All Whites vs. Me-hi-co player ratings
http://www.yellowfever.co.nz/users/195
Permalink
Permalink
Moss- 7 - could've done a little better on goals, but exposed too many times. Brilliant double save
Reid - 6 - Did ok, wasn't at his best but not the worst
Vicelich - 3 - worst I've seen the Godfather play, out of place and slow to react
Boyens - 4 - Only slightly better than Ivan
Boxall - 4 - positioning off
Fitzgerald - 3 - Looked out of sorts all half
Brown - 3 - Anon
Elliot - 5 - a few decent passes, a few poor ones.
Barbarouses - 5 - looked out of depth but tried hard
Smeltz - 3 - also missing
Wood - 7 - worked hard and defended well, missed a decent chance though
------------SUBS-----------
Mulligan - 7 - Some great deliveries and got stuck in
Killen - 6 - Some classy touches
Brockie - 6 - Looked quite good
McGlinchey - 6 - Some good touches
Sigmund - 8 - Beast
Clapham - 6 - did ok
Reid - 6 - Did ok, wasn't at his best but not the worst
Vicelich - 3 - worst I've seen the Godfather play, out of place and slow to react
Boyens - 4 - Only slightly better than Ivan
Boxall - 4 - positioning off
Fitzgerald - 3 - Looked out of sorts all half
Brown - 3 - Anon
Elliot - 5 - a few decent passes, a few poor ones.
Barbarouses - 5 - looked out of depth but tried hard
Smeltz - 3 - also missing
Wood - 7 - worked hard and defended well, missed a decent chance though
------------SUBS-----------
Mulligan - 7 - Some great deliveries and got stuck in
Killen - 6 - Some classy touches
Brockie - 6 - Looked quite good
McGlinchey - 6 - Some good touches
Sigmund - 8 - Beast
Clapham - 6 - did ok
http://www.yellowfever.co.nz/users/195
Permalink
Permalink
Moss - 8.5 - amazing save and kept the scoreline from blowing up, got caught out once.
Vicelich - 4 - Only reason its not 3 or less is because he saved us from a certain goal in the 1st half
Barbarouses - 7 - Decent
Smeltz - 6
Wood - 7
Mulligan - 5
Sigmund - 7
Otherwise agree
Vicelich - 4 - Only reason its not 3 or less is because he saved us from a certain goal in the 1st half
Barbarouses - 7 - Decent
Smeltz - 6
Wood - 7
Mulligan - 5
Sigmund - 7
Otherwise agree
Permalink
Permalink
Can i add to Elliots comment
"WTF was up with THAT backpass to Moss!"
"WTF was up with THAT backpass to Moss!"
Yellow Whever Whanganui
Permalink
Permalink
Brown? Was he even there? Woeful, doesn't deserve a rating at all.
Surprised people are giving good ratings to Wood, I thought he was woeful - terrible control, always a couple of steps behind, and the one chance he got he fluffed really badly. He has to do much better if he wants to play at the level he aspires to.
Surprised people are giving good ratings to Wood, I thought he was woeful - terrible control, always a couple of steps behind, and the one chance he got he fluffed really badly. He has to do much better if he wants to play at the level he aspires to.
Permalink
Permalink
Turns out there is a worse RB than Mully in NZ.
Permalink
Permalink
I like Tim Brown but I've never seen a footballer so poor at international level.
Permalink
Permalink
I thought Fitzgerald was absolutely awful, maybe give him the benefit of the doubt because he was played out of position, but on that performance I'd give him a 2.
And Elliot a 4 instead of a 5, he deserves to drop at least one for the most awful backpass I've ever seen.
And Elliot a 4 instead of a 5, he deserves to drop at least one for the most awful backpass I've ever seen.
Permalink
Permalink
The best player on the park for us was Siggy. He was aggressive, mostly good positional and for the most part the timing of his tackles was spot on.
Permalink
Permalink
I thought Fitzgerald was absolutely awful, maybe give him the benefit of the doubt because he was played out of position, but on that performance I'd give him a 2.
I thought Fitzgeralds passing was good. He lost his footing multiple times when changing direction, I think he would have gone a lot better if he was familiar with the ground and worn the appropriate footwear. Did the NZ players even inspect the ground before playing? A lot of them had the same problem. Anyway I really like the look of him and think giving him a 2 is stupidly off the mark.
Permalink
Permalink
I thought Fitzgerald was absolutely awful, maybe give him the benefit of the doubt because he was played out of position, but on that performance I'd give him a 2.
�
I thought Fitzgeralds passing was good. He lost his footing multiple times when changing direction, I think he would have gone a lot better if he was familiar with the ground and worn the appropriate footwear. Did the NZ players even inspect the ground before playing? A lot of them had the same problem. Anyway I really like the look of him and think giving him a 2 is stupidly off the mark.
I just thought he was completely outplayed by his opposite number, the amount of times there was a mexican with acres of space was woeful
Permalink
Permalink
I thought Fitzgerald was absolutely awful, maybe give him the benefit of the doubt because he was played out of position, but on that performance I'd give him a 2.
�
I thought Fitzgeralds passing was good. He lost his footing multiple times when changing direction, I think he would have gone a lot better if he was familiar with the ground and worn the appropriate footwear. Did the NZ players even inspect the ground before playing? A lot of them had the same problem. Anyway I really like the look of him and think giving him a 2 is stupidly off the mark.
I just thought he was completely outplayed by his opposite number, the amount of times there was a mexican with acres of space was woeful
I agree with both. He was good on the ball, but was caught out of position when defending.
Probably not a system or position he is used to playing but does show some potential. Bullion2011-06-03 16:03:05
Permalink
Permalink
This game proved one thing that has probably been obvious for a while: Brown is too one dimensional for decent quality internal fixtures. Ideal vs Islands, rubbish against anyone else.
Supporter of the world's best football teams: Waikato..., Kingz FC, NZ Knights, The Nix, The Argyle & of course the All Whites
Permalink
Permalink
I thought Fitzgerald was absolutely awful, maybe give him the benefit of the doubt because he was played out of position, but on that performance I'd give him a 2.
I thought Fitzgeralds passing was good. He lost his footing multiple times when changing direction, I think he would have gone a lot better if he was familiar with the ground and worn the appropriate footwear. Did the NZ players even inspect the ground before playing? A lot of them had the same problem. Anyway I really like the look of him and think giving him a 2 is stupidly off the mark.
I just thought he was completely outplayed by his opposite number, the amount of times there was a mexican with acres of space was woeful
I agree with both. He was good on the ball, but was caught out of position when defending.
Probably not a system or position he is used to playing but does show some potential.
He's a right sided player asked to play a left wingback against a team as classy as Mexico. U agree thought his passing was good.
martinb2011-06-04 09:47:05
Permalink
Permalink