Post history

History for YoungHeartHM

R2 vs Sydney FC | Sun 20th Oct | 8:00pm | SS7

Back to topic

Current version

Posted October 20, 2019 09:48 · last edited October 20, 2019 09:51

aitkenmike wrote:

YoungHeart wrote:

james dean wrote:

YoungHeart wrote:

martinb wrote:

so the ref waves play on and you lie on the ground you get a VAR check...ffs

And then a replay comes on in the ground, people see it, start booing and then it becomes a VAR check...

Not debating the red card, but if we're living in a VAR influenced world. Surely replays in grounds shouldn't come up on the big screens to influence decisions before they're made by the guy with all the camera angles at his disposal...

Come on var worked exactly as its supposed to. Bad on field decision over turned after a clear mistake on a major decision 

You're missing the point. Read again, and then try again.

Right, OK, you don't think replays should be shown at the grounds before a decision is made.  I disagree completely.  Spectators pay for the experience, and it's hard enough for teams to get crowds off the cash and into the grounds without treating them like mushrooms.  It's part of officials jobs to make objective decisions and I don't think diminishing the crowds experience to coddle them is the way to go.

Fixed

Previous versions

2 versions
Unknown editor edited October 20, 2019 09:51
aitkenmike wrote:
YoungHeart wrote:
james dean wrote:
YoungHeart wrote:
martinb wrote:

so the ref waves play on and you lie on the ground you get a VAR check...ffs

And then a replay comes on in the ground, people see it, start booing and then it becomes a VAR check...

Not debating the red card, but if we're living in a VAR influenced world. Surely replays in grounds shouldn't come up on the big screens to influence decisions before they're made by the guy with all the camera angles at his disposal...

Come on var worked exactly as its supposed to. Bad on field decision over turned after a clear mistake on a major decision 

You're missing the point. Read again, and then try again.

Right, OK, you don't think replays should be shown at the grounds before a decision is mad3.  I disagree completely.  Spectators pay for the experience, and it's hard enough for teams to get crowds off the cash and into the grounds without treating them like mushrooms.  It's part of officials jobs to make objective decisions and I don't think diminishing the crowds experience to coddle them is the way to go.

Fixed

Unknown editor edited October 20, 2019 09:50
aitkenmike wrote:
YoungHeart wrote:
james dean wrote:
YoungHeart wrote:
martinb wrote:

so the ref waves play on and you lie on the ground you get a VAR check...ffs

And then a replay comes on in the ground, people see it, start booing and then it becomes a VAR check...

Not debating the red card, but if we're living in a VAR influenced world. Surely replays in grounds shouldn't come up on the big screens to influence decisions before they're made by the guy with all the camera angles at his disposal...

Come on var worked exactly as its supposed to. Bad on field decision over turned after a clear mistake on a major decision 

You're missing the point. Read again, and then try again.

Right, OK, you don't think replays should be shown at the grounds.  I disagree completely.  Spectators pay for the experience, and it's hard enough for teams to get crowds off the cash and into the grounds without treating them like mushrooms.  It's part of officials jobs to make objective decisions and I don't think diminishing the crowds experience to coddle them is the way to go.

Maybe show replays after a decision is made??