Post history

History for mjp2

PLayer ratings v WSW

Back to topic

Current version

Posted December 28, 2014 09:39 · last edited December 28, 2014 09:41

Fenton's versatility and play in midfield to finish the game, and his work getting forward says for me he is a half point better than Doyle.  And I did not think Doyle had much more than a serviceable solid game.  I'd drop Doyle a half.

Lia does some good stuff but he gifted some seriously dangerous turnovers and gets left for dead; 5.5, and bring back Alex.

Dura deserves an extra half point, he had a very tidy and organised game, particularly against some very strong tall timber. 

I thought he was a significant part of the reason we got "lucky".

Plus I think the 6's for Krishna and Burns are a bit harsh.  It didn't quite flow for them, but they were threats and busy.  6.5 for me.  Maybe without Alex, Roly wasn't quite where they expected him to be as an option.

And Moss just the 7.  Some good shot stopping and positioning, and though he managed to control the six yard box well enough against a big side it wasn't without a bit of luck.

Pleased to get away with that one, but at times we looked very good.

Previous versions

1 version
mjp2 edited December 28, 2014 09:41

Fenton's versatility and play in midfield to finish the game, and his work getting forward says for me he is a half point better than Doyle.  And I did not think Doyle had much more than a serviceable solid game.  I'd drop Doyle a half.

Lia does some good stuff but he gifted some seriously dangerous turnovers and gets left for dead; 5.5, and bring back Alex.

Dura deserves an extra half point, he had a very tidy and organised game, particularly against some very strong tall timber.

Plus I think the 6's for Krishna and Burns are a bit harsh.  It didn't quite flow for them, but they were threats and busy.  6.5 for me.  I thought he was a significant part of the reason we got "lucky".

And Moss just the 7.  Some good shot stopping and positioning, and though he managed to control the six yard box well enough against a big side it wasn't without a bit of luck.

Pleased to get away with that one, but at times we looked very good.