Current version

Posted January 12, 2009 06:11 · last edited March 18, 2021 07:44

timmymadden wrote:
 He could set himself up well in England in Championship or even EPL if given the opportunity. I have heard the A-League compared to the Championship in terms of quality in the past, so it's not unreasonable that he be spotted... although in saying that, there's not many that have made a leap the england from the HAL.


Smeltz is nowhere near good enough for a mid-top championship side or EPL. He doesn't really have any outstanding qualities - he's a good goal poacher. Like, say, Archie Thompson - he's terrific at A-League level but anything more than that is too much.

If I was him i'd take the Turkey deal. After that is over he can come back to Aussie/NZ and probably still be quite effective as he doesn't rely on pace at all.

valeo2009-01-12 19:12:25

Previous versions

1 version
Unknown editor edited March 18, 2021 07:44
timmymadden wrote:
 He could set himself up well in England in Championship or even EPL if given the opportunity. I have heard the A-League compared to the Championship in terms of quality in the past, so it's not unreasonable that he be spotted... although in saying that, there's not many that have made a leap the england from the HAL.


Smeltz is nowhere near good enough for a mid-top championship side or EPL. He doesn't really have any outstanding qualities - he's a good goal poacher. Like, say, Archie Thompson - he's terrific at A-League level but anything more than that is too much.

If I was him i'd take the Turkey deal. After that is over he can come back to Aussie/NZ and probably still be quite effective as he doesn't rely on pace at all.

valeo2009-01-12 19:12:25