Current version

Posted November 27, 2017 02:27 · last edited November 27, 2017 02:27

james dean wrote:

Nelfoos wrote:

Jeff Vader wrote:

Nelfoos wrote:

For a bit of context, we won our last game before CCM and scored 5 goals. So much here is a complete overreaction, how about we wait and see how Kalezic and the team bounce back from his first bad loss before we write everyone off wholesale?

You are correct, but you can't deny that he has personnel problems now.

Can't I? Finkler was absolutely outstanding against Perth, but now he's a donkey cos our holding midfielders did fudge all against CCM? I don't think he should start though. Hamish Watson is an issue I agree, but not sure who else we could have instead - ACFC players don't want to come here and there's not really anyone else in the ISPS Handy that I'm falling over myself to sign instead. Like, its Hoyle or Kilkolly? Anyone I'm missing?

From watching that performance I can't help but think that the reason we struggled so much was due to a lack of movement in midfield. Any time the CBs or Italiano had the ball there was no movement and CCM were easily able to mark them out of the game. Add the fact that all of the ball movement was at a snails pace and the CCM midfield must have thought Christmas had come early, and I think it is largely on Dura and Italiano.

That, for me, is the first discouraging performance this year. I'm not ready to throw in the towel and burn my membership just yet.

Don't agree with that, I think he has had very little influence on games this season.  

Newcastle away was absolutely hopeless as well... 

Newcastle wasn't great but I'm giving us the benefit of the doubt given the Jets are arguably the best team in the league right now bar Sydney.

He's been hit and miss, but he was great vs Perth and he's only started 3 games so far, so 1 great performance, 1 average one (Newcastle) and 1 where he got fudge all ball (CCM) aren't enough for me to write him off.

Obviously there's some knees around here that jerk quicker than mine though.

Previous versions

2 versions
Unknown editor edited November 27, 2017 02:27
james dean wrote:
Nelfoos wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:
Nelfoos wrote:

For a bit of context, we won our last game before CCM and scored 5 goals. So much here is a complete overreaction, how about we wait and see how Kalezic and the team bounce back from his first bad loss before we write everyone off wholesale?

You are correct, but you can't deny that he has personnel problems now.
Can't I? Finkler was absolutely outstanding against Perth, but now he's a donkey cos our holding midfielders did fudge all against CCM? I don't think he should start though. Hamish Watson is an issue I agree, but not sure who else we could have instead - ACFC players don't want to come here and there's not really anyone else in the ISPS Handy that I'm falling over myself to sign instead. Like, its Hoyle or Kilkolly? Anyone I'm missing?

From watching that performance I can't help but think that the reason we struggled so much was due to a lack of movement in midfield. Any time the CBs or Italiano had the ball there was no movement and CCM were easily able to mark them out of the game. Add the fact that all of the ball movement was at a snails pace and the CCM midfield must have thought Christmas had come early, and I think it is largely on Dura and Italiano.

That, for me, is the first discouraging performance this year. I'm not ready to throw in the towel and burn my membership just yet.

Don't agree with that, I think he has had very little influence on games this season.  

Newcastle away was absolutely hopeless as well... 

Newcastle wasn't great but I'm giving us the benefit of the doubt given the Jets are arguably the best team in the league right now bar Sydney.

He's been hit and miss, but he was great vs Perth and he's only started 3 games so far, so 1 great performance, 1 average one (Newcastle) and 1 where he got fudge all ball (CCM) aren't enough for me to write him off.

Obviously there's some knees around here that jerk quicker than mine though.

Unknown editor edited November 27, 2017 02:27
james dean wrote:
Nelfoos wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:
Nelfoos wrote:

For a bit of context, we won our last game before CCM and scored 5 goals. So much here is a complete overreaction, how about we wait and see how Kalezic and the team bounce back from his first bad loss before we write everyone off wholesale?

You are correct, but you can't deny that he has personnel problems now.
Can't I? Finkler was absolutely outstanding against Perth, but now he's a donkey cos our holding midfielders did fudge all against CCM? I don't think he should start though. Hamish Watson is an issue I agree, but not sure who else we could have instead - ACFC players don't want to come here and there's not really anyone else in the ISPS Handy that I'm falling over myself to sign instead. Like, its Hoyle or Kilkolly? Anyone I'm missing?

From watching that performance I can't help but think that the reason we struggled so much was due to a lack of movement in midfield. Any time the CBs or Italiano had the ball there was no movement and CCM were easily able to mark them out of the game. Add the fact that all of the ball movement was at a snails pace and the CCM midfield must have thought Christmas had come early, and I think it is largely on Dura and Italiano.

That, for me, is the first discouraging performance this year. I'm not ready to throw in the towel and burn my membership just yet.

Don't agree with that, I think he has had very little influence on games this season.  

Newcastle away was absolutely hopeless as well... 

Newcastle wasn't great but I'm giving us the benefit of the doubt given the Jets are arguably the best team in the league right now bar Sydney.

He's been hit and miss, but he was great vs Perth and he's only started 3 games so far, so 1 great performance, 1 average one and 1 where he got fudge all service  cos our deeper midfielders didn't make themselves available aren't enough for me to write him off.

Obviously there's some knees around here that jerk quicker than mine though.