Current version

Posted January 26, 2012 06:19 · last edited March 18, 2021 07:19

Leggy wrote:
ShowUsYaNix wrote:
Leggy wrote:
Reckon it was def a penalty. The hand blocked the delfection off his foot, which could of gone anywhere.
�

No card though, but has to be a pen...


Great win, but was not a penalty.


Why not? Genuine question, I always thought a handball in the box was always a penalty, except sometimes if a players arms are pinned to their sides or maybe to cover the 'boys'.



It hit his knee first, his head was turned away so he had no idea whehe the ball was.I guess it is a question of intent. I don't think there was any.In saying that, having seen all the replays, the ref was in a very good position,


But why should it be a question of intent? What if he is on the goal line and it's genuinely unintentional?

Previous versions

1 version
Unknown editor edited March 18, 2021 07:19
Leggy wrote:
ShowUsYaNix wrote:
Leggy wrote:
Milky Pisswit wrote:
Reckon it was def a penalty. The hand blocked the delfection off his foot, which could of gone anywhere.
�

No card though, but has to be a pen...


Great win, but was not a penalty.


Why not? Genuine question, I always thought a handball in the box was always a penalty, except sometimes if a players arms are pinned to their sides or maybe to cover the 'boys'.



It hit his knee first, his head was turned away so he had no idea whehe the ball was.I guess it is a question of intent. I don't think there was any.In saying that, having seen all the replays, the ref was in a very good position,


But why should it be a question of intent? What if he is on the goal line and it's genuinely unintentional?