There is only one true version of that song and it is #2 on your list. #1 is definitely trying a bit too hard, she's got some lungs though. Ironically Aretha was originally offered the song I think, but passed on it, so it was given to Dusty.
For me there's not much between Aretha and Dusty's version, Dusty just came up first on the youtube search. I probably do like Dusty better as it was played a lot when I was growing up and she is mesmerizing. But there is only one Aretha Franklin.
Read that too about Aretha passing on the song first.
Agreed as LoneGunmen would say Joss has a great set of ju.. lungs on her but she is missing soul.