Post history

History for Gdog

WPM R18 vs Brisbane Roar | Thu 6th Feb | 5:00pm | RoF - Kids Go Free!

Back to topic

Current version

Posted February 08, 2025 00:11 · last edited February 08, 2025 03:30

Re that penalty.
I don't recall seeing an end on  clip of the incident and Isighe actually being knocked .We have only the players word for it that he was.
On the that basis it wasn't clear and obvious so the ref took the highest of tests and disallowed it.End of story.
Correction: Ive been back and stand corrected. The Prof is right. There was obvious contact that did put him off his stride and should have been enough for ma pen.So we have grades of contact now do  we? So do we reopen the rule books and guidance notes  for refs?

Previous versions

2 versions
Unknown editor edited February 08, 2025 03:30
Re that penalty.
I don't recall seeing an end on  clip of the incident and Isighe actually being knocked .We have only the players word for it that he was.
On the that basis it wasn't clear and obvious so the ref took the highest of tests and disallowed it.End of story.
Unknown editor edited February 08, 2025 03:18
'Re that penalty.
I don't recall seeing an end on  clip of the incident and Asighe actually being knocked .We have only the players word for it that he was.
On the that basis it wasn't clear and obvious so the ref took the highest of tests as disallowed it.End of story.