Maybe we need a specific Doctor Who thread

Christmas Special was so so but good to see Amy Pond at the end.

Matt Smith a great Doctor but what a terrible influence Moffat has become.

He has changed a detached, alien being, a complete chancer, a thief, who stole the Tardis, who survived many encounters just by the skin of his teeth into this Super Hero. Basically he has ruined a very interesting character.

Also the villains - The Cybermen have been rubbish for years and changed  from their fr*ggin messed up scary selves with Troughton to a side show. The Daleks are going the same way. Boring he always wins with his sonic-screwdriver that can do anything.

And now he can sort everything out when he regens.

That used to be amazing - The Doctor close to death - actually being beaten or close to it.

Horrible, horrible writing.

And Peter Capaldi looks a joke saying those words when he should be the best Doctor ever.

But I would say that the weeping angels are brilliant and the farting Slitheens are great comedy.

Amy Pond is utterly fantastic too.

Dammit FT. Take that back about Amy right now.

Or so help me I'll put a load of synthetics through on 60oC.

Dr Who DVD Board game arrived by courier today.

Perfect timing for sucky Wgtn weather.

Delivered by Tardis I presume as NZ post were not to be seen today. Staff cut backs me thinks.

The tardis looked like a grey and white van (courier post?).

Pretty simple board game but enjoyable and lots of clips of Amy, Sarah Jane, Tegan and Nyssa, Romana etc.

Thanks Flybuys.

Amy is great.

Romana was pure fluff.

Sea Devils kick arse, as do the Autons.

Clara I agree with you FT, but Amy is great.

Female companions in the new series are generally stronger, confident and intelligent compared with earlier ones.

Amy and Clara are also funny (and stunning). 

1) I like the story lines for the new episodes and the use of humour. Probably also reflects different social mores now compared with 70-80's dr who.

2) Not fussed either way. 

3) Agree. Dr Who is about outsmarting cunning aliens.

4) Clara needs to improve but wouldn't bench her just yet. She is our Tyler Boyd. Amy is our Marco. Leela is our Ifill.

5-8) Agree.

Did I say that Amy is great?

Jnr Jnr went to the symphony orchestra concert yesterday. Got the t shirt and progamme.  The programme looks great.

Anyone (grown up) go to it and if so your thoughts?

'Ere we go: http://www.stuff.co.nz/dominion-post/culture/nz-festival-2014/9751894/Review-Doctor-Who-Symphonic-Spectacular

This Sunday, Prime, 7:30 - 9:30 pm.

Excite!

I went and saw it at The Embassy on Sunday. It's good.

sorry gentlemen as much as I realise that Dr Who is a serious subject and I for one would not decry it. I have to put my pennyworth in and say that I loved River songs part in the whole process and being an older man than you both (possibly) think that Alex kingston is/was a babe and if ever they had planned a female Dr who (god forbid) she would have been my first choice for the part

I enjoyed River Song in her first two episodes (Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead), but I can't help but feel that her storyline would have been better if she didn't keep coming back. She didn't even really need to come back at all, they could have had the rest of her and the Doctors timelines play out in the 300 years that occurred between the two Doctors in The Impossible Astronaut and nothing would have really been lost, imo.

It's FT who is hating on River Song.  I am agnostic.

I would be OK with a female Dr Who and would nominate Sara Martins from Death in Paradise.

She would be the perfect foil for Amy Pond.

Yes, this is serious business.

With the bbc going with the 'older doctor theme" I used to think that as an older doctor that Alun Armstrong would probabl;y have been a good choice, maybe too old these days

He is by far the best thing in New Tricks but agree not at the moment as it would be to huge a shift for people to take in. (yes I know that's sad but it's true).

Like the idea of Capaldi  because I don't think he will f*uck it up. 

River Song - I'd have rather bought leela out of retirement.

'Tis good so far.

Strax, Clara, Vastra and Jenny.  And a Scottish Dr.

Get. In.

It is awful beyond belief.

Moffat just f*cking leave this alone.

A mess of a script that was largely incomprehensible for the first 20 minutes. A poor story. Capaldi is very fine but with very little to work with. 

The lesbian dinosaur women and her "cor blimey guv' wife  pc rubbish that is embarrassing. The Sontaren was funny but has terrible lines. 

Annoyingly smug companion.

The leftovers and Penny Dreadful have left Dr Who for dust.

The worst I've seen since DW got canned the first time. Actually I think Silvester Mccoy's episodes were better.

I've watched this show forever.

Timelords and Monkeys ffs.

Hang on a moment. Sure, there was a samey-ness with what they've done before.

But comparing it to Sylvester McCoy's Doctor is incredibly strong language and I would suggest mods take control. I take exception to that! I was very leery of Matt Smith's baby Doctor and didn't watch all of his episodes. I think I might have seen most of them now. 

I'm going to concur with J and Patrick. Also, in the hope that there is a line drawn between the Matt Smith era and the new Doctor that we see soon. I'm not necessarily happy with this 'lady in the garden' character. But she may be bluff and double bluff. 

I too wouldn't mind the introduction of either another companion simultaneous with Clara or her replacement alogether. It seems like she is popular though...

I'm going to say we had a lot of Capaldi monologues in this and from next week we might see more of the plot. Bit disappointed that they didn't go with what my friend suggested they might have- some sort of Doctor /Tardis rift- like Pertwee or where Capaldi wasn't able to control the workings of his TARDIS due to some problems in the regeneration and might skip erratically...There is actually time missing in the story line before they dropped into London via dinosaur mouth...maybe they'll go back and let us know what was going on there. 

Would be awesome, in fact, to see the emergence or re-emergence of the Rani or of another female time lord. Was that perhaps her? Or something else?

I must say that last week's episode was rather underwhelming.

Clara however is growing on me, but I think Capaldi is struggling (as is the Dr).  

Capaldi is f$^&ing awesome. Think the writing is a bit shite. It was okay, but if this season is just some rubbish about 'The Promised Land' I'll be cheesed. They cast Capaldi, they need to write something for him. Some new direction for the show, not more of the same, but worse.

Wait until 'Listen' tomorrow night. Apparently it's fucking amazing.

Moffart just stop writing for DR WHO!!!!!!

Since the poor Gatiss robot in sherwood and the first and second episode the series has been excellent, even with Clara. Dark, a great alien Doctor, no namby-pamby stuff - loved it. This Doctor is fantastic.

*****SPOILER ALERT******

Sunday night so fucking obvious, the 3W Symbol - hmmm I wonder what that could mean???

A women with 2 hearts called Misty, hmmm this is a puzzler.....

Then the poor abused Cybermen - clanking around doing f*all as usual, just Clanking around. Where is the menace??

Mistress - silly.

The idea behind the episode was great but Moffart just makes it so mundane and boring. 

Please stop.

Have missed it for the last three weeks but have been quite luke warm towards this series.

I've stuck with it because I could see Capaldi would make a great doctor and he has.

Why are you lukewarm??

A very very nice bloke Chris B I've met him in real life.

Because I am a Silurian and I can't afford the home heating!

And the plots were way too introverted/self-absorbed 

I think the plots are smaller scale and I don't think that should be a criticism. How can you say the recent plots are more self-absorbed when we had to endure the River-Song thing?

 I prefer this older more claustrophobic atmosphere rather than Tennantt/Smith "Wahey I'm the doctor/superman and I can solve everything and dontcha love me random companion?" approach of the last two. 

I don't mind either of those doctors I think this incarnation is just a little truer to what the doctor is.

Christmas Special on now.

Nick Frost as Santa Claus.  Amusing.

http://www.theguardian.com/football/2014/dec/26/la...

Surely a red card for the dalek. Goal disallowed.

Keeper's team should be ale to field a sub assuming subs not used up and the dalek goes into the match report

For number 2, get a tetnus shot and a test for HIV and anything else.