Post history

History for mjp2

Players RATINGS v tiger moths

Back to topic

Current version

Posted November 18, 2012 07:46 · last edited November 18, 2012 07:50

2ndBest wrote:

mjp2 wrote:

I presume Stein was unavailable (?), in which case I'm not sure how much we can give Ricki credit for the tactics and formation change - pretty much forced on him.  May be unfair to jump to that conclusion, but I wonder.


That is a very unfair thing to say.

Nah mate, just not tribal love festing, and as i said, I wonder.
He's failed to make that change in two games when it would have made a difference
I guess he could have played Ifill and Brockie up front, and Fenton and Totori wide, or Boyd and Brockie up front, but hardly likely
and he's been reluctant to make changes in the past until it's been forced on him
so I think there is good reason to ask the question, would Ricki have done this if Stein was available?
(and, as I asked, I presume Stein was not)
no big deal, but i think it's a valid question and not unfair at all
but, as I said, it WOULD be unfair to jump to the conclusion that Ricki definately wouldn't have made the change if Stein was available
I'd like to think Ricki was proactive on this one, but there are plenty of reasons to have some doubts about that

Previous versions

1 version
mjp2 edited November 18, 2012 07:50
2ndBest wrote:
mjp2 wrote:

I presume Stein was unavailable (?), in which case I'm not sure how much we can give Ricki credit for the tactics and formation change - pretty much forced on him.  May be unfair to jump to that conclusion, but I wonder.


That is a very unfair thing to say.

Nah mate, just not tribal love festing, and as i said, I wonder.
He's failed to make that change in two games when it would have made a difference
I guess he could have played Ifill and Brockie up front, and Fenton and Totori wide, or Boyd and Brockie up front, but hardly likely
and he's been reluctant to make changes in the past until it's been forced on him
so I think there is good reason to ask the question, would Ricki have done this if Stein was available?
(and, as I asked, I presume Stein was not)
no big deal, but i think it's a valid question and not unfair at all