It makes me laugh when people say Stefan was woeful in Israel. There seem a lot of experts in the Israeli football league. Did you actually watch any games? If so how did you watch them? Maybe he had a shark Defense? Personally I have seen Sail have triple the number of woeful games the Stefan did for the Nix or the All Whites and yes, they were actually watched - on sky. How did you watch your Israeli football?
For comparison with Marinovic this season: Sail this past season conceded 45 goals from 44.86 xGOT (-0.01 GPrev/90), Tzanev 51 goals from 48.76 xGOT (-0.06 GPrev/90) and Crocombe 62 goals from 53.69 xGOT (-0.15 GPrev/90). In Paulsen's small A League sample size (333 minutes in 21/22 season) he conceded 10 goals from 9.92 xGOT (-0.02 GPrev/90). For completion sake of NZ overseas keepers (except Zac Jones): Woud in the Cup last season 9 goals from 5.87 xGOT (-1.04 GPrev/90) and Sims last year 27 goals from 24.19 xGOT (-0.17 GPrev/90).
That being said, I prefer as many New Zealand players to play outside of the Phoenix as possible, so if Marinovic gets himself a gig in Europe these next couple months, that's better than having him at the Phoenix, and I say that as a guy who's always been a fan of his. Marinovic, Sail, Paulsen all playing first choice for different clubs is far more preferable than Marinovic, Sail, Paulsen at one club with one goalkeeping spot like in 20/21.