Post history

History for aitkenmike

Phoenix Transfer Speculation 2012/13

Back to topic

Current version

Posted January 13, 2013 09:37 · last edited January 19, 2013 23:50

playwithFire wrote:

Dont think its up to the fans to identify players everytime they want to point out a position we lack in.

However we could look at contracted players who arent getting much game time currently. Im thinking Caravella, Jonny McKain, Jimmy Jeggo, Mitch Cooper etc. 
All could play in the CM position. Not saying they would be the solution necessarily.  But there are probably plenty more guys like this who arent being played as much as they would like. 


Also, another option could be guys who are currently in their offseason - like matty mckay, or dan keat. Theres some suggestions


None of those contracted guys are that much of an upgrade from what we have now.  I doubt they would come over here for a 3 month contract, thus we would need to sign them to a 2 season deal at least, in the long run doing more harm than good.  It's the fallacy of 'we need to do something, this is something, therefore we need to do it'.  Would love Matty McKay, do you really think he would come here rather than play K-League?  I dont.

Previous versions

2 versions
Unknown editor edited January 19, 2013 23:50
playwithFire wrote:

Dont think its up to the fans to identify players everytime they want to point out a position we lack in.

However we could look at contracted players who arent getting much game time currently. Im thinking Caravella, Jonny McKain, Jimmy Jeggo, Mitch Cooper etc. 
All could play in the CM position. Not saying they would be the solution necessarily.  But there are probably plenty more guys like this who arent being played as much as they would like. 


Also, another option could be guys who are currently in their offseason - like matty mckay, or dan keat. Theres some suggestions


None of those contracted guys are that much of an upgrade from what we have now.  I doubt they would come over here for a 3 month contract, thus we would need to sign them to a 2 season deal at least, in the long run doing more harm than good.  It's the fallacy of 'we need to do something, this is something, therefore we need to do it'.  Would love Matty McKay, do you really think he would come here rather than play K-League?  I dont.
aitkenmike edited January 13, 2013 09:38
playwithFire wrote:

Dont think its up to the fans to identify players everytime they want to point out a position we lack in.

However we could look at contracted players who arent getting much game time currently. Im thinking Caravella, Jonny McKain, Jimmy Jeggo, Mitch Cooper etc. 
All could play in the CM position. Not saying they would be the solution necessarily.  But there are probably plenty more guys like this who arent being played as much as they would like. 


Also, another option could be guys who are currently in their offseason - like matty mckay, or dan keat. Theres some suggestions


None of those guys are that much of an upgrade from what we have now.  I doubt they would come over here for a 3 month contract, thus we would need to sign them to a 2 season deal at least, in the long run doing more harm than good.  It's the fallacy of 'we need to do something, this is something, therefore we need to do it'.  Would love Matty McKay, do you really think he would come here rather than play K-League?  I dont.