Post history

History for Ryan54

Pelligra's Glory FC

Back to topic

Current version

Posted April 10, 2015 12:33 · last edited April 10, 2015 12:34

Bullion wrote:

Ryan54 wrote:

Bullion wrote:

Tegal wrote:

number8 wrote:

269k fine, biggest chunk for this season.

http://www.a-league.com.au/article/ffa-statement-r...

They get the amount of points deducted to be on the 7th place after all rounds are played.

Sounds fair.

Except for the 3 teams they finish ahead of

Wish we had Perth again this season. Don't see why they just didn't void all their games - every game they had been cheating, should just give everyone a win for the games against Perth.

But some teams may have done well against Perth this team. If you have beaten a cheating side 2 or 3 times then you should be rewarded for that. Otherwise teams just get rewarded for being poor against Perth earlier in the season.

I think it's the more fair thing to do, Perth still have a say on the finishing order of the league but have nothing to play for - their season finished 3pm AEST 10 April. And there is no problem teams doing poorly against a team that cheated to get an unfair advantage, if this was a WCQ FIFA would be awarding 3-0 wins to Perth's opposition every game?

When Melbourne got stripped of points they started playing even better. You can't tell how these things will go.

Central Coast don't have anything to play for either and results against them will still count.

Previous versions

1 version
Ryan54 edited April 10, 2015 12:34
Bullion wrote:
Ryan54 wrote:
Bullion wrote:
Tegal wrote:
number8 wrote:

269k fine, biggest chunk for this season.

http://www.a-league.com.au/article/ffa-statement-r...

They get the amount of points deducted to be on the 7th place after all rounds are played.

Sounds fair.

Except for the 3 teams they finish ahead of

Wish we had Perth again this season. Don't see why they just didn't void all their games - every game they had been cheating, should just give everyone a win for the games against Perth.

But some teams may have done well against Perth this team. If you have beaten a cheating side 2 or 3 times then you should be rewarded for that. Otherwise teams just get rewarded for being poor against Perth earlier in the season.

I think it's the more fair thing to do, Perth still have a say on the finishing order of the league but have nothing to play for - their season finished 3pm AEST 10 April. And there is no problem teams doing poorly against a team that cheated to get an unfair advantage, if this was a WCQ FIFA would be awarding 3-0 wins to Perth's opposition every game?

When Melbourne got stripped of points they started playing even better. You can't tell how these things will go.