Oh don't get me wrong. He will start at Waikato purely because there is no one else. Of those 9 goals, how many were flick ons and penalties..... That will answer your question. He's the guy that's there and taps it in when it bounces off the post. Yes he scored them, but more for being Johnny on the spot. I guess in that respect, I should give him props for having that instinct.
The answer is I would probably want neither. Is Colin Gardyne interested in another go around at Y-bopamooloo? I'd take him over those two. Much higher work ethic and work rate AND can score goals.