I honestly can't see why we'd pick Clapham over James..
Cost is probably not a reason right now with Paul Ifill wages covered by insurance, but perhaps there is also the question if James actually wants to come and play at home right now or continue in Europe. I recall there were comments earlier that he would be free (off contract) but I do not know the current situation. Ernie would have seen James play against Mexico so there is hopefully enough material for him to go by.