Post history

History for djtim3000

Season 14: Week 13

Back to topic

Current version

Posted January 14, 2019 04:13 · last edited January 14, 2019 04:13

RR wrote:

kwlap wrote:

bullshark penalty to win it. there was nothing there. Would have thought/hoped VAR would have overruled that. 

There was contact, so failed the 'clear and obvious' part. The VAR isn't there to re-Ref games, so can't rule on if its enough contact or not. Ams should be embarrassed that he gave that.

The VAR over-ruled a penalty shout in the Nix game vs WSW when Kamau was brought down in the box. And there was clearly contact on Kamau. It looked as though he had lost control and was already falling over but it certainly wasn't clear and obvious. What is the difference?

Previous versions

1 version
Unknown editor edited January 14, 2019 04:13
RR wrote:
kwlap wrote:

bullshark penalty to win it. there was nothing there. Would have thought/hoped VAR would have overruled that. 

There was contact, so failed the 'clear and obvious' part. The VAR isn't there to re-Ref games, so can't rule on if its enough contact or not. Ams should be embarrassed that he gave that.

The VAR over-ruled a penalty should in the Nix game vs WSW when Kamau was brought down in the box. And there was clearly contact on Kamau. It looked as though he had lost control and was already falling over but it certainly wasn't clear and obvious. What is the difference?