Starting XI
1.8K
·
4.1K
·
over 17 years

dowling and caunter in at waitak

Phoenix Academy
82
·
400
·
over 10 years


Where has Dowling been playing? I don't know how much game time he's going to get.

Starting XI
1.8K
·
4.1K
·
over 17 years

it sounds like waitak's new scottish signing jordon lowdon is not too bad

he is a former celtic youth player and then had a season in cyprus before moving to australia

anyone with any info from today, feel free to leave a comment on him!

WeeNix
43
·
640
·
almost 13 years

Great opening goal... Then second best all around the park.waitakere just coughed up possession . Right back for Waitak was poor..

The scotish lad looked good when he actually got the ball

Fair result

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
almost 15 years

ACFC treated Waitakere like the side they were - second best

Other than the opening goal which was a lovely ball to split both CBs, Williams did nothing. I though Alec Solomon(s?) was lucky not to get a red card for his tackle on Krishna - it was ugly. Probably the only saving grace was no studs but Jesus..

I though ACFC carried Billen and Feneridis who did nothing for them and Tade did his usually 20 mins of brilliance and not much else. Bale was easily the best player on the park with Irving making everything look simple. Waitakere carried more than a few players that did nothing - Jack Hobson-McVeigh won't start again and Cuneen is slower than Sigmund and Ivan combined and was consistently beaten. Cardoza = ineffectual

Waitakere will beat some sides simply because they are Waitakere but they won't beat a TW or ACFC this year. They looked in pre-season mode still and coughed up possession far far too easily. I think they got to the stage where they started focusing on the decisions they were not getting vs playing to beat ACFC in the end. Interesting to hear Butler give his coach (Shelley) a serve and Shelley just took it. I think this side will implode because there is no dominate personality to tell Butler and co to pull their heads in.

Phoenix Academy
82
·
400
·
over 10 years
Jeff Vader wrote:

ACFC treated Waitakere like the side they were - second best

Other than the opening goal which was a lovely ball to split both CBs, Williams did nothing. I though Alec Solomon(s?) was lucky not to get a red card for his tackle on Krishna - it was ugly. Probably the only saving grace was no studs but Jesus..

I though ACFC carried Billen and Feneridis who did nothing for them and Tade did his usually 20 mins of brilliance and not much else. Bale was easily the best player on the park with Irving making everything look simple. Waitakere carried more than a few players that did nothing - Jack Hobson-McVeigh won't start again and Cuneen is slower than Sigmund and Ivan combined and was consistently beaten. Cardoza = ineffectual

Waitakere will beat some sides simply because they are Waitakere but they won't beat a TW or ACFC this year. They looked in pre-season mode still and coughed up possession far far too easily. I think they got to the stage where they started focusing on the decisions they were not getting vs playing to beat ACFC in the end. Interesting to hear Butler give his coach (Shelley) a serve and Shelley just took it. I think this side will implode because there is no dominate personality to tell Butler and co to pull their heads in.

From what you've said Jeff Vader I don't expect much from Waitakere this reason which makes me angry. They can't afford to keep their top players and a quality coach and when they go and they don't have money to replace them with top quality. I don't think Shelley as coach works because if you're a senior player I doubt you'd want to have a fellow teammate who is also a coach telling you what to do, especially if you're at the same level.

I just don't think Waitakere have the strike power up front to trouble teams now. I think they had a pretty average pre season compared to ACFC which isn't going to help you prepare to come up a team which would probably fit into the A-League.

Starting XI
900
·
2.5K
·
over 12 years
Jtoml3 wrote:


Where has Dowling been playing? I don't know how much game time he's going to get.

he played last winter season with Ellerslie in our doomed premier league campaign - but he was immense - going to be tough for him to challenge Robbo but he does like a challenge.

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
almost 15 years

Whoops. Someone is not very happy. Perhaps its cause his brothers new team lost?

Marquee
970
·
6.5K
·
over 11 years
Jeff Vader wrote:

Whoops. Someone is not very happy. Perhaps its cause his brothers new team lost?

Ha ha. Dad wasn't best pleased either!

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
almost 15 years

I thought the Hogg that played for Waitakere was not the same quality as the Hogg that played for ACFC. I guess oddly enough when you look at the difference in Bale since he moved to ACFC, I guess players can look better in good sides. Coombes is not the same player he was at ACFC either.

Marquee
970
·
6.5K
·
over 11 years
Jeff Vader wrote:

I thought the Hogg that played for Waitakere was not the same quality as the Hogg that played for ACFC. I guess oddly enough when you look at the difference in Bale since he moved to ACFC, I guess players can look better in good sides. Coombes is not the same player he was at ACFC either.

Agree. And I wonder, like you?, if Krishna & de Vries are going to look as good with ACFC as they did with Waitak. Somehow I doubt it. As you say, different system.

Btw, if you ever saw Darren White struggling at Eastern Suburbs c.f. his committment to the ACFC cause! Of course East Subs weren't in a position to tempt him with a trip to Morocco.

Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
about 17 years
Jerzy Merino wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:

Whoops. Someone is not very happy. Perhaps its cause his brothers new team lost?

Ha ha. Dad wasn't best pleased either!

#computerLife
Starting XI
70
·
3.1K
·
almost 14 years
Jeff Vader wrote:

I thought the Hogg that played for Waitakere was not the same quality as the Hogg that played for ACFC. I guess oddly enough when you look at the difference in Bale since he moved to ACFC, I guess players can look better in good sides. Coombes is not the same player he was at ACFC either.


Coombes was very close to signing for WaiBOP, with no incentive of extra pay or anything on the side, Mulligan the same (he wanted to coach as well but the Fed wouldn't sign off on it, so HB it was). While I don't know much about the coaches in Waitak, I think that shows the attitude towards them and the season ahead somewhat
Phoenix Academy
82
·
400
·
over 10 years


I've tried a few times now to purchase a Waitak polo shirt from the club and all my attempts to contact them (Facebook and email) have been ignored. This to me clearly show's they don't exactly care about their fan base which due to their limited marketing is probably quite small. I think the quality of the coaching reflects the club's image overall.

Legend
2.5K
·
17K
·
over 17 years

Despite the result, Pep Temple, sorry i mean Paul Guardiola, looked dashing yesterday in his suit and tie combo. Not sure why he felt the need to pass instructions on to his players via notes though. Could hear a pin drop out at that paddock.

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
almost 15 years
Buffon II wrote:

Despite the result, Pep Temple, sorry i mean Paul Guardiola, looked dashing yesterday in his suit and tie combo. Not sure why he felt the need to pass instructions on to his players via notes though. Could hear a pin drop out at that paddock.

Yeah I agree. The supporters for ACFC were the loudest. Ramon did not need to do anything and Temple/Shelley should have been doing coaching.

If Mulligan and Coombes had both gone to Waibop, that would have done that franchise the world of good. I put the Alan jones connection down to that. Interesting as to why Mulligan did not go and the coaching thing why it was dismissed..

Marquee
970
·
6.5K
·
over 11 years
Jeff Vader wrote:
Buffon II wrote:

Despite the result, Pep Temple, sorry i mean Paul Guardiola, looked dashing yesterday in his suit and tie and shirt sleeve suspender combo. Not sure why he felt the need to pass instructions on to his players via notes though. Could hear a pin drop out at that paddock.

Yeah I agree. The supporters for ACFC were the loudest. Ramon did not need to do anything and Temple/Shelley should have been doing coaching.

If Mulligan and Coombes had both gone to Waibop, that would have done that franchise the world of good. I put the Alan jones connection down to that. Interesting as to why Mulligan did not go and the coaching thing why it was dismissed..

fixed.

Starting XI
1.8K
·
4.1K
·
over 17 years
Jerzy Merino wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:
Buffon II wrote:

Despite the result, Pep Temple, sorry i mean Paul Guardiola, looked dashing yesterday in his suit and tie and shirt sleeve suspender combo. Not sure why he felt the need to pass instructions on to his players via notes though. Could hear a pin drop out at that paddock.

Yeah I agree. The supporters for ACFC were the loudest. Ramon did not need to do anything and Temple/Shelley should have been doing coaching.

If Mulligan and Coombes had both gone to Waibop, that would have done that franchise the world of good. I put the Alan jones connection down to that. Interesting as to why Mulligan did not go and the coaching thing why it was dismissed..

fixed.



ha ha, nice.
Starting XI
70
·
3.1K
·
almost 14 years
Jeff Vader wrote:
Buffon II wrote:

Despite the result, Pep Temple, sorry i mean Paul Guardiola, looked dashing yesterday in his suit and tie combo. Not sure why he felt the need to pass instructions on to his players via notes though. Could hear a pin drop out at that paddock.

Yeah I agree. The supporters for ACFC were the loudest. Ramon did not need to do anything and Temple/Shelley should have been doing coaching.

If Mulligan and Coombes had both gone to Waibop, that would have done that franchise the world of good. I put the Alan jones connection down to that. Interesting as to why Mulligan did not go and the coaching thing why it was dismissed..


Federation too cheap I believe. If this squad had even one of those two players, they'd be a legitimate playoff contender. Not as much with the current midfield.
Starting XI
1.8K
·
4.1K
·
over 17 years
Jeff Vader wrote:
Buffon II wrote:

Despite the result, Pep Temple, sorry i mean Paul Guardiola, looked dashing yesterday in his suit and tie combo. Not sure why he felt the need to pass instructions on to his players via notes though. Could hear a pin drop out at that paddock.

Yeah I agree. The supporters for ACFC were the loudest. Ramon did not need to do anything and Temple/Shelley should have been doing coaching.

If Mulligan and Coombes had both gone to Waibop, that would have done that franchise the world of good. I put the Alan jones connection down to that. Interesting as to why Mulligan did not go and the coaching thing why it was dismissed..



good point about jones. a lot of people have a lot of time for him.  even in the negative world of football
Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
almost 15 years

Hi Stu

Did you watch the replay? What game were you watching??

Mike

Must try harder
96
·
1.5K
·
about 17 years

What time did the replay start ?

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
almost 15 years

7pm.. Had the full game.

Live I thought the tackle by Solomon might have been red but it was yellow. Certainly stuffed up the Berlanga card though..... Otherwise, there was nothing in the game remotely controversial or decided by the officials.

Legend
2.1K
·
16K
·
over 17 years
WeeNix
43
·
640
·
almost 13 years

No doubt auckland were the better side but  waitakere no 6 falls over 1 st goal.. The  Waitakere right back  gives ball away ( again) for 2nd goal. Then gets caught for 3 rd goal  then young Thai boy get caught for 4 th goal....

 Think if Myers goes back in they won't be to far off...  Just no depth...as auckland city got them all 


Marquee
970
·
6.5K
·
over 11 years
Big T wrote:

No doubt auckland were the better side but  waitakere no 6 falls over 1 st goal.. The  Waitakere right back  gives ball away ( again) for 2nd goal. Then gets caught for 3 rd goal  then young Thai boy get caught for 4 th goal....

 Think if Myers goes back in they won't be to far off...  Just no depth...as auckland city got them all 


ACFC gave them an All Whites LB.

Cock
2.7K
·
16K
·
almost 15 years
Jerzy Merino wrote:
Big T wrote:

No doubt auckland were the better side but  waitakere no 6 falls over 1 st goal.. The  Waitakere right back  gives ball away ( again) for 2nd goal. Then gets caught for 3 rd goal  then young Thai boy get caught for 4 th goal....

Think if Myers goes back in they won't be to far off...  Just no depth...as auckland city got them all 

ACFC gave them an All Whites LB.

He did not play like one (Still reading Stu?)
Marquee
970
·
6.5K
·
over 11 years
Feverish wrote:

Shelley/Temple


Brilliant! Shelley Temple. "Are you watching, Shirley Temple?!" Sorted. Just wait til the next ACFC Waitak game!.

Phoenix Academy
82
·
400
·
over 10 years

Does anyone know what position Limwatthana plays? I haven't been able to find any lineups with him in a position. 

Starting XI
1.8K
·
4.1K
·
over 17 years

according to the asb prem match report he stood in for butler at CM

First Team Squad
69
·
1K
·
about 17 years

Yeah holding midfield. Would be hard to drop based on today.

Phoenix Academy
82
·
400
·
over 10 years
reg22 wrote:

according to the asb prem match report he stood in for butler at CM


Thank you! I still have the feeling that City will get top spot this season but a 3-0 win is a good way to start. Does anyone know if OFC TV will be doing highlights of Waitak's games again this season?
Appiah without the pace
6.7K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years


Home games are meant to be on Sommet sports tonight.

Phoenix Academy
82
·
400
·
over 10 years
2ndBest wrote:


Home games are meant to be on Sommet sports tonight.


Very true however living in Australia is slightly annoying for that reason so I have to try and scavenge whatever is uploaded onto the world wide web. 
Appiah without the pace
6.7K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

Rumours of a training field bust up between Hogg and Cuneen. Neither playing tomorrow apparently. 

Starting XI
120
·
4.3K
·
over 15 years

Hoggs temperamently .......you`re joking !!!

Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
about 17 years
Starting XI
1.8K
·
4.1K
·
over 17 years

cunneen and hogg both left out of the team today

good waitak win, but still no fans on here posting

if anyone has a run down of the game, please feel free to share your thoughts

Appiah without the pace
6.7K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

Fa'ardo missed plenty of chances.

Legend
2.5K
·
17K
·
over 17 years

TW looked very average.

You’ll need an account to join the conversation!

Sign in Sign up