Post history

History for mjp2

Phoenix Team of the First Decade

Back to topic

Current version

Posted February 26, 2017 03:02 · last edited February 26, 2017 03:03

aitkenmike wrote:

Tegal wrote:

it factors in but isn't the only consideration. For example for defenders I voted the 3 highest appearances, plus Rossi. 

The whole idea of this is people use their own criteria. 

Yep, longevity was definitely a factor for me.  It was the only thing that held me back from picking Rossi.  Another full season and he would have walked in if he keeps it up, but we have seen others flop after a great first season.

I'm the total opposite.  Rossi's the best CB we've had play for us.  Consumate class.  He's been an automatic starter for us since arriving. So McKain and Rossi for me. But I'd go along with Dura if we're picking McKain at DM. :)

FB, jeez.  I ended up with Muscat and Boxall.  Which says a lot about the rest of them; Lochhead, Doyle, Hearfield, Bertos, Fenton ... who am I missing?

Unless I am missing someone I'd say Tratt would be about the next best after Boxall and he's a first year rookie.  And I've got both Boxall and Manny out of position.  Such is the history of 'Nix fullbacks! 

At least Manny and Boxall get intimidation bonus points.

Previous versions

1 version
mjp2 edited February 26, 2017 03:03
aitkenmike wrote:
Tegal wrote:

it factors in but isn't the only consideration. For example for defenders I voted the 3 highest appearances, plus Rossi. 

The whole idea of this is people use their own criteria. 

Yep, longevity was definitely a factor for me.  It was the only thing that held me back from picking Rossi.  Another full season and he would have walked in if he keeps it up, but we have seen others flop after a great first season.

I'm the total opposite.  Rossi's the best CB we've had play for us.  Consumate class.  He's been an automatic starter for us since arriving. So McKain and Rossi for me. But I'd go along with Dura if we're picking McKain at DM. :)

FB, jeez.  I ended up with Muscat and Boxall.  Which says a lot about the rest of them; Lochhead, Doyle, Hearfield, Bertos, Fenton ... who am I missing?

Unless I'm missing someone I'd say Tratt would be about the next best after Boxall and he's a first year rookie.  And I've got both Boxall and Manny out of position.  Such is the history of 'Nix fullbacks! 

At least Manny and Boxall get intimidation bonus points.