Thats fine but we need someone to replace last seasons Roy not the one that was here the first season,
This is true, but last season's Roy was the best attacking player the Phoenix have ever had in 12 seasons in the A-League. He was the best attacking player (by expected goals + assists) in the entire league. They'll do well finding that anywhere.
Btw, I'm not saying they should sign Semmy – just get him in for a look, at the very least. Let Talay and Taylor be the judges. With Ball seemingly signing, who's good for 7 or 8 goals, looking at his career, they're probably still looking for a gun striker, which will hurt Semmy's chances.