Marquee
3.3K
·
5.1K
·
about 13 years

I think while Olympic appear to have been tripped up on this, could we make take the discussion aroudn the rule to Capital Football Governance thread to continue the discussion. Rather keep this thread for the upcoming Palmerston North Marist v North Wellington game. https://www.yellowfever.co.nz/categories/regional-...

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
about 17 years

Nelfoos wrote:

Feverish wrote:

ok cool.

One thing that is needed for the rule is a managed approach from the club. Maybe make Alex aware of that. It can't 'trip you up' if you look at the CF stats. 

And the rule for Cup comp is that they can only play in one - and it has been like that for about five years after some teams were playing the same squad in both.

I'm well aware of the rules and which players are eligible for what - no one will be getting tripped up over anything (aside from Olympic). We've tracked appearances independently from Capital Football and know exactly who can play for who for the remainder of the season - it wouldn't look good for us to have eligibility issues after whinging about Miramar last season! Like I said, this rule is not a massive issue for our club this year, I was just giving an overall opinion on the 12 game rule like you asked for and providing some context, and that opinion is my personal one and not the opinion of VUWAFC or any other coach at the club.

ok but with your quote below - you don't think the % rule has an effect on drop downs in the big picture?

"I can see how it would be abused but I think limiting it to 3 mitigates the unfairness of it enough that the 12 game rule has no real effect but to trip people up and lose points."

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
about 17 years

Yakcall wrote:

I think while Olympic appear to have been tripped up on this, could we make take the discussion aroudn the rule to Capital Football Governance thread to continue the discussion. Rather keep this thread for the upcoming Palmerston North Marist v North Wellington game. https://www.yellowfever.co.nz/categories/regional-...

this is more important than a one sided playoff :)

Starting XI
1.3K
·
2.8K
·
about 9 years

Feverish wrote:

Yakcall wrote:

I think while Olympic appear to have been tripped up on this, could we make take the discussion aroudn the rule to Capital Football Governance thread to continue the discussion. Rather keep this thread for the upcoming Palmerston North Marist v North Wellington game. https://www.yellowfever.co.nz/categories/regional-...

this is more important than a one sided playoff :)

which should also be in the Central League thread as its a Central League playoff! :)

Starting XI
2.6K
·
2.4K
·
over 8 years

Feverish wrote:

Nelfoos wrote:

Feverish wrote:

ok cool.

One thing that is needed for the rule is a managed approach from the club. Maybe make Alex aware of that. It can't 'trip you up' if you look at the CF stats. 

And the rule for Cup comp is that they can only play in one - and it has been like that for about five years after some teams were playing the same squad in both.

I'm well aware of the rules and which players are eligible for what - no one will be getting tripped up over anything (aside from Olympic). We've tracked appearances independently from Capital Football and know exactly who can play for who for the remainder of the season - it wouldn't look good for us to have eligibility issues after whinging about Miramar last season! Like I said, this rule is not a massive issue for our club this year, I was just giving an overall opinion on the 12 game rule like you asked for and providing some context, and that opinion is my personal one and not the opinion of VUWAFC or any other coach at the club.

ok but with your quote below - you don't think the % rule has an effect on drop downs in the big picture?

"I can see how it would be abused but I think limiting it to 3 mitigates the unfairness of it enough that the 12 game rule has no real effect but to trip people up and lose points."

Edit: Moved to other thread
Marquee
3.3K
·
5.1K
·
about 13 years

Nelfoos wrote:

Feverish wrote:

Nelfoos wrote:

Feverish wrote:

ok cool.

One thing that is needed for the rule is a managed approach from the club. Maybe make Alex aware of that. It can't 'trip you up' if you look at the CF stats. 

And the rule for Cup comp is that they can only play in one - and it has been like that for about five years after some teams were playing the same squad in both.

I'm well aware of the rules and which players are eligible for what - no one will be getting tripped up over anything (aside from Olympic). We've tracked appearances independently from Capital Football and know exactly who can play for who for the remainder of the season - it wouldn't look good for us to have eligibility issues after whinging about Miramar last season! Like I said, this rule is not a massive issue for our club this year, I was just giving an overall opinion on the 12 game rule like you asked for and providing some context, and that opinion is my personal one and not the opinion of VUWAFC or any other coach at the club.

ok but with your quote below - you don't think the % rule has an effect on drop downs in the big picture?

"I can see how it would be abused but I think limiting it to 3 mitigates the unfairness of it enough that the 12 game rule has no real effect but to trip people up and lose points."

Yakcall - can you move the comments? I dunno how to quote stuff from a different thread.

I think it definitely has an effect, however, I also think the rule could be vastly improved to allow for more flexibility in clubs while still preventing the abuse of the ability to drop players down.

Best I can do is this https://www.yellowfever.co.nz/categories/regional-...

Funny enough just above what I posted is the discussion happening last time.

Feverish, still prefer not to flood this thread with rule discussion but you are correct the play off stuff will probably happen in the Central League thread.

Trialist
20
·
140
·
over 14 years

So you agree PNM will romp in?

Starting XI
490
·
2.1K
·
over 14 years

North Wellington win promotion to the central league, so Olympic safe from relegation.

Trialist
2
·
58
·
about 6 years

My Pics for tomorrows match ups

Wainuiomata

WIN

2:30pm | 30/3/19

vs

Richard Prouse 1

Parapine ITM Upper Hutt City Football
Kapiti Coast Utd

2:30pm | 30/3/19

vs

Weka Park 1

Victoria University Men's Firsts

WIN
Advance Electrical Western Suburbs

2:30pm | 30/3/19

DRAW

vs

Endeavour 1

Tawa AFC
Petone FC

WIN

3:00pm | 30/3/19

Miramar Rangers
Island Bay Utd AFC

WIN

3:30pm | 30/3/19

vs

Wakefield 1 Turf

Wellington Olympic
Starting XI
1.3K
·
2.8K
·
about 9 years

I'd go

Wainui v Upper Hutt Draw

KCU v Vic Uni Draw

Wests v Tawa Tawa

Petone v Mar Petone

Island Bay v Olympic Olympic

for the season I reckon

Petone

Upper Hutt

Wainui

Tawa

Wests

Mar

Island Bay

Olympic

KCU

Vic Uni

Starting XI
2.6K
·
2.4K
·
over 8 years

I'd go

Wainui v Upper Hutt Draw

KCU v Vic Uni Draw

Wests v Tawa Tawa

Petone v Mar Petone

Island Bay v Olympic Olympic

for the season I reckon

Petone

Upper Hutt

Wainui

Tawa

Wests

Mar

Island Bay

Olympic

KCU

Vic Uni

Someone's still upset about last weeks result!

Kidding, I think Uni will have a tough year and that's not a bad shout.

Trialist
2
·
58
·
about 6 years

The Season will be very tight, From what iv watched from hilton Heres my Final outlook.

Good Luck to all clubs from this beautiful city. (WE ARE ONE!)

Wainuiomata

Petone

Upper Hutt

Wests

Tawa

Island Bay

Miramar

University

Olympic

Kapiti

Not Boyd
420
·
3.7K
·
about 16 years

Well the Wainui bandwagon was quickly de railed

Trialist
0
·
28
·
over 11 years

Round 1 Results:  30 March 2019 (from Capital Football)

Upper Hutt  def. Wainuiomata   4 - 1 

Petone       def. Miramar            4 - 2

Wests        def. Tawa                2 - 0

Island Bay  def. Olympic           3 - 1

KCU   and   Vic. Uni   drew       1 - 1

Scores a bit closer than some of those lop-sided results today in the Central League (10 - 0 and 8 - 0)

Phoenix Academy
270
·
460
·
almost 10 years

scorpio1 wrote:

Round 1 Results:  30 March 2019 (from Capital Football)

Upper Hutt  def. Wainuiomata   4 - 1 

Petone       def. Miramar            4 - 2

Wests        def. Tawa                2 - 0

Island Bay  def. Olympic           3 - 1

KCU   and   Vic. Uni   drew       1 - 1

Scores a bit closer than some of those lop-sided results today in the Central League (10 - 0 and 8 - 0)

 - Whilst I hadn't seen them pre-season. based on the chatter going around I wasn't expecting that Wanui result. They've got Petone next week which may help get an indication of wether it was just a one off bad day or where they are really at in comparison to the other tipped contenders.

 - Olympic & Miramar  as expected & may struggle not to be in bottom 4, but will always be strengthend later in the season when required by the ability to have first teamers dropping down to help. If it transpire Petone are going for the title I'm sure they'd like it sewn up before facing Olympic on the last day. 

 - KCU & Vic Uni as expected & may make up the bottom 4 with Oly/Mar.

 - Had Tawa down as a win v Wests but expect these 2 to be in the middle positions at end of season

 - Petone play some good football & I have them as favourites for the league. From what I've seen they create a lot of chances. A concern may be the conversion rate into goals isnt as high as it needs to be which can be costly in those tight games where things aren't going all your way.    

Marquee
3.3K
·
5.1K
·
about 13 years

From what I heard Wainui were in it. Wainui scored in the 56 before Upper Hutt scored to equal in the 67. They then took the lead in the 82 before the blow out of two more goals in extra time (90+). 

So seems like a case of heads down after losing the lead and leaking more. They'll have to learn from that if they want to be up the top of the league come seasons end. 

Trialist
2
·
58
·
about 6 years

I caught the second half of Wainui v Upper hutt game. Upper hutt wanted it more and it showed.

Both sides have class players but did notice a few missing from pre season games. Were both at full strength or players still to come in?

Trialist
0
·
28
·
over 11 years

Round 2, 6th April:

Miramar def Island Bay 3 - 2

Wainuiomata def Petone 2 - 1

KCU def. Wests 2 - 1

Upper Hutt def. Tawa 2 - 1

Victoria Uni. def Olympic 2 - 1

All very close games yesterday. Table topping Upper Hutt have league favourite's Petone away next week but will be without the services of Centreback Hamish Price, who received a Red Card in yesterday's game against Tawa.

Trialist
2
·
58
·
about 6 years

Watched Petone get out played by a more determined Wainui side. It shouldve have been 3 or 4 before the half.

1 of the English imports is out with a badly sprained ankle and also there top goal scorer is still out with an on going knee injury.

Kapiti is a surpise beating Wests.

Tawa were abit unlucky i heard.

Petone vs Upper hutt where il be heading nxt week!

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
about 17 years

have Wests morphed into having Black as their shirt colour?

Starting XI
280
·
2.7K
·
over 16 years

Yes. It's black with red pinstripes for almost every team in the club now.

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
about 17 years

Yes. It's black with red pinstripes for almost every team in the club now.

how come?

there is only one black team in town

Woof Woof
2.7K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

Feverish wrote:

Yes. It's black with red pinstripes for almost every team in the club now.

how come?

there is only one black team in town

Racist

Starting XI
280
·
2.7K
·
over 16 years

I think the conspiracists might suggest Olé has taken over the club so much they've just gone and changed their colours.

WeeNix
510
·
800
·
about 10 years

The original Western Suburbs played  in  blue and yellow

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
about 17 years

I think the conspiracists might suggest Olé has taken over the club so much they've just gone and changed their colours.

Will take that as fact 

Starting XI
490
·
2.1K
·
over 14 years

They'll go back to blue and  yellow next #oleswedishconspiracy.

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
about 17 years

Ikea Ole Western/Eastern Suburbs United

Starting XI
490
·
2.1K
·
over 14 years

If endeavour park clubrooms start selling meatballs, I'm in.

WeeNix
510
·
800
·
about 10 years

I see that the Ole Turnips had a 4  to 1  win over Oylmpic

Trialist
0
·
56
·
about 15 years

Anchor25 wrote:

Petone vs Upper hutt where il be heading nxt week!

Any Report?

Trialist
2
·
58
·
about 6 years

It was a very high tempo game, both sides had their chances. I think Petone are in need of a decent striker.

Jock is a great signing for Upper Hutt, he still has it!! coach foster is doing well.

looking foward to easter weekend! Can Upper hutt continue the run of form?

Trialist
1
·
15
·
about 5 years

There are a few good strikers from round the league that could make the switch from what ive seen, Petone to scout locally?

Looks like upper hutt couldnt continue their rich run of form unfortunately

Trialist
0
·
28
·
over 11 years

Watched Upper Hutt play Miramar at Upper Hutt yesterday. An end to end game with lots of drama including a Red Card to a Miramar player for deliberate handball and a disallowed goal to Upper Hutt, both late in the 2nd Half. Final result was a 4 - 4 Draw after Miramar led 2 - 0 at Half Time.

Trialist
2
·
58
·
about 6 years

I Was over at Sunny Richard Prowse to watch Wainui take on the greeks!!

Talk about goal fest!! great game with quality attacking plays from both teams.

Wainui will score plenty of goals with those English lads up top, but I can see the defence costing them.

Phoenix Academy
270
·
460
·
almost 10 years

Didn't see it but seems KCU conceded the same amount of goals as they got red cards : 3 !

Trialist
10
·
43
·
about 12 years

Heard a whisper Petone have played the whole season with an unregistered/wrongly registered player. Could lose all of their points. 

Can anyone confirm this? If true they will turn into the Leeds United of the Cap Prem, just can't get out of it. 

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
about 17 years

leftfootonly wrote:

Heard a whisper Petone have played the whole season with an unregistered/wrongly registered player. Could lose all of their points. 

Can anyone confirm this? If true they will turn into the Leeds United of the Cap Prem, just can't get out of it. 

how is that possible with comet online team cards?

Trialist
10
·
43
·
about 12 years

Changing details to create a duplicate player avoiding a red flag

Marquee
3.3K
·
5.1K
·
about 13 years

leftfootonly wrote:

Changing details to create a duplicate player avoiding a red flag

Be incredible stupid if they have done that on purpose.

You’ll need an account to join the conversation!

Sign in Sign up