Post history

History for Leggy

Manchester United

Back to topic

Current version

Posted December 04, 2017 05:54 · last edited December 04, 2017 05:55

Nelfoos wrote:

Leggy wrote:

Nelfoos wrote:

Leggy wrote:

If the Woolwich boys think the ref was poor then what about the yellow that Koscielny got towards the end of the game. That should have been a red as he fouled Lukaku in the Arsenal half and he was the last man.  

Nah Bellerin had it covered, yellow was the right call. No such rule as last man!

Not actually true.                           Bellerin was not last man

If the foul is violent or consists in a hand ball in the box then the player will  get a red card .  As long as the foul  is judged to be an honest attempt at taking the ball , the defender will only be shown a yellow card.

That is crap as he was cheating by pulling back a player that may have scored. 

  Last man means literally nothing.  He would have had to deny an "obvious goal scoring opportunity". For me there's enough doubt and Bellerin is fast enough to prevent an obvious goal scoring opportunity, so yellow is the correct decision.

As I have already stated the rules above, yellow is the only one he could have got. However  had he not got dragged down, who will ever know what might have happened. And by the way Lukaku is pretty quick.

Previous versions

1 version
Unknown editor edited December 04, 2017 05:55
Nelfoos wrote:
Leggy wrote:
Nelfoos wrote:
Leggy wrote:

If the Woolwich boys think the ref was poor then what about the yellow that Koscielny got towards the end of the game. That should have been a red as he fouled Lukaku in the Arsenal half and he was the last man.  

Nah Bellerin had it covered, yellow was the right call. No such rule as last man!

Not actually true.                           Bellerin was not last man

If the foul is violent or consists in a hand ball in the box then the player will  get a red card .  As long as the foul  is judged to be an honest attempt at taking the ball , the defender will only be shown a yellow card.

That is crap as he was cheating by pulling back a player that may have scored. 

  Last man means literally nothing.  He would have had to deny an "obvious goal scoring opportunity". For me there's enough doubt and Bellerin is fast enough to prevent an obvious goal scoring opportunity, so yellow is the correct decision.

As I have already stated the rules above, yellow is the only one he could have got. However  had he not got dragged down, who will ever know what might have happened.