That's not a penalty for me. It looked one live but it's not like Redmayne can really get out of the way though. Also if that is a foul then it is also a red.
I sort of agree with you but in today's football that's going to be a penalty 99 times out of a 100. It's all about that dreaded word 'contact'. Even though Redmayne was clearly almost flinching from the contact the ref is practically obliged to give it.
Weird tactics from City to stick Kisnorbo up front and bang it long for the last ten minutes. Didn't even get them close.