Post history

History for Frankie Mac

GCSB protest

Back to topic

Current version

Posted July 28, 2013 20:26 · last edited July 28, 2013 20:43

Bevan wrote:

The question can be looked at another way:

Do you want some government agency collecting all your phone calls and emails, ready to be searched and re-read/re-played at a moment's notice?

I'd prefer that not to happen. 

Happy for them to track individuals suspected of something, as long as they have a warrant. But a dragnet on everyone? That's Stasi/Gestapo stuff which doesn't belong in a democracy.


There is no threat of terrorism; the last terrorist act in NZ was in 1985 (Rainbow Warrior). 

We should at least wait until Australia is attacked before we worry about ourselves being a target.


Do I want some government agency collecting all your phone calls and emails, ready to be searched and re-read/re-played at a moment's notice? More than fine for that to happen although I feel sorry for the person who has to trawl through all the spam and bollocks that I receive.  Emails about penis enhancements and illiterate texts from Greenie - go nuts chaps.

I am sure that Bali didn't think it was going to be a terrorist target in 2002 based on their recent history and what had been happening to the countries around it.  If there is a way to prevent incidents like this, or at least reduce the impact, then we need to look at it.

Previous versions

1 version
Frankie Mac edited July 28, 2013 20:43
Bevan wrote:

The question can be looked at another way:

Do you want some government agency collecting all your phone calls and emails, ready to be searched and re-read/re-played at a moment's notice?

I'd prefer that not to happen. 

Happy for them to track individuals suspected of something, as long as they have a warrant. But a dragnet on everyone? That's Stasi/Gestapo stuff which doesn't belong in a democracy.


There is no threat of terrorism; the last terrorist act in NZ was in 1985 (Rainbow Warrior). 

We should at least wait until Australia is attacked before we worry about ourselves being a target.


Do I want some government agency collecting all your phone calls and emails, ready to be searched and re-read/re-played at a moment's notice? More than fine for that to happen although I feel sorry for the person who has to trawl through all the spam and bollocks that I receive.

I am sure that Bali didn't think it was going to be a terrorist target in 2002