.5m

NSW = 7.4m/4 = 1.85m

SA = 1.7m/1 = 1.7m

Man no wonder Brisbane Roar are storming the league ;-) If you want to use NZ's full population you have to at least use the whole state for the Australian teams. Just using the City Populations then you should do the same for Phoenix and have just Wellington = 200,000 (Deliberately excluding Porirua & Hutt Valley)

Previous versions

3 versions
JonoNewton edited August 03, 2014 22:55
mjp2 wrote:
valeo wrote:

To be fair, it kind of balances out considering we can sign kiwis and aussies as locals and no one else can.

just a quick squiz at population bases

Melbourne (4.1m), Sydney(4.6m), Brisbane(2m), Perth( 1.7m), Adelaide(1.2m) populations; amongst 7 teams = 1.94m per team

vs NZ (4.43m)

but hey, they nicked Smeltz, Rojas, Roux, Barbarouses

and they have a full Youth League and three more players

nah, you are not being fair

Mariners (?) and Newcastle (0.55m) I can maybe feel sorry for

Besides, this is football, who said it had to be fair?  Ask the bottom half of the EPL. And everybody that bid against Quatar as a WC venue.  

Go Ernie.

How about this

Queensland = 4.7m/1 team = 4.7m per team

NZ = 4.4m/1 = 4.4m

Victoria = 5.8m/2 = 2.9m

WA = 2.5m/1 = 2.5m

Australia = 22.7m/9 = 2.5m

NSW = 7.4m/4 = 1.85m

SA = 1.7m/1 = 1.7m

Man now wonder Brisbane Roar are storming the league ;-) If you want to use NZ's full population you have to at least use the whole state for the Australian teams. Just using the City Populations then you should do the same for Phoenix and have just Wellington = 200,000 (Deliberately excluding Porirua & Hutt Valley)

JonoNewton edited August 03, 2014 22:55
mjp2 wrote:
valeo wrote:

To be fair, it kind of balances out considering we can sign kiwis and aussies as locals and no one else can.

just a quick squiz at population bases

Melbourne (4.1m), Sydney(4.6m), Brisbane(2m), Perth( 1.7m), Adelaide(1.2m) populations; amongst 7 teams = 1.94m per team

vs NZ (4.43m)

but hey, they nicked Smeltz, Rojas, Roux, Barbarouses

and they have a full Youth League and three more players

nah, you are not being fair

Mariners (?) and Newcastle (0.55m) I can maybe feel sorry for

Besides, this is football, who said it had to be fair?  Ask the bottom half of the EPL. And everybody that bid against Quatar as a WC venue.  

Go Ernie.

How about this

Queensland = 4.7m/1 team = 4.7m per team

NZ = 4.4m/1 = 4.4m

Victoria = 5.8m/2 = 2.9m

WA = 2.5m/1 = 2.5m

Australia = 22.7m/9 = 2.5m

NSW = 7.4m/4 = 1.85m

SA = 1.7m/1 = 1.7m

Man now wonder Brisbane Roar are storming the league ;-) If you want to use NZ's full population you have to at least use the whole state for the Australian teams.

JonoNewton edited August 03, 2014 22:54
mjp2 wrote:
valeo wrote:

To be fair, it kind of balances out considering we can sign kiwis and aussies as locals and no one else can.

just a quick squiz at population bases

Melbourne (4.1m), Sydney(4.6m), Brisbane(2m), Perth( 1.7m), Adelaide(1.2m) populations; amongst 7 teams = 1.94m per team

vs NZ (4.43m)

but hey, they nicked Smeltz, Rojas, Roux, Barbarouses

and they have a full Youth League and three more players

nah, you are not being fair

Mariners (?) and Newcastle (0.55m) I can maybe feel sorry for

Besides, this is football, who said it had to be fair?  Ask the bottom half of the EPL. And everybody that bid against Quatar as a WC venue.  

Go Ernie.

How about this

Queensland = 4.7m/1 team = 4.7m per team

NZ = 4.4m/1 = 4.4m

Victoria = 5.8m/2 = 2.9m

WA = 2.5m/1 = 2.5m

NSW = 7.4m/4 = 1.85m

SA = 1.7m/1 = 1.7m

Man now wonder Brisbane Roar are storming the league ;-)