Post history

History for valeo

Sarpreet Singh

Back to topic

Current version

Posted June 30, 2019 22:28 · last edited June 30, 2019 22:54

theprof wrote:

Agree that it will be a very steep learning curve for him. If he does the same way as Rojas I hope he is luckier and or smarter with his future moves as Rojas has never impressed anywhere outside of the A league, aside from maybe half a season with FC Thun.

Singh is a vastly different prospect to Rojas, Singh appears waaay more grounded and less "certain" about how fabulous he is. Rojas' dad/manager probably hasn't helped his cause. I don't see singh's management making the same mistakes. Plus, for mine Singh is a much better player now than Rojas was at a similar age.

Not sure I agree; I think Rojas still seems like a pretty grounded guy, and I also think he was more consistently good at the same age as Singh. However, I also think it's easier for a younger player out wide v being a younger player basically tasked with the entire creative burden of the team. Singh has unique skills that I haven't seen much out of NZ; it really just depends on whether he can improve his major flaws too (easily bundled off the ball, very inconsistent, loses it in dangerous areas too often etc.)

Previous versions

4 versions
Unknown editor edited June 30, 2019 22:54
theprof wrote:
newzealandpower wrote:

Agree that it will be a very steep learning curve for him. If he does the same way as Rojas I hope he is luckier and or smarter with his future moves as Rojas has never impressed anywhere outside of the A league, aside from maybe half a season with FC Thun.

Singh is a vastly different prospect to Rojas, Singh appears waaay more grounded and less "certain" about how fabulous he is. Rojas' dad/manager probably hasn't helped his cause. I don't see singh's management making the same mistakes. Plus, for mine Singh is a much better player now than Rojas was at a similar age.

Not sure I agree; I think Rojas still seems like a pretty grounded guy, and I also think he was more consistently good at the same age as Singh. However, I also think it's easier for a younger player out wide v being a younger player basically tasked with the entire creative burden of the team. Singh has unique skills that I haven't seen much out of NZ; it really just depends on whether he can improve his major flaws too (easily bundled off the ball, very inconsistent, loses it in dangerous areas too often etc.)

Unknown editor edited June 30, 2019 22:54
theprof wrote:
newzealandpower wrote:

Agree that it will be a very steep learning curve for him. If he does the same way as Rojas I hope he is luckier and or smarter with his future moves as Rojas has never impressed anywhere outside of the A league, aside from maybe half a season with FC Thun.

Singh is a vastly different prospect to Rojas, Singh appears waaay more grounded and less "certain" about how fabulous he is. Rojas' dad/manager probably hasn't helped his cause. I don't see singh's management making the same mistakes. Plus, for mine Singh is a much better player now than Rojas was at a similar age.

Not sure I agree; I think Rojas still seems like a pretty grounded guy, and I also think he was more consistently good at the same age as Singh. However, I also think it's easier for a younger player out wide v being a younger player basically tasked with the entire creative burden of the team. Singh has unique skills that I haven't seen much out of NZ; it really just depends on whether he can improve his major flaws too (easily bundled off the ball, very inconsistent, loses it in dangerous areas too often etc.)

Unknown editor edited June 30, 2019 22:54
theprof wrote:
newzealandpower wrote:

Agree that it will be a very steep learning curve for him. If he does the same way as Rojas I hope he is luckier and or smarter with his future moves as Rojas has never impressed anywhere outside of the A league, aside from maybe half a season with FC Thun.

Singh is a vastly different prospect to Rojas, Singh appears waaay more grounded and less "certain" about how fabulous he is. Rojas' dad/manager probably hasn't helped his cause. I don't see singh's management making the same mistakes. Plus, for mine Singh is a much better player now than Rojas was at a similar age.

Not sure I agree; I think Rojas still seems like a pretty grounded guy, and I also think he was more consistently good at the same age as Singh. However, I also think it's easier for a younger player out wide v being a younger player basically tasked with the entire creative burden of the team. Singh has unique skills that I haven't seen much out of NZ; it really just depends on whether he can improve his major flaws too (easily bundled off the ball, very inconsistent, loses it in dangerous areas too often etc.)

Unknown editor edited June 30, 2019 22:28
theprof wrote:
newzealandpower wrote:

Agree that it will be a very steep learning curve for him. If he does the same way as Rojas I hope he is luckier and or smarter with his future moves as Rojas has never impressed anywhere outside of the A league, aside from maybe half a season with FC Thun.

Singh is a vastly different prospect to Rojas, Singh appears waaay more grounded and less "certain" about how fabulous he is. Rojas' dad/manager probably hasn't helped his cause. I don't see singh's management making the same mistakes. Plus, for mine Singh is a much better player now than Rojas was at a similar age.

Not sure I agree; I think Rojas still seems like a pretty grounded guy, and I also think he was more consistently good at the same age as Singh. However, I also think it's easier for a younger player out wide v being a younger player basically tasked with the entire creative burden of the team. Singh has unique skills that I haven't seen much out of NZ; it really just depends on whether he can improve his major flaws too (easily bundled off the ball, very inconsistent etc.)