Post history

History for Napier Phoenix

Phoenix Ownership - Rob says FTFFA (Part 2)

Back to topic

Current version

Posted April 20, 2018 06:25 · last edited March 18, 2021 07:34

patrick478 wrote:
Napier Phoenix wrote:
Baiter wrote:

I like the bit where people believe the rumours from a tabloid website where an agent hides badly behind a nom de plume ahead of Jason Pine stating clearly that it's not the case.

You know, I want to hear more from the likes of Piney than "its not true" Anyone can say that. I want to hear what he says, and then some reason for me believing him, more than just because it was Piney that said it. How does Piney know its not true? surely he can say why he knows without betraying any trust.

Why do you instantly believe what Rallis under his Covert Agent pseudonym has written then? Surely you should be holding him piece to the same standards you are holding Piney to?

I'm not saying either source is correct. My points have all been directed at the fact that you and others are always quick to pooh pooh Covert Agent's stories based on innuendo whereas you immediately accept the word of the likes of Piney. What you said is just turning around what I said. And again, you are simply stating Rallis is Covert Agent, no one has been able to provide any proof [no matter how weak] that he is.

Previous versions

2 versions
Unknown editor edited March 18, 2021 07:34
patrick478 wrote:
Napier Phoenix wrote:
Baiter wrote:

I like the bit where people believe the rumours from a tabloid website where an agent hides badly behind a nom de plume ahead of Jason Pine stating clearly that it's not the case.

You know, I want to hear more from the likes of Piney than "its not true" Anyone can say that. I want to hear what he says, and then some reason for me believing him, more than just because it was Piney that said it. How does Piney know its not true? surely he can say why he knows without betraying any trust.
Why do you instantly believe what Rallis under his Covert Agent pseudonym has written then? Surely you should be holding him piece to the same standards you are holding Piney to?
I'm not saying either source is correct. My points have all been directed at the fact that you and others are always quick to pooh pooh Covert Agent's stories based on innuendo whereas you immediately accept the word of the likes of Piney. What you said is just turning around what I said. And again, you are simply stating Rallis is Covert Agent, no one has been able to provide any proof [no matter how weak] that he is.
Unknown editor edited April 20, 2018 06:26
patrick478 wrote:
Napier Phoenix wrote:
Baiter wrote:

I like the bit where people believe the rumours from a tabloid website where an agent hides badly behind a nom de plume ahead of Jason Pine stating clearly that it's not the case.

You know, I want to hear more from the likes of Piney than "its not true" Anyone can say that. I want to hear what he says, and then some reason for me believing him, more than just because it was Piney that said it. How does Piney know its not true? surely he can say why he knows without betraying any trust.
Why do you instantly believe what Rallis under his Covert Agent pseudonym has written then? Surely you should be holding him piece to the same standards you are holding Piney to?
I'm not saying either source is correct. My points have all been directed at the fact that you and others are always quick to pooh pooh Covert Agent's stories based on innuendo whereas you immediately accept the word of the likes of Piney. What you said is just turning around what I said.