Post history

History for Luis Garcia

Ernie Merrick - former Phoenix manager

Back to topic

Current version

Posted May 12, 2013 04:45 · last edited May 12, 2013 04:47

tripvincent wrote:

Luis Garcia wrote:

Jeff Vader wrote:

Luis Garcia wrote:

Paul Ifill was scathing in his review of Herbert at a charity dinner last night. Told everyone that Herbert was out of his depth, there was no accountability for poor performances and that he doesn't expect the All Whites to qualify for the world cup because the players aren't good enough.

Care to review this since you just got called out by Ifill himself?


Hmmm was told this by a friend who was at the event - will have to show him Ifill's comments! Sorry Paul :( 


If you weren't there then what a dumb thing to post...



Tony Smith has said worse about Herbert in the press before, writing something on a forum having just been told that by a friend is hardly a crime. Obviously things were exaggerated, and I wish I had gone. Good on Paul coming down and helping out the Nelson Falcons.


I think Herbert was out of his depth and that we probably don't have the players to qualify for the world cup, it's hardly a big scandal.. Just wish I had been told the 100% truth. 

Previous versions

1 version
Luis Garcia edited May 12, 2013 04:47
tripvincent wrote:
Luis Garcia wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:
Luis Garcia wrote:

Paul Ifill was scathing in his review of Herbert at a charity dinner last night. Told everyone that Herbert was out of his depth, there was no accountability for poor performances and that he doesn't expect the All Whites to qualify for the world cup because the players aren't good enough.

Care to review this since you just got called out by Ifill himself?


Hmmm was told this by a friend who was at the event - will have to show him Ifill's comments! Sorry Paul :( 


If you weren't there then what a dumb thing to post...



Tony Smith has said worse about Herbert in the press before, writing something on a forum having just been told that by a friend is hardly a crime. Obviously things were exaggerated, and I wish I had gone. Good on Paul coming down and helping out the Nelson Falcons.