Post history

History for Walsall Boy

Cap Prem 2020

Back to topic

Current version

Posted July 18, 2015 09:59 · last edited July 18, 2015 10:02

feetup wrote:

Walsall Boy wrote:

It seemed like he said - "I dont know if it a penalty or not, so i will give it but wont send him off."  As I said, truely bizzare

Spot on call from the AR from where I was stood - there was light contact, but nothing to say yellow/red IMO. Was an entertaining game for sure, if only UH found this form earlier...

I bow to your judgment on the penalty.  I was too far away to tell for any certainty.  Once a foul was determined though, it by definition stopped a clear goal scoring opportunity as apart from the goalkeeper there was no one else to beat.  The law is quite clear, the player must be sent off.  The referee has no discretion

Previous versions

2 versions
Walsall Boy edited July 18, 2015 10:02
feetup wrote:
Walsall Boy wrote:

It seemed like he said - "I dont know if it a penalty or not, so i will give it but wont send him off."  As I said, truely bizzare

Spot on call from the AR from where I was stood - there was light contact, but nothing to say yellow/red IMO. Was an entertaining game for sure, if only UH found this form earlier...

I bow to your judgment on the penalty.  I was too far away to tell.  Once a foul was determined though, it by definition stopped a clear goal scoring opportunity.  The law is quite clear, the player must be sent off.  The referee has no discretion

Walsall Boy edited July 18, 2015 10:01
feetup wrote:
Walsall Boy wrote:

It seemed like he said - "I dont know if it a penalty or not, so i will give it but wont send him off."  As I said, truely bizzare

Spot on call from the AR from where I was stood - there was light contact, but nothing to say yellow/red IMO. Was an entertaining game for sure, if only UH found this form earlier...

I bow to your judgment on the penalty.  I was too far away to tell.  once a foul was determined, it stopped a clear goal scoring opportunity.  The law is quite clear, the player must be sent off.  The referee has no discreation