Post history

History for paullt

Player ratings v Reds

Back to topic

Current version

Posted March 30, 2014 19:39 · last edited March 30, 2014 19:39

clyde wrote:

Its horrible starting the week with depression, if only, if only

Mossy 6 Not really a lot to do
Boxall 6 Had Zullo in his pocket, had a header lined up if only Brockie hadn't got to it first, A fullback's volley though
Siggy 5.5 Was going to rate higher, until he was arguing with the ref upfield while they won a penalty
Dura 5.5 Had a real good game first half, then a silly dive in to give them the pen
Timmins 4.5 Bring back Lochie. Why didn't he (Timmins) play on????
Lia 5.5 Had to do a lot of covering other people's men
Manny 6 Lovely ball for Stein, did well
Ridenton 5.5 Some good turns, out muscled at times
Kenny 5.5 Almost scored a great goal, hungry
Stein 5.5 Should have scored. Faded
Brockie 5.5 Good shot on goal that Galek was lucky to stop, worked hard ish
Carlos 6 Considering he was always under pressure from several players, did well with the ball a number of times.
Roy 5 Didn't get in the game much, well done Adelaide
Boyd 5 Ditto

Oh well, the local leagues are starting and we can  have some other performances to worry about.


Mossy 6 Not really a lot to do
Boxall 5 Kept Zullo at bay - should have done better with volley
Siggy 5.5 Was going to rate higher, until he was arguing with the ref upfield while they won a penalty
Dura 6 Had a good game overall, apart from silly dive in to give them the pen
Timmins 6.5 Kept two of the best wingers in the league at bay as well as contributing down the wing - is improving
Lia 5  Done his job
Manny 6 Some good tackles and some bad but worked hard
Ridenton 5 Some good turns, out muscled at times started to fade - is improving
Kenny 5.5  Almost scored a great goal, hungry
Stein 5  Should have scored. Faded
Brockie 5.5 Good shot on goal didn't work well with  Stein - not doing it for me
Carlos 4  Looked tired after a couple of minutes, gave the ball away far to easy 
Roy 4   Didn't get in the game much, well done Adelaide 
Boyd 5 Did some good work when he came on looked like things could happen - is improving


Thought Timmins got  better as the game progressed

Would rate manny lower as I thought he was an accident waiting to happen, his frustration was starting to get into yellow card territory a bit too much

Stein and brockie as a pairing was crap, on this performance no-one will want Stein and as for Brockie...just not good enough

Previous versions

1 version
paullt edited March 30, 2014 19:39
clyde wrote:
Oi Oi Edgecumbe wrote:

Its horrible starting the week with depression, if only, if only

Mossy 6 Not really a lot to do
Boxall 6 Had Zullo in his pocket, had a header lined up if only Brockie hadn't got to it first, A fullback's volley though
Siggy 5.5 Was going to rate higher, until he was arguing with the ref upfield while they won a penalty
Dura 5.5 Had a real good game first half, then a silly dive in to give them the pen
Timmins 4.5 Bring back Lochie. Why didn't he (Timmins) play on????
Lia 5.5 Had to do a lot of covering other people's men
Manny 6 Lovely ball for Stein, did well
Ridenton 5.5 Some good turns, out muscled at times
Kenny 5.5 Almost scored a great goal, hungry
Stein 5.5 Should have scored. Faded
Brockie 5.5 Good shot on goal that Galek was lucky to stop, worked hard ish
Carlos 6 Considering he was always under pressure from several players, did well with the ball a number of times.
Roy 5 Didn't get in the game much, well done Adelaide
Boyd 5 Ditto

Oh well, the local leagues are starting and we can  have some other performances to worry about.


Mossy 6 Not really a lot to do
Boxall 5 Kept Zullo at bay - should have done better with volley
Siggy 5.5 Was going to rate higher, until he was arguing with the ref upfield while they won a penalty
Dura 6 Had a good game overall, apart from silly dive in to give them the pen
Timmins 6.5 Kept two of the best wingers in the league at bay as well as contributing down the wing - is improving
Lia 5  Done his job
Manny 6 Some good tackles and some bad but worked hard
Ridenton 5 Some good turns, out muscled at times started to fade - is improving
Kenny 5.5  Almost scored a great goal, hungry
Stein 5  Should have scored. Faded
Brockie 5.5 Good shot on goal didn't work well with  Stein - not doing it for me
Carlos 4  Looked tired after a couple of minutes, gave the ball away far to easy 
Roy 4   Didn't get in the game much, well done Adelaide 
Boyd 5 Did some good work when he came on looked like things could happen - is improving


Thought Timmins got  better as the game progressed game as the game progressed

Would rate manny lower as I thought he was an accident waiting to happen, his frustration was starting to get into yellow card territory a bit too much

Stein and brockie as a pairing was crap, on this performance no-one will want Stein and as for Brockie...just not good enough