All Whites vs Solomon Islands | Fri 1 Sept | 7:30pm | QBE Stadium

Phoenix Academy
310
·
160
·
about 7 years

People are entitled to their opinion on Hudson.  I don't hate him, I just think he is not very good. He stands and falls by his record. The Hudson era stats against non Island sides are

Played 15, won 1 draw 2, goals for 9, goals against 26, 0.6 goals per match...can't score, can't defend

0.6 goals per match with a side that has a EPL striker and two wingers currently at Dutch Div 1 clubs is not good enough IMO.

The Roar said today they had recieved zero information from anyone at NZF about the fitness requirements for Ingham and they think that the whole thing was handled poorly....no info from NZF? well knock me down with a feather...LOL

Considering the past AW scores in NZ against the Solomons are 6-1, 5-1, 6-0 ???? then anything less than a 4 goal winning margin will be a disappointment

and 3 others
Starting XI
1.3K
·
2.8K
·
about 9 years

wibbler wrote:

RoriM6 wrote:

Anyone in welly going anywhere to watch it?

I'm thinking of watching it at Four Kings.

I'll be at the Four Kings as well

First Team Squad
1.2K
·
1.2K
·
over 9 years

https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/football/nz-teams/96339996/all-white-dane-ingham-arrives-back-at-brisbane-roar-after-being-deemed-unfit

Roar football director Craig Moore met with Ingham on Wednesday, and said the club would provide the shattered 18-year-old with the support he needed.

“I don’t think it was good the way the situation was handled,” Moore said.

“We were never given any guidelines by the New Zealand Football Association about the level of fitness Dane was expected to be at.”

Hudson: jump

Players: how high

Hudson: just jump

Players: *jump*

Hudson: ok, you you and you, you didn't jump high enough, you're cut

and 2 others
Woof Woof
2.7K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

Balbi wrote:

https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/football/nz-teams/96339996/all-white-dane-ingham-arrives-back-at-brisbane-roar-after-being-deemed-unfit

Roar football director Craig Moore met with Ingham on Wednesday, and said the club would provide the shattered 18-year-old with the support he needed.

“I don’t think it was good the way the situation was handled,” Moore said.

“We were never given any guidelines by the New Zealand Football Association about the level of fitness Dane was expected to be at.”

Hudson: jump

Players: how high

Hudson: just jump

Players: *jump*

Hudson: ok, you you and you, you didn't jump high enough, you're cut

The great communicator.

Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
about 17 years
First Team Squad
1.2K
·
1.2K
·
over 9 years

That was EXACTLY what I had in mine Tegal.

Woof Woof
2.7K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

el grapadura wrote:

Balbi wrote:

https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/football/nz-teams/96339996/all-white-dane-ingham-arrives-back-at-brisbane-roar-after-being-deemed-unfit

Roar football director Craig Moore met with Ingham on Wednesday, and said the club would provide the shattered 18-year-old with the support he needed.

“I don’t think it was good the way the situation was handled,” Moore said.

“We were never given any guidelines by the New Zealand Football Association about the level of fitness Dane was expected to be at.”

Hudson: jump

Players: how high

Hudson: just jump

Players: *jump*

Hudson: ok, you you and you, you didn't jump high enough, you're cut

The great communicator.

Rumour is also that Hudson's rejected a whole heap of interview requests from NZ media, and has cancelled media appearances.

Yet he still has time to do self-fluffing puff pieces with the UK media.

Listen here Fudgeface
3.7K
·
15K
·
over 14 years

el grapadura wrote:

el grapadura wrote:

Balbi wrote:

https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/football/nz-teams/96339996/all-white-dane-ingham-arrives-back-at-brisbane-roar-after-being-deemed-unfit

Roar football director Craig Moore met with Ingham on Wednesday, and said the club would provide the shattered 18-year-old with the support he needed.

“I don’t think it was good the way the situation was handled,” Moore said.

“We were never given any guidelines by the New Zealand Football Association about the level of fitness Dane was expected to be at.”

Hudson: jump

Players: how high

Hudson: just jump

Players: *jump*

Hudson: ok, you you and you, you didn't jump high enough, you're cut

The great communicator.

Rumour is also that Hudson's rejected a whole heap of interview requests from NZ media, and has cancelled media appearances.

Yet he still has time to do self-fluffing puff pieces with the UK media.

Hudson shielding himself from questions that deserve to be asked at the detriment of promoting the game on Friday.

What a guy.

First Team Squad
1.2K
·
1.2K
·
over 9 years

Cordwainer Bull with a brief history of All Whites who Hudson would have definitely sent home here...

https://in-the-back-of-the.net/2017/08/31/guest-post-dane-ingham-chewing-the-fat/

It’s hard to recall a historical precedent for Dane Ingham being expelled from the All Whites team camp this week.

While many a player has been overlooked for selection for not scrubbing up in the first place, to be flown in, kitted out and then sent packing breaks new ground and commands a special place in the relatively small Rogue’s Gallery of miscreant All Whites.

“He came in but he was unfit, his body fat was high, and we’ve given him a couple of fitness tests and he’s not where he needs to be,” All Whites coach Anthony Hudson said, in sending Ingham packing back to Brisbane, where he is either now running madly or commiserating with a dozen Castlemaine XXXX and a plate of pork scratchings.

Marquee
2.8K
·
7.3K
·
about 17 years

austin11 wrote:

People are entitled to their opinion on Hudson.  I don't hate him, I just think he is not very good. He stands and falls by his record. The Hudson era stats against non Island sides are

Played 15, won 1 draw 2, goals for 9, goals against 26, 0.6 goals per match...can't score, can't defend

0.6 goals per match with a side that has a EPL striker and two wingers currently at Dutch Div 1 clubs is not good enough IMO.

The Roar said today they had recieved zero information from anyone at NZF about the fitness requirements for Ingham and they think that the whole thing was handled poorly....no info from NZF? well knock me down with a feather...LOL

Considering the past AW scores in NZ against the Solomons are 6-1, 5-1, 6-0 ???? then anything less than a 4 goal winning margin will be a disappointment

You are SO right - couldn't have said it better myself.

I also want to add - if AH has been talking about fitness levels for so long - why has he not given his players an indication of what level they need to be at when reporting for duty? Moore says NZF didn't tell the Roar - how about the players? You'd think aside from the usual "I need you to run for 90+ minutes and never give up bla bla" - AH could give the players some tangible parameters (body fat not higher than...Beep test minimum acceptable level...100m, 200m, 400m and 800m to be completed in less than...

I was aware of where I needed to be when playing in Cap 1... and the best players in the country don't?

WeeNix
900
·
540
·
about 7 years

I find it kind of disturbing that 19 of our 20 All Whites squad have scored a combined total of 10 goals in their Entire international careers. Chris Wood has scored 20 which is double the entire All Whites team hahah 

WeeNix
900
·
540
·
about 7 years

Our second leading goalscorer is Michael Mcglinchy with 4 goals in 48 All White appearances.

Groundskeeper Willie
700
·
7.5K
·
over 16 years
But old mate Anthony has created such #depth don't come at me with stats
Life and death
2.4K
·
5.5K
·
about 17 years

austin11 wrote:

People are entitled to their opinion on Hudson.  I don't hate him, I just think he is not very good. He stands and falls by his record. The Hudson era stats against non Island sides are

Played 15, won 1 draw 2, goals for 9, goals against 26, 0.6 goals per match...can't score, can't defend

0.6 goals per match with a side that has a EPL striker and two wingers currently at Dutch Div 1 clubs is not good enough IMO.

The Roar said today they had recieved zero information from anyone at NZF about the fitness requirements for Ingham and they think that the whole thing was handled poorly....no info from NZF? well knock me down with a feather...LOL

Considering the past AW scores in NZ against the Solomons are 6-1, 5-1, 6-0 ???? then anything less than a 4 goal winning margin will be a disappointment

You are SO right - couldn't have said it better myself.

I also want to add - if AH has been talking about fitness levels for so long - why has he not given his players an indication of what level they need to be at when reporting for duty? Moore says NZF didn't tell the Roar - how about the players? You'd think aside from the usual "I need you to run for 90+ minutes and never give up bla bla" - AH could give the players some tangible parameters (body fat not higher than...Beep test minimum acceptable level...100m, 200m, 400m and 800m to be completed in less than...

I was aware of where I needed to be when playing in Cap 1... and the best players in the country don't?

Who is to say they didn't know? It would be very strange if they didn't.
Opinion Privileges revoked
4.9K
·
9.9K
·
over 14 years

james dean wrote:

Yeah but you said that people would still be saying sack him if we got through the group stages of the World Cup which is just fanciful

Fanciful? Possibly, possibly hyperbole. But we're in a situation where people assume the worst of Hudson from default. We've got people assuming he sent Ingham home to get his excuses in in advance for losing tomorrow; others who assume that NZF "shut down" his interview quickly to shield him from criticism when they in fact did no such thing. Some even hate him for his English accent which he can't help. Give a dog a bad name and you can hang him. Assign a dedicated scapegoat and he'll never shirk the tag.

In case there's any disagreement, I am radically neutral on Hudson. I think he's clearly angling for a big British job and is mainly concerned with making himself look good, but I'll reserve judgement until after the intercontinental playoff to join the hate.

Opinion Privileges revoked
4.9K
·
9.9K
·
over 14 years

2ndBest wrote:

BUT THE HARBOUR BRIDGE

Come on the goddamn Northern Express bus, guys. It's efficient, it's got its own busway AND cool double-deckers so you can watch the sunset from high over the bridge. SOME Aucklanders can't imagine going anywhere on public transport and those are the ones who give the rest of us a bad name.

Woof Woof
2.7K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

Doloras wrote:

james dean wrote:


Yeah but you said that people would still be saying sack him if we got through the group stages of the World Cup which is just fanciful

We've got people assuming he sent Ingham home to get his excuses in in advance for losing tomorrow; others who assume that NZF "shut down" his interview quickly to shield him from criticism when they in fact did no such thing.

1. No-one's saying he's creating an excuse for the Solomons game with the Ingham thing - rather that he's been creating a narrative that his far from stellar record here is not his fault, but a result of unprofessional environment and general shamblessness of NZF (some of which, coincidentally, is probably correct). What irks people is that he excels at self-fluffery. If he showed a degree a personal accountability in all this, I suspect most would be a lot more accepting of him.

2. No-one ever said NZF 'shut him down'. In fact it was Hudson who shut down the media appearances, much to NZF's despair (as they're obviously wanting to promote the game on Friday).

Opinion Privileges revoked
4.9K
·
9.9K
·
over 14 years

Anyway, I suggest we move the Anfony bashing into the thread designed for that, and return to important matters.

Are we at that same fancy pub in the mall pre-game? The one with Rekorderlig on tap?

Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
about 17 years

Doloras wrote:

Anyway, I suggest we move the Anfony bashing into the thread designed for that, and return to important matters.

Are we at that same fancy pub in the mall pre-game? The one with Rekorderlig on tap?

Mods, take control 

Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
almost 13 years

CactusJones wrote:
Burgess seems to hate New Zealand Football. He's always writing negative stories. This is a lot more professional than a boys club that Herbert held. Fielding Lochhead and Christie against Mexico had me done. Sending Ingham home was right imo. If he's not fit, why have him?
Is playing Lochhead and Christie vs Mexico that much worse than some of Hudson's selection decisions?
Marquee
1.2K
·
8.2K
·
almost 17 years

Balbi wrote:

Cordwainer Bull with a brief history of All Whites who Hudson would have definitely sent home here...

https://in-the-back-of-the.net/2017/08/31/guest-post-dane-ingham-chewing-the-fat/

It’s hard to recall a historical precedent for Dane Ingham being expelled from the All Whites team camp this week.

While many a player has been overlooked for selection for not scrubbing up in the first place, to be flown in, kitted out and then sent packing breaks new ground and commands a special place in the relatively small Rogue’s Gallery of miscreant All Whites.

“He came in but he was unfit, his body fat was high, and we’ve given him a couple of fitness tests and he’s not where he needs to be,” All Whites coach Anthony Hudson said, in sending Ingham packing back to Brisbane, where he is either now running madly or commiserating with a dozen Castlemaine XXXX and a plate of pork scratchings.

Surprised Chris James isn't mentioned, didn't he miss out on the Bahrain games and 2010 WC as a result of turning up unfit to the 2009 Confeds?
Marquee
2.8K
·
7.3K
·
about 17 years

austin11 wrote:

People are entitled to their opinion on Hudson.  I don't hate him, I just think he is not very good. He stands and falls by his record. The Hudson era stats against non Island sides are

Played 15, won 1 draw 2, goals for 9, goals against 26, 0.6 goals per match...can't score, can't defend

0.6 goals per match with a side that has a EPL striker and two wingers currently at Dutch Div 1 clubs is not good enough IMO.

The Roar said today they had recieved zero information from anyone at NZF about the fitness requirements for Ingham and they think that the whole thing was handled poorly....no info from NZF? well knock me down with a feather...LOL

Considering the past AW scores in NZ against the Solomons are 6-1, 5-1, 6-0 ???? then anything less than a 4 goal winning margin will be a disappointment

You are SO right - couldn't have said it better myself.

I also want to add - if AH has been talking about fitness levels for so long - why has he not given his players an indication of what level they need to be at when reporting for duty? Moore says NZF didn't tell the Roar - how about the players? You'd think aside from the usual "I need you to run for 90+ minutes and never give up bla bla" - AH could give the players some tangible parameters (body fat not higher than...Beep test minimum acceptable level...100m, 200m, 400m and 800m to be completed in less than...

I was aware of where I needed to be when playing in Cap 1... and the best players in the country don't?

Who is to say they didn't know? It would be very strange if they didn't.

I didn't read anywhere that the players knew any specifics (other than AH saying they needed to be 'fit'). If Craig Moore says NZF didn't give the Roar any direction, I wonder if the players were given some - more detailed - instructions regarding the acceptable level of fitness required.

Also beats me how a kid who is going through pre-season and playing minutes can be fitter than [awesome] old, injured Durante.

Early retirement
3.1K
·
34K
·
over 17 years

90 minutes plus a late, late goal from Tuiloma today.  imagine what he could do if he was fit...

First Team Squad
1.2K
·
1.6K
·
almost 15 years

Hard News wrote:

90 minutes plus a late, late goal from Tuiloma today.  imagine what he could do if he was fit...

Play for the first team?

Early retirement
3.1K
·
34K
·
over 17 years

USL.  Relevance?

First Team Squad
280
·
1.6K
·
about 12 years

I know there's an election campaign on.......  Lets Go All Whites

Life and death
2.4K
·
5.5K
·
about 17 years

austin11 wrote:

People are entitled to their opinion on Hudson.  I don't hate him, I just think he is not very good. He stands and falls by his record. The Hudson era stats against non Island sides are

Played 15, won 1 draw 2, goals for 9, goals against 26, 0.6 goals per match...can't score, can't defend

0.6 goals per match with a side that has a EPL striker and two wingers currently at Dutch Div 1 clubs is not good enough IMO.

The Roar said today they had recieved zero information from anyone at NZF about the fitness requirements for Ingham and they think that the whole thing was handled poorly....no info from NZF? well knock me down with a feather...LOL

Considering the past AW scores in NZ against the Solomons are 6-1, 5-1, 6-0 ???? then anything less than a 4 goal winning margin will be a disappointment

You are SO right - couldn't have said it better myself.

I also want to add - if AH has been talking about fitness levels for so long - why has he not given his players an indication of what level they need to be at when reporting for duty? Moore says NZF didn't tell the Roar - how about the players? You'd think aside from the usual "I need you to run for 90+ minutes and never give up bla bla" - AH could give the players some tangible parameters (body fat not higher than...Beep test minimum acceptable level...100m, 200m, 400m and 800m to be completed in less than...

I was aware of where I needed to be when playing in Cap 1... and the best players in the country don't?

Who is to say they didn't know? It would be very strange if they didn't.

I didn't read anywhere that the players knew any specifics (other than AH saying they needed to be 'fit'). If Craig Moore says NZF didn't give the Roar any direction, I wonder if the players were given some - more detailed - instructions regarding the acceptable level of fitness required.

Also beats me how a kid who is going through pre-season and playing minutes can be fitter than [awesome] old, injured Durante.

I saw in an article today that Hudson said he wasn't in contact with the Roar or any other club regarding expectations for fitness of his squad players. That was up to the players to take personal responsibility for. I still cant get over the fact that some of you intelligent people think for a second that the ultimate responsibility for the fitness of a professional footballer [in any environment] does not lay with the player. Even in amateur football that is the expectation -  in fact amateur or professional sport full stop. I've played sport where my coach has given us all a training schedule and had us periodically undertake fitness tests and if we weren't fit enough we sat on the bench. If we were coming back from injury, that was a different thing and latitude was given and we got limited minutes. But if we weren't fit enough because of our own slackness, we had no one to blame but ourselves.
Starting XI
550
·
2.4K
·
over 14 years

Theres a good chance we could lose this match, given all the players that are out. Sol Islands play nice attacking football we are going to have to park the bus and counter.

Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
almost 13 years

austin11 wrote:

People are entitled to their opinion on Hudson.  I don't hate him, I just think he is not very good. He stands and falls by his record. The Hudson era stats against non Island sides are

Played 15, won 1 draw 2, goals for 9, goals against 26, 0.6 goals per match...can't score, can't defend

0.6 goals per match with a side that has a EPL striker and two wingers currently at Dutch Div 1 clubs is not good enough IMO.

The Roar said today they had recieved zero information from anyone at NZF about the fitness requirements for Ingham and they think that the whole thing was handled poorly....no info from NZF? well knock me down with a feather...LOL

Considering the past AW scores in NZ against the Solomons are 6-1, 5-1, 6-0 ???? then anything less than a 4 goal winning margin will be a disappointment

You are SO right - couldn't have said it better myself.

I also want to add - if AH has been talking about fitness levels for so long - why has he not given his players an indication of what level they need to be at when reporting for duty? Moore says NZF didn't tell the Roar - how about the players? You'd think aside from the usual "I need you to run for 90+ minutes and never give up bla bla" - AH could give the players some tangible parameters (body fat not higher than...Beep test minimum acceptable level...100m, 200m, 400m and 800m to be completed in less than...

I was aware of where I needed to be when playing in Cap 1... and the best players in the country don't?

Who is to say they didn't know? It would be very strange if they didn't.

I didn't read anywhere that the players knew any specifics (other than AH saying they needed to be 'fit'). If Craig Moore says NZF didn't give the Roar any direction, I wonder if the players were given some - more detailed - instructions regarding the acceptable level of fitness required.

Also beats me how a kid who is going through pre-season and playing minutes can be fitter than [awesome] old, injured Durante.

I saw in an article today that Hudson said he wasn't in contact with the Roar or any other club regarding expectations for fitness of his squad players. That was up to the players to take personal responsibility for. I still cant get over the fact that some of you intelligent people think for a second that the ultimate responsibility for the fitness of a professional footballer [in any environment] does not lay with the player. Even in amateur football that is the expectation -  in fact amateur or professional sport full stop. I've played sport where my coach has given us all a training schedule and had us periodically undertake fitness tests and if we weren't fit enough we sat on the bench. If we were coming back from injury, that was a different thing and latitude was given and we got limited minutes. But if we weren't fit enough because of our own slackness, we had no one to blame but ourselves.

I think in modern professional environments it's more complex than that. Clubs manage players workloads and training schedules and get detailed information back from GPSs and fitness trackers which monitor heartrates and maximum speeds and distance covered and all that sort of thing. Yes the player has to put the effort in but his physical condition is monitored and managed by the club. If the Roar are confused by this then you have to think that the fault isn't solely with the player.
and 1 other
Life and death
2.4K
·
5.5K
·
about 17 years

Anyone that actually coaches more than a pub team agree with that? So when julian Savea was dropped from the All Blacks for not being fit enough it was the All Black and Hurricane management/coaches fault - not Savea himself?

Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
almost 13 years

Anyone that actually coaches more than a pub team agree with that? So when julian Savea was dropped from the All Blacks for not being fit enough it was the All Black and Hurricane management/coaches fault - not Savea himself?

I don't follow rugby so I don't know what happened there, did the Hurricanes express surprise and disappointment the way the Roar have? 
Marquee
1.7K
·
7.5K
·
about 17 years

CactusJones wrote:
Burgess seems to hate New Zealand Football. He's always writing negative stories. This is a lot more professional than a boys club that Herbert held. Fielding Lochhead and Christie against Mexico had me done. Sending Ingham home was right imo. If he's not fit, why have him?
Is playing Lochhead and Christie vs Mexico that much worse than some of Hudson's selection decisions?

Nope, Lochhead at the time was our best left back despite being unattached and from memory went on to play in a (admittedly terrible) MLS team afterwards.  Christie was terrible, but our midfield options were (are!) seriously lacking then, with Elliott and Vicelich never being replaced.

Headocunt
460
·
990
·
almost 10 years

wibbler wrote:

RoriM6 wrote:

Anyone in welly going anywhere to watch it?

I'm thinking of watching it at Four Kings.

I'll be at the Four Kings as well


Ok awesome i may rock up. If you see a weird looking introvert give me a shout.
Marquee
970
·
6.5K
·
over 11 years

Royz wrote:

Theres a good chance we could lose this match, given all the players that are out. Sol Islands play nice attacking football we are going to have to park the bus and counter.

Bollocks. We'll run 'em ragged. We're the Super Skinny Trim Whites.

Phoenix Academy
310
·
160
·
about 7 years

Anyone that actually coaches more than a pub team agree with that? So when julian Savea was dropped from the All Blacks for not being fit enough it was the All Black and Hurricane management/coaches fault - not Savea himself?

I know you are trying to make a point but can we please leave rugby out of these forums. Rugby dominates just about every aspect of life in NZ...to the point of saturation. Its kind of nice to come somewhere where you can discuss other stuff without rugby. It is a football forum after all.

LG
Legend
5.8K
·
24K
·
almost 17 years

Anyone want to guess what the Crowd attendance might be at "The Home of NZ Football"?

Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
about 17 years

Lonegunmen wrote:

Anyone want to guess what the Crowd attendance might be at "The Home of NZ Football"?

5000 sold as of a day or two ago. That's pretty impressive so far. 

Life and death
2.4K
·
5.5K
·
about 17 years

Anyone that actually coaches more than a pub team agree with that? So when julian Savea was dropped from the All Blacks for not being fit enough it was the All Black and Hurricane management/coaches fault - not Savea himself?

I don't follow rugby so I don't know what happened there, did the Hurricanes express surprise and disappointment the way the Roar have? 

No, because they knew it was his fault, no one else's lol
Starting XI
510
·
2.1K
·
about 15 years

Anyone that actually coaches more than a pub team agree with that? So when julian Savea was dropped from the All Blacks for not being fit enough it was the All Black and Hurricane management/coaches fault - not Savea himself?

I don't follow rugby so I don't know what happened there, did the Hurricanes express surprise and disappointment the way the Roar have? 

No, because they knew it was his fault, no one else's lol

Not the best example. Julian Savea has been picked for the ABs having been benched by the Hurricanes over fitness & form. 

You’ll need an account to join the conversation!

Sign in Sign up