Pogba is top class but needs to do it more often than not to be world class. He would get away with his social presence if his football presence was better. But I still think he deserves to be in that team of the year.

Pogba within a balanced side (some decent leaders and senior players as well as youth and potential) would be world class (refer to Juve comments). United just don't have that balance or squad planning at the moment, hence the inconsistency. The players at the moment either look too old and past it or too young and not up to it.
Since Moyes was here, we have let Evra, Rio, Vidic, Fletcher, Evans, Rafael and Rooney all leave. Leaders, those with a United passion and style about them. The best leader we bought in was Herrera and we have let him run his contract down. Valencia and Young have been kept simply because there are no other leaders. And now De Gea is stalling on a contract, same with Rashford apparently which is remarkable.
Keep Ole with a plan, because other, more experienced managers without a plan has clearly not worked out.