Post history

History for Jeff Vader

Phoenix Transfer Speculation 2012/13

Back to topic

Current version

Posted November 16, 2012 02:41 · last edited November 16, 2012 02:43

Trueblue wrote:

Jeff Vader wrote:

Trueblue wrote:

Huysegems is better with his feet than his head and Killen is the reverse, could work. Huys certainly needs someone who can play to his feet though. Couldn't RH tell McGlinchey if he wants to go to Brazil then he better shift to Wellington?

Still think Tade is the best finisher in NZ but you can't have him.

Once again, your flair-less midfield is crying out for Clapham.

We already have our quota of imports thanks. If he was good enough, he would have got a spot.

 

I'm sorry, I don't know how Smith got selected for the Phoenix. I doubt he'd even get in the current City squad. Clapham has better all round skills, is tenacious and is good at free kicks. RH has some peculiar preferences, remember you guys had to force Rojas on him when it was obvious the kid had talent. I think RH has a stubborn streak that often gets in the road of his judgement. Just look at Lochhead's continued presence in the AWs.

I'll give you a different perspective and its the same thing with Roy Krishna and everyone else that 'should' play A League.

Unfortunately, Kiwis count as imports in other sides but if they were good enough, they would get picked as an import including Tade. Those that play here like Krishna and Tade would be an import for as well as the other 9 sides in the league. Why haven't they signed them if Ricki has clearly lost his marbles? The fact is that Smith was with another side (yes he got dumped for a supposedly bigger star) so was good enough to play elsewhere in the league (granted it was Miron so not much to rave about)

Previous versions

1 version
Jeff Vader edited November 16, 2012 02:43
Trueblue wrote:
Jeff Vader wrote:
Trueblue wrote:

Huysegems is better with his feet than his head and Killen is the reverse, could work. Huys certainly needs someone who can play to his feet though. Couldn't RH tell McGlinchey if he wants to go to Brazil then he better shift to Wellington?

Still think Tade is the best finisher in NZ but you can't have him.

Once again, your flair-less midfield is crying out for Clapham.

We already have our quota of imports thanks. If he was good enough, he would have got a spot.

I'm sorry, I don't know how Smith got selected for the Phoenix. I doubt he'd even get in the current City squad. Clapham has better all round skills, is tenacious and is good at free kicks. RH has some peculiar preferences, remember you guys had to force Rojas on him when it was obvious the kid had talent. I think RH has a stubborn streak that often gets in the road of his judgement. Just look at Lochhead's continued presence in the AWs.

I'll give you a different perspective and its the same thing with Roy Krishna and everyone else that 'should' play A League.

Unfortunately, Kiwis count as imports in other sides but if they were good enough, they would get picked as an import including Tade. Those that play hear like Krishna and Tade would be an import for as well as the other 9 sides in the league. Why haven't they signed them if Ricki has clearly lost his marbles? The fact is that Smith was with another side (yes he got dumped for a supposedly bigger star) so was good enough to play elsewhere in the league (granted it was Miron so not much to rave about)