All Whites, Ferns, and other international teams

NZ U20s

74 replies · 3,370 views
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Andora je pobjedila Makedoniju 1-0 jednom...i Farski Otoci Austriju...Lihtenstajn 2-2 sa Portugalom...Luksemburg pobjedio Svicarce 2-1 nedavno...Ima nade!
Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Easy there, Teske Vijesti.
















Shame only about 3 people on this forum will get that.
Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
very very disappointing

Normo's coming home

Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
It is dissapointing, in a way though I think Tahiti now deserve to win the tournement and go through.
 
It would be great if we win and fiji get a draw with Tahiti, but i would almost feel gutted for Tahiti then.
 
To be fair, we have had loads of great opportunities with all these world cups we are qualifing for. It would be a benefit to let one of the island teams have a crack at it.
 
 

If we build it, they will come...

Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Well London Chris, Tahiti it is.

Tahiti beat fiji 2-0, and NZ drew 2-2 with New Caledonia.

http://www.oceaniafootball.com/

While never good to fail to progress from these tournaments, I do think we sometimes underestimate the abilities of some of the other oceania teams (or overestimate ours).

Hopefully Tahiti can get some decent buildup and do well at the U20 world cup.
Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Hard News wrote:
el grapadura wrote:
Easy there, Teske Vijesti.

Shame only about 3 people on this forum will get that.


Vijesti = News ?
 
Teske Vijesti your getting the lingo...neverovatno = unbelievable
 
Final Standings
 
1) Tahiti (Qualify for Egypt 09)
2) New Caledonia
3) New Zealand
4) Fiji
 
Not good at all!!!!!!!
Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

Founder

Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Well good luck to Tahiti at the U20 World Cup next year. They'll probably get done in all 3 games but i hope they put in some decent performances more for the own sake than Oceania's.

As for us, it should be a future lesson to never underestimate these island nations. Especially away from home.

Three for me, and two for them.

Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
The island teams will always be hard to beat in there own environment, the heat but also the fans are something else. Lets hope NZ Soccer looks to put in place better buildups and systems to learn from this - in the meantime allez allez Tahiti....
Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
I always had fears this team would come unstuck and didn't even bother following their progress until today with the tournament over. Loosing to a small island of 178,000 (about Dunedin and Nelson together) really sucks, but credit to Tahiti and I hope they enjoy their time in the sun.
(Last time though, an Oceania team played in a finals in Egypt, our u-17s were spanked 13-0 by Spain.)
  This was probably one of the worst-prepared national teams we've sent overseas for a long time. Assembling a week before a major tournament and playing one warm-up game against Waikato's NZFC reserve team was clearly inadequate.
 I guess no money was left after spending a lot on the NZ women's u-17 preparations this year (not that I begrudge them that preparation, which they needed).  Admittedly, the women's u-20s did do really well in their finals with a similar lack of preparation- but basing the side around the match-hardened nucleus of u-17 players proved a coup. 
 One factor in the men's u-20s demise was having too many players in the side who don't play regular club football- any advantage from having A- League pros Barbarouses and Draper in the side was cancelled by the fact they have barely played a match of any kind in their two years at the Phoenix (having no reserve or youth team is a major problem fortheir younger players), whilst most of the NZFC players in the team don't play regularly for their franchises either.
 The fact that no South Islanders were deemed good enough for a place in the squad of 18 has raised a few eyebrows down here and suggests slack scouting in selecting the team. (But then again Otago and All Whites legend Mike McGarry was never selected for any national age-group side back in the 80s either).
 In contrast to our u-20s' non-existent preparation, Tahiti had their side playing in their "Championnat D1" national championship since Sept. 13 (three months of games every week).
 As Tahitian coach Lionel Charbonnier said on the eve of the tournament, "The technical gap between New Zealand and the rest of Oceania is not that great."
 Charbonnier has an interesting pedigree, having been a goalkeeper in France's 98 World Cup- winning squad and played for Auxerre and Glasgow Rangers. He came to the Tahiti job after starting a coaching career a few years ago in the lower reaches of French football, most recently coaching FC Sens in the fifth tier of French footie.
 Probably just as many (if not more) Tahitian players have played in the top European leagues (i.e. in their case the French First Division) as have Kiwis e.g. Vahirua who played for France in the 1980s and the current head of the Oceania federation Temari, who also played in the French First Div. and must be as pleased as the bee's knees with his fellow countrymen right now.

Big Pete 65, Christchurch

Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Its time for NZ Football to stop hiding behind every youth team that qualifys for a world cup tourn beating Tonga or Papa  New Guinee or Fiji New caladonia etc does nothing for advancing the game forward. We go to world cups and defend for 90 minutes and talk it up. Granted it is different for the girls, but we would really benefit all teams if NZ Football commited themselves to entering the asia con fed. Playing in quality world cup groups is what is needed if we are to get better in playing terms.
But I know this is only a dream as NZ Football does not have the abiltiy to make this happen. They jump up and down saying they have secured the all time future of the game by gaining access to taking out a loan to cover costs it has incurred. How does it pay for this!!!! They put a surgharge on all ameteur players in NZ. This is shocking. But it shows that they have no idea on what a strategic plan is!!!!!!    
Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Very poor result no matter which way you look at it.
Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Hard News wrote:

el grapadura wrote:
Easy there, Teske Vijesti.

Shame only about 3 people on this forum will get that.
Vijesti = News ?


And Teske = Hard (as in difficult). Or heavy.

Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
BUGGER.

Ah well. Good luck to Tahiti.
Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Or it could be good if they're ruthlessly slaughtered 20-0 three games in a row because that would put the spotlight on the validity of the Oceania region.
Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
This has set the development of the under 20s back abit. Some of these kids could have been scouted by Euro clubs from the exposer of this under 20`s WC.

At the end of the day it must be the coach that is to blame. Why say its NZF fault when Stu never attemped to build a stronger side.
Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
have you thought that perhaps this years crop just werent good enough??
Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
convict wrote:
This has set the development of the under 20s back abit. Some of these kids could have been scouted by Euro clubs from the exposer of this under 20`s WC.

At the end of the day it must be the coach that is to blame. Why say its NZF fault when Stu never attemped to build a stronger side.


You have got to be kidding here!!!! Stu can only do what he can with the program and financial budget he has been allocated from NZ Soccer - so if you are looking to put any onus on where it should be - then start with the administration!!!

In terms of the Tahiti team it would have been logistically easier to house everyone in a central location to achieve the goals they set out - if only the U20s had a similar buildup then perhaps we could compare apples with apples (or pineapples in this case) ....

I too am disappointed for the team because there is some very talented lads in the squad.....But at the same time its gotta be good for Oceania overall. It shows we can longer be complacent about where we stand in the federation and take it for granted - lets see some real progress here from the administration or suffer the consequences and future disappointment.
Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
We assume too much on how weak the other Oceania nations are and never on how weak we are. One week preparation? You got to be kidding me?! Most of those U20 players were available for an early training camp at least, where was the sacrifice?
Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
I can,t believe how far the standards and level of nz soccer have fallen
Quite simply the talent identification programme initiated by Ricky Herbert ,the federations and NZ soccer is abysmal.
We used to have a tremendous rep programme that meant that thousands of kids all over NZ would play club or school football on a Saturday and then for their local association on Sunday
In the Wellington Region we would have Wellington reps ,Mana Reps,Hutt Valley Reps and Kapiti Reps
the grass roots had a wide base and young players spilled in to vibrant strong clubs
now we have a small base and apathetic clubs who have given away their democratic rights to federations who are autonomous and answer only to themselves.
For example Stop Out was once a competitive ambitious National League club now it wallows in mediocrity with no National league to aspire to.
The NZFC is under funded and the standard has gone backwards not forwards Waikato FC is run out of the secretary,s front room has no club base and doesn,t even charge a gate!!!
The Under 20,s result is the tip of the ice berg.
The game needs a revolution by the clubs and leadership at the topQ!! 
Permalink Permalink
over 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
I must admit I feel sorry for the boys. I know there are some very talented young players. Unfortunately, the fact is that Tahiti (population 262,000) and New Caledonia (population 221,000) have put more funds and effort than New Zealand.
Another thing is that we, instead of trying to catch up with the rest of the world (remember the last under 17 and under 20 world cups), are struggling with Oceania teams (with no disrespect to Tahiti or New Caledonia). It is OK to say that they have improved significantly, technically, speed etc, but what did we do improve our game? Lack of preparation time? We knew that this competition will take place in Tahiti at least a year ago.
Remember that in the past Australia beat those teams 10 or 12 NIL.
Our aim should be to close the gap with the best in the world. If we don't know how to do it we should try to copy the best football schools in the world.
 

Permalink Permalink
about 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
hika wrote:
I must admit I feel sorry for the boys. I know there are some very talented young players. Unfortunately, the fact is that Tahiti (population 262,000) and New Caledonia (population 221,000) have put more funds and effort than New Zealand.
Another thing is that we, instead of trying to catch up with the rest of the world (remember the last under 17 and under 20 world cups), are struggling with Oceania teams (with no disrespect to Tahiti or New Caledonia). It is OK to say that they have improved significantly, technically, speed etc, but what did we do improve our game? Lack of preparation time? We knew that this competition will take place in Tahiti at least a year ago.
Remember that in the past Australia beat those teams 10 or 12 NIL.
Our aim should be to close the gap with the best in the world. If we don't know how to do it we should try to copy the best football schools in the world.
 

 
  We tend to be a bit unrealistic about our strength and influence in the world compared to other (much bigger) countries whether it's in sport or other areas of life, since most Kiwis follow sports only a handful of countries are interested in. It's unlikely we'll ever seriously compete with the major football nations and it's always going to be  hard to achieve any sustained success with our small population and remoteness. We can't compare ourselves to Brazil with 180 million citizens passionate about the game.
 To "copy the best football schools in the world" may be impractical since we lack the resources as a nation of even one of the best club schools e.g. Ajax Amsterdam or France's highly successful youth academies. These are only possible with large populations enthusiastic for the sport, sufficient spare cash and good organisational structures, all of which are lacking here.
 We are making slow progress in our own way though, with one professional club established (though even they at present lack a reserve or youth team) and at least the national league still exists (just) though the national youth league has gone. Seems to be one step forward, cancelled out by another step backwards at present.
 Countries with a similar population to us in Europe such a the Republic of Ireland or Norway enjoyed a spell of success in the nineties, qualifying for most major age group and senior World Cups. No doubt this was based on improved coaching structures as well as the public enthusiasm generated by the success of their national teams such as Ireland's wonderful exploits at the 1990 and 1994 World Cups underJack Charlton. Football only cemented a position as Ireland's most popular sport  in that period. However neither country has been able to sustain that success and they haven't qualified for any World Cups at any level for a few years now.
 Success is always relative to your circumstances, so we can't expect too much as long as the public enthusiasm and finances aren't there.( However, losing to tiny Pacific Island nations is not acceptable, even at this stage of our development). But it's the effort that counts, and who knows what we can achieve if we can establish a healthy reciprocal relationship between national team success and an improved base of skilled players. Entering the Asian Confederation and testing ourselves there is a good long-term goal too.
 

Big Pete 65, Christchurch

Permalink Permalink
about 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Big Pete 65 that is a very well reasoned summary.

This U20s failure also shows, as someone else said, that we can't expect to turn up with a team and qualify.  Meaningful preparation is needed.  A salutory lesson for the future.

Incredible stamina. No shame. Yellow Fever.

Permalink Permalink
about 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Thanks Big Pete
I agree with Smithy that is a very well reasoned summary, but, as Smithy said, we can't expect to turn up and qualify.
Just a matter of clarification, I do not expect our team to qualify and win under 20 world cup tournament, but do expect short, medium and long term planning. Knowing that football is the most popular sport in NZ for teenagers up to 15, one would think that there is a base to build on. Apart from some youngsters switching to Rugby or Rugby Union, what we are lacking is a future that some of those kids can dream of.
As a short term, I would see a proper minimum 6 months preparations for such a qualifying tournament (not 4 days with only two friendly games, where some players hardly know each other). Based on success and qualifying we could achieve our medium term, get public attention (like girls football), and financial support. Our long term aim should be to try to reach the quarterfinals. That could be achieved by arranging regular simultaneous trainings/camps in Auckland and Wellington where each camp would have a pool of 15/18 players competing for the spots in Under 20s.
Going back to original topic, I can't believe that Tahiti, Fiji New Caledonia or any other Pacific nation has more resources (Africa?) , but probably more passion for the game and desire to win.
The last thing that probably need to be mentioned is refereeing . NZ Football should officially request that Oceania tournaments be refereed by  refs from Australia, Asia or Europe and not from the nations which are attempting to qualify for the world cup. That is the only way to clear any doubts on impartiality.
Permalink Permalink
about 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
hika wrote:
.....The last thing that probably need to be mentioned is refereeing . NZ Football should officially request that Oceania tournaments be refereed by� refs from Australia, Asia or Europe and not from the nations which are attempting to qualify for the world cup. That is the only way to clear any doubts on impartiality.


Hika I agree that the Pacific countries have more passion but also the desire for the game, they can see the opportunities that can get them somewhere playing a sport they love and play on a daily basis (as they do in the villages and on surfaces which would be deemed unplayable in NZ)...

BUT please dont bring the refs into it ...thats just so a real lame excuse!!!!! At the end of the day we should be good enough to overcome anything a ref can influence so dont even go there - lets get back to seeking out funding etc to set up programmes and time to prepare correctly for a tournament which should be given the respect it deserves.

NZ Football (national body) - TAKE NOTE!!! It is not a given right that we turn up and qualify anymore!!! The Pacific Islands will be the next Africans of the region and will surpass NZ Football if we do not setup the right systems!!!!   
Permalink Permalink
about 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Smithy wrote:
Big Pete 65 that is a very well reasoned summary.This U20s failure also shows, as someone else said, that we can't expect to turn up with a team and qualify.� Meaningful preparation is needed.� A salutory lesson for the future.


Sadly, we have made that mistake in the past and not learnt from it.

One thing about youths and even the elite youths, is that adapting to change and getting familiar to team members and the environment is difficult to the adolescent mind and body. Any school teacher should tell you that.

Hence the need for longer meaningful preparation to any age group tournament or they will be caught out by teams that are not as talented but are more organised. In a tournament, you have to assume that there is going to be well prepared teams for it.
Permalink Permalink
about 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Its hard to prepare a team on no dollars. Our National Assn cant afford to prepare these teams so we have to accept these results untill (if ever) there is money available in the sport.
 
On the refs, Oceania refs need to be officating at these games to gain experince before they can be considered for higher honours. They need international experince just as the players do.

A dog with a bone :)

Permalink Permalink
about 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

Hence the need for longer meaningful preparation to any age group tournament or they will be caught out by teams that are not as talented but are more organised. In a tournament, you have to assume that there is going to be well prepared teams for it.


This is really a major problem for NZ football. Assuming that we have more talent than the Pacific Island nations.
Permalink Permalink
about 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
losing 5 teams out of the national youth league is a big set back.
Permalink Permalink
about 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Ryzah13 wrote:
losing 5 teams out of the national youth league is a big set back.

The NZFC should have a bigger youth allocation anyway and should be setup as such with at least compulsory 4-6 under 23 spots on the playing line up and the national youth league based as under 17s , were the best of that group will filter up when they turn 18.
Permalink Permalink
about 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
disagree sloth
All regions ie wellington ,mana hawkes bay canterbury etc should have their own youth rep team funded by federations
what else do they do!!
Permalink Permalink
about 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
bobmorton wrote:
disagree sloth
All regions ie wellington ,mana hawkes bay canterbury etc should have their own youth rep team funded by federations
what else do they do!!


they dont need an excuse to increase fees


Permalink Permalink
about 17 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Smithy wrote:
Big Pete 65 that is a very well reasoned summary.

This U20s failure also shows, as someone else said, that we can't expect to turn up with a team and qualify.  Meaningful preparation is needed.  A salutory lesson for the future.

They could of played the NZSS u19s the day before they flew to the UK would of been good for both squads
Permalink Permalink