Question: Who would you rather keep, McKain or Reddy? I can't seperate them, I love them both.
Who would I keep? I think I'd take McKain. Reddy has been ridiculously good for us, but Pasty does a good enough job. In losing McKain, yes we have a good replacement in Siggy, but lose Siggy/Dura (more likely than Pasty)- then we really are a bit stuffed for a CB. I'm sure Manny could fill it for a game or two, but not for any length of time.
Really tough question though, fortunately the world doesn't operate like that (unless both are being money hungry bastards).