Starting XI
920
·
2.5K
·
over 12 years

Global Game wrote:

Smithy wrote:

Global Game wrote:

GK wrote:

Tegal wrote:

GK wrote:

Under the radar U17/U20

Conor Tracey,   17, GK - Beachlands/QPR (Eng)

Ellis Hare-Reid, 16, GK - IFANZ/Cracks (Spain)

Dylan Morris,     17, Back, Ole/St Kents

Dan Allen,          18, CB, Northern Suburbs/Splits (Cro) Trial

Kieran Pinkney, 17, Back, IFANZ, Cracks (Spain)

Birhanu Taye,    19, Wing, APFA, (Slov) - OK - taking the shark a bit - but needed a right wing and missed the U20 cut. He's known.

Dylan Burns,     18, Mid, West Lake/Nottingham Forest (Eng)

Bertie Fish,       17, HMid, Northern Suburbs/Splits (Trial)

Nando Pijnaker, 17, Wing/Mid, Ole/Western Heights - Dutch passport - uh oh - look out.

Waikato Ball,    18, St Pauls/Phoenix Trial and friendly goal (2014)

Max Mata,         16, Striker, Onehunga Sports/Man U tournaments (Brother is in U17 - Ben)

Patrick Hay,      17, Striker, Auckland Grammer/5000 juggles in front of a croud = dedication to a goal.

Hopefully some of these players can get a look in at age group level?

So which one is your kid?

Looks like Ellis Hare-Reid was in the Burnley Academy in Chch, so he certainly is trying as hard as he can to go pro - he went on a tour of England with a guy from Dunedin called Jack Kirkwood, who plays in the Dunedin club scene for Green Island but is probably 19 now - getting old believe it or not aswell as Perth based Burnley Academy players. No England trial for Kirkwood as far as I can tell.

I guess the question is - did missing out on Rep honours so far, give these players the drive to get overseas = great for their development, or did overseas scouts and coaches see something in these players that the FTC/NTC did not see?

Should we have U17A and U20A teams to increase the player pools - or should we just encourage players not in the squads to get overseas and prove their point to selectors?

I know Hare Reid and Pinkney definitely pursued IFANZ(ex Burnley)/Cracks Academy option after they missed U17 training camp selection. Note, both have UK passports/eligibility.

As previously stated Morris left Ole after not being given a chance to trial by NZF, this cycle, because he was at Ole (a decision only very recently reversed for Ole players). Only time will tell whether leaving Ole environment for Auckland school/club/possible u17 world cup turns out to be a good decision or not.

I think in principle "encouraging players...to get overseas" is cool; but way too reliant on parentage/passport/eligibility to be a reliable foundation for the development of the majority of NZ players.

 

Where are you getting your intel that Ole players are excluded?

Out of the previous crop of Ole players, Alex Palezevic was in a national team, Riley Kelliher was in a national team (iirc), Corey Brown was in a national team...they were all at Ole at the same time they were in national teams.

I've said it once or twice. This cycle. For U17. It was policy.  Commencing April 2014 NTC. Jose new coach. Ole players excluded from all training camps. National coach didn't visit Ole. Only with Hudson quest for players maybe, or change of coach that Ole players considered for U17. Faber doesn't count by the way as he was still doing FTC, not Ole, when he went to an initial camp. I promise you I'm not wearing a tin foil hat ;)

Anyway, cycle nearly over now. Ole lads only had one shot at a training camp. Football politics.

it's not true sorry.  NZF did look at FTC players more often but they had TOL days for those outside the system and I was told academy players were more than welcome.  If they didn't go then that's their own fault.
Marquee
1.2K
·
5.5K
·
almost 14 years
Wrong chopah. Fact.
Marquee
1.2K
·
5.5K
·
almost 14 years
At least in case of mainland, football south and capital. Ole players were excluded.
Starting XI
920
·
2.5K
·
over 12 years

Global Game wrote:
At least in case of mainland, football south and capital. Ole players were excluded.

Got any proof, because I spoke to Jose and Fred about it directly.

Marquee
1.2K
·
5.5K
·
almost 14 years

chopah wrote:

Global Game wrote:
At least in case of mainland, football south and capital. Ole players were excluded.

Got any proof, because I spoke to Jose and Fred about it directly.

Starting XI
920
·
2.5K
·
over 12 years

Global Game wrote:

chopah wrote:

Global Game wrote:
At least in case of mainland, football south and capital. Ole players were excluded.

Got any proof, because I spoke to Jose and Fred about it directly.

Andy Hedge denied Ole players entry.

All Ole players or specific ones as that's two different things.

Marquee
1.2K
·
5.5K
·
almost 14 years

chopah wrote:

Global Game wrote:

chopah wrote:

Global Game wrote:
At least in case of mainland, football south and capital. Ole players were excluded.

Got any proof, because I spoke to Jose and Fred about it directly.

Andy Hedge denied Ole players entry.

All Ole players or specific ones as that's two different things.

Marquee
1.2K
·
5.5K
·
almost 14 years

Global Game wrote:

chopah wrote:

Global Game wrote:

chopah wrote:

Global Game wrote:
At least in case of mainland, football south and capital. Ole players were excluded.

Got any proof, because I spoke to Jose and Fred about it directly.

Andy Hedge denied Ole players entry.

All Ole players or specific ones as that's two different things.

In the South Island and Wellington, no Ole player was able to attend any U17 trial, from early 2014. My understanding was that NZF wanted to limit U17 trials to NTC/FTC participants, at least in those regions. Nix Academy players were given an exemption even though they did not attend FTC. I can't speak for Wynrs players who presumably did trial.

Water under the bridge now Chopah. Lots of reasons for it, but at the time NZF were not looking at the widest possible selection of quality players eligible.

Marquee
1.2K
·
5.5K
·
almost 14 years
Stage Punch
2.1K
·
11K
·
about 17 years

Global Game wrote:

Smithy wrote:

Global Game wrote:

GK wrote:

Tegal wrote:

GK wrote:

Under the radar U17/U20


Conor Tracey,   17, GK - Beachlands/QPR (Eng)

Ellis Hare-Reid, 16, GK - IFANZ/Cracks (Spain)

Dylan Morris,     17, Back, Ole/St Kents

Dan Allen,          18, CB, Northern Suburbs/Splits (Cro) Trial

Kieran Pinkney, 17, Back, IFANZ, Cracks (Spain)

Birhanu Taye,    19, Wing, APFA, (Slov) - OK - taking the shark a bit - but needed a right wing and missed the U20 cut. He's known.

Dylan Burns,     18, Mid, West Lake/Nottingham Forest (Eng)

Bertie Fish,       17, HMid, Northern Suburbs/Splits (Trial)

Nando Pijnaker, 17, Wing/Mid, Ole/Western Heights - Dutch passport - uh oh - look out.

Waikato Ball,    18, St Pauls/Phoenix Trial and friendly goal (2014)

Max Mata,         16, Striker, Onehunga Sports/Man U tournaments (Brother is in U17 - Ben)

Patrick Hay,      17, Striker, Auckland Grammer/5000 juggles in front of a croud = dedication to a goal.

Hopefully some of these players can get a look in at age group level?

So which one is your kid?

Looks like Ellis Hare-Reid was in the Burnley Academy in Chch, so he certainly is trying as hard as he can to go pro - he went on a tour of England with a guy from Dunedin called Jack Kirkwood, who plays in the Dunedin club scene for Green Island but is probably 19 now - getting old believe it or not aswell as Perth based Burnley Academy players. No England trial for Kirkwood as far as I can tell.

I guess the question is - did missing out on Rep honours so far, give these players the drive to get overseas = great for their development, or did overseas scouts and coaches see something in these players that the FTC/NTC did not see?

Should we have U17A and U20A teams to increase the player pools - or should we just encourage players not in the squads to get overseas and prove their point to selectors?

I know Hare Reid and Pinkney definitely pursued IFANZ(ex Burnley)/Cracks Academy option after they missed U17 training camp selection. Note, both have UK passports/eligibility.

As previously stated Morris left Ole after not being given a chance to trial by NZF, this cycle, because he was at Ole (a decision only very recently reversed for Ole players). Only time will tell whether leaving Ole environment for Auckland school/club/possible u17 world cup turns out to be a good decision or not.

I think in principle "encouraging players...to get overseas" is cool; but way too reliant on parentage/passport/eligibility to be a reliable foundation for the development of the majority of NZ players.

 

Where are you getting your intel that Ole players are excluded?

Out of the previous crop of Ole players, Alex Palezevic was in a national team, Riley Kelliher was in a national team (iirc), Corey Brown was in a national team...they were all at Ole at the same time they were in national teams.

I've said it once or twice. This cycle. For U17. It was policy.  Commencing April 2014 NTC. Jose new coach. Ole players excluded from all training camps. National coach didn't visit Ole. Only with Hudson quest for players maybe, or change of coach that Ole players considered for U17. Faber doesn't count by the way as he was still doing FTC, not Ole, when he went to an initial camp. I promise you I'm not wearing a tin foil hat ;)

Anyway, cycle nearly over now. Ole lads only had one shot at a training camp. Football politics.

 

Fair enough. That's a very narrow timeframe during which that policy applied!

Trialist
0
·
4
·
over 9 years

Max Mata is in fact only just turned 15, a real rising talent

GK
Phoenix Academy
100
·
410
·
about 11 years

When do they name the new U17 team - or will they stick with the squad that got them through the Oceania qualifiers? 

Word on the street is that there are more eligiblity problems with some of the Ole boys - bugger - just when they get a step over in the door.

Stage Punch
2.1K
·
11K
·
about 17 years

GK wrote:

Word on the street is that there are more eligiblity problems with some of the Ole boys - bugger - just when they get a step over in the door.

One of them I know is in the same boat as Wynne. Not born here but grew up here and holds a passport.

TV
On probation
250
·
4.2K
·
over 13 years
Marquee
1.3K
·
7.4K
·
almost 16 years

Foryoursupper?

TV
On probation
250
·
4.2K
·
over 13 years
Wasteful post
Stage Punch
2.1K
·
11K
·
about 17 years

foal30 wrote:

Foryoursupper?

whenyourewinning?

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
about 15 years

Played against Ellerslie last night? How did that go?

Phoenix Academy
130
·
440
·
about 17 years

Played a composite Western Springs side made up of players from age 15 to men's reserves, and lots of under 17 and 19s.

Rested most of the players who started against Forrest Hill in the July camp and no Wellington players, so quite a next tier side. Lost the game and not so great to watch. Against Forrest the starting 11 looked tidy and won 1-0 

Starting XI
920
·
2.5K
·
over 12 years

Jeff Vader wrote:

Played against Ellerslie last night? How did that go?

Played at Ellerslie.

Marquee
260
·
5K
·
about 17 years

TV wrote:
Singh?

The same one that said in the NZ Herald as a kid that he wanted to play for England?

Marquee
1.2K
·
5.5K
·
almost 14 years

Absolutely gutted for all the lads and families caught up in the #eligbilityadminshambles.

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
about 15 years

I've heard 2 independent rumours (one very good and one not so good) that the U17s trip to the WC is being revoked by OFC for player ineligibility. Apparently its due for release any day now.

WeeNix
170
·
550
·
over 11 years

Jeff Vader wrote:

I've heard 2 independent rumours (one very good and one not so good) that the U17s trip to the WC is being revoked by OFC for player ineligibility. Apparently its due for release any day now.

I see your two independent rumours and raise you a Mai Chen working for OFC - this disaster you speak of will almost certainly happen and it will not be the last. Every thermo-nuclear avenue of punishment will be explored and deployed.

Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
almost 13 years

Well, at least all our age group teams are going through this

#alignment

and 1 other
Life and death
2.4K
·
5.5K
·
over 17 years

Jeff Vader wrote:

I've heard 2 independent rumours (one very good and one not so good) that the U17s trip to the WC is being revoked by OFC for player ineligibility. Apparently its due for release any day now.

Very NUFC-esque
WeeNix
170
·
550
·
over 11 years

Well, at least all our age group teams are going through this

#alignment

but there is a solution, you can teach yourself alignment - because NZF has taught itself suffering and our vibrational waves are affecting the vortex of pacific football.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IO1Tb7_DtSk

Marquee
4.5K
·
5.8K
·
about 12 years

We can't be booted out retrospectively by them... we have already qualified and being drawn. Only FIFA can make that call now.

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
about 15 years

Jeff Vader wrote:

I've heard 2 independent rumours (one very good and one not so good) that the U17s trip to the WC is being revoked by OFC for player ineligibility. Apparently its due for release any day now.

Very NUFC-esque

True but I don't tend to come out with stuff like this often.
Stage Punch
2.1K
·
11K
·
about 17 years

Jeff Vader wrote:

I've heard 2 independent rumours (one very good and one not so good) that the U17s trip to the WC is being revoked by OFC for player ineligibility. Apparently its due for release any day now.

Very NUFC-esque

 

I have heard the same rumour from a reasonable sauce.

Phoenix Academy
24
·
240
·
almost 15 years

MetalLegNZ wrote:

We can't be booted out retrospectively by them... we have already qualified and being drawn. Only FIFA can make that call now.

Yes, I can't understand how OFC still have their hands in this one - surely FIFA's call now ?

Stage Punch
2.1K
·
11K
·
about 17 years

MetalLegNZ wrote:

We can't be booted out retrospectively by them... we have already qualified and being drawn. Only FIFA can make that call now.

Yes, I can't understand how OFC still have their hands in this one - surely FIFA's call now ?

 

I haven't looked at the rules but you can be virtually certain that if we have been proven to have cheated then we can be eliminated.

Protests from other teams might have to be put in before kick off, but that doesn't mean the rules go out the window at that point.

Phoenix Academy
24
·
240
·
almost 15 years

Smithy wrote:

MetalLegNZ wrote:

We can't be booted out retrospectively by them... we have already qualified and being drawn. Only FIFA can make that call now.

Yes, I can't understand how OFC still have their hands in this one - surely FIFA's call now ?

 

I haven't looked at the rules but you can be virtually certain that if we have been proven to have cheated then we can be eliminated.

Protests from other teams might have to be put in before kick off, but that doesn't mean the rules go out the window at that point.

Agreed - but wouldn't it be FIFA talking the action at this point ?

Opinion Privileges revoked
5.2K
·
10K
·
almost 15 years

Maybe FIFA agree with OFC.

Marquee
1.2K
·
5.5K
·
almost 14 years
Any French speakers know if this is news in Tahiti yet?
WeeNix
370
·
760
·
about 17 years

You know one thing i wish people would stop doing is talking about NZ Football 'cheating'. The players concerned are all legit kiwi citizens - many of whom have spent most of their lives here or at least developed most of their footballing experience here - who due to the vagaries of FIFA rules appear to have their eligibility in question. So on those technicalities they could be considered ineligible. Its a long long way from systematically poaching overseas kids into NZ in an underhand way to try and win games. these are legitimate real NZ citizens we're talking about. I'm happy to accept there have been massive errors of judgement around the eligibility rules - but lets stop talking about 'cheating'. It just demeans everyone concerned. 

Getting regulations wrong through error isn't cheating - its just a stuff up. 

Stage Punch
2.1K
·
11K
·
about 17 years

Gordinho wrote:

You know one thing i wish people would stop doing is talking about NZ Football 'cheating'. The players concerned are all legit kiwi citizens - many of whom have spent most of their lives here or at least developed most of their footballing experience here - who due to the vagaries of FIFA rules appear to have their eligibility in question. So on those technicalities they could be considered ineligible. Its a long long way from systematically poaching overseas kids into NZ in an underhand way to try and win games. these are legitimate real NZ citizens we're talking about. I'm happy to accept there have been massive errors of judgement around the eligibility rules - but lets stop talking about 'cheating'. It just demeans everyone concerned. 

Getting regulations wrong through error isn't cheating - its just a stuff up. 

 

Are you Lance Armstrong's PR man?

Not playing by the rules = cheating.

Phoenix Academy
55
·
200
·
over 10 years

Gordinho wrote:

You know one thing i wish people would stop doing is talking about NZ Football 'cheating'. The players concerned are all legit kiwi citizens - many of whom have spent most of their lives here or at least developed most of their footballing experience here - who due to the vagaries of FIFA rules appear to have their eligibility in question. So on those technicalities they could be considered ineligible. Its a long long way from systematically poaching overseas kids into NZ in an underhand way to try and win games. these are legitimate real NZ citizens we're talking about. I'm happy to accept there have been massive errors of judgement around the eligibility rules - but lets stop talking about 'cheating'. It just demeans everyone concerned. 

Getting regulations wrong through error isn't cheating - its just a stuff up. 

Agreed they are all citizens and this is not the players fault (even though they should be fully aware of the rules),  a few questions I have

1. Have they had any immigration fast tracking help from NZF? to speed up their "eligibility"

2.Was it by error? they have previously asked FIFA for clarification (deVries) so are well aware of the rules.

We could all accept 1 or 2 but up to 16 Errors makes it look like policy.

Marquee
1.2K
·
5.5K
·
almost 14 years
Agree with smithy on this. The players are victims not perpetrators.
Marquee
1.2K
·
5.5K
·
almost 14 years
NZF will never be able to claim to be a victim in this mess though.

You’ll need an account to join the conversation!

Sign in Sign up