Post history

History for djtim3000

R3 vs Western Sydney Wanderers | Sat 3rd Nov | 7:35pm | Westpac Stadium

Back to topic

Current version

Posted November 05, 2018 01:43 · last edited November 05, 2018 01:43

ColeWorld wrote:

djtim3000 wrote:

AucklandPhoenix wrote:

Apart from throwing  SIngh in there which statement however is actually incorrect?

I assume you're replying to me? I thought the comment was harsh on the players I mentioned because:

Krisha is one of our most consistent players.

Fenton being useless for TW has no bearing on his performance for the Nix. He certainly isn't useless for us.

Rufer has been one of the better players across the first three games. Worse then Ridenton is subjective.

Cacace and Singh have played a handful of games sure, but look like A-League standard youngsters to me.

Well, sorry to break the news, but;

Yes, Krishna is a good player. But there is no doubt he goes quiet throughout most games, where he has little impact. The lack of quality in our team does not help this, though. However, when hes on, hes dangerous, and he does manage to turn up with a goal every now and then. But he is inconsistent - if he wasnt, he would've scored more than 4 goals last season as our primary scoring option.

Fenton is pretty useless for us. Not the best defender and can barely make a 10 yard pass. His performances for TW 100% allow us to come to the conclusion that he is not the required standard - because he barely was at a lower level of football.

Cacace IMO is barely A-League standard. Has way too many limitations to be a reliable starter... He constantly gets caught out in defence and struggles to cope with opposition attackers -  as a result, teammates have to help him and this ends up drawing the rest of the team out of shape. I dont believe he would be a standout in the NZFC, in fact I dont think he would even start for the top 2 or 3 teams.

Conan's already replied on Krishna, but I'd add that Krishna is nevery quiet. In the game's he has little impact up-front (where the Nix are on the back foot), you'll see him chasing down opposition players deep into our half to try and get the ball back.


Also Fenton and Cacace are decent A-League quality players and have the same limitations as almost all fullbacks in the league. Scott Galloway, Kye Rowles, Connor O'Toole, Jack Clisby are just a few starting FB's that would be the same level. If Cacace wasn't a reliable starter at this level, I don't think you'd see a former A-League winner and our coach starting him in the first three games of the season.

Previous versions

1 version
Unknown editor edited November 05, 2018 01:43
ColeWorld wrote:
djtim3000 wrote:
AucklandPhoenix wrote:

Apart from throwing  SIngh in there which statement however is actually incorrect?

I assume you're replying to me? I thought the comment was harsh on the players I mentioned because:

Krisha is one of our most consistent players.

Fenton being useless for TW has no bearing on his performance for the Nix. He certainly isn't useless for us.

Rufer has been one of the better players across the first three games. Worse then Ridenton is subjective.

Cacace and Singh have played a handful of games sure, but look like A-League standard youngsters to me.

Well, sorry to break the news, but;

Yes, Krishna is a good player. But there is no doubt he goes quiet throughout most games, where he has little impact. The lack of quality in our team does not help this, though. However, when hes on, hes dangerous, and he does manage to turn up with a goal every now and then. But he is inconsistent - if he wasnt, he would've scored more than 4 goals last season as our primary scoring option.

Fenton is pretty useless for us. Not the best defender and can barely make a 10 yard pass. His performances for TW 100% allow us to come to the conclusion that he is not the required standard - because he barely was at a lower level of football.

Cacace IMO is barely A-League standard. Has way too many limitations to be a reliable starter... He constantly gets caught out in defence and struggles to cope with opposition attackers -  as a result, teammates have to help him and this ends up drawing the rest of the team out of shape. I dont believe he would be a standout in the NZFC, in fact I dont think he would even start for the top 2 or 3 teams.

Conan's already replied on Krishna, but I'd add that Krishna is nevery quiet. In the game's he has little impact (where the Nix are on the back foot), you'll see him chasing down opposition players deep into our half to try and get the ball back.


Also Fenton and Cacace are decent A-League quality players and have the same limitations as almost all fullbacks in the league. Scott Galloway, Kye Rowles, Connor O'Toole, Jack Clisby are just a few starting FB's that would be the same level. If Cacace wasn't a reliable starter at this level, I don't think you'd see a former A-League winner and our coach starting him in the first three games of the season.