I'd go May over Ishige. Ironically the Nix get 2 attackers named
https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/360582561/how-many-phoenix-players-would-make-combined-auckland-fc-wellington-phoenix-xi
Alex Paulsen (Auckland)
https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/360582561/how-many-phoenix-players-would-make-combined-auckland-fc-wellington-phoenix-xi
Alex Paulsen (Auckland)
Hiroki Sakai (Auckland)
Dan Hall (Auckland)
Nando Pijnaker (Auckland)
Francis de Vries (Auckland)
Alex Rufer (Phoenix)
Louis Verstraete (Auckland)
Jake Brimmer (Auckland)
Neyder Moreno (Auckland)
Kosta Barbarouses (Phoenix)
Hideki Ishige (Phoenix)