Starting XI
1.3K
·
2.8K
·
about 9 years

GK wrote:

There seem to be a lot of Lower Hutt City - pseudo - Phoenix Academy players in the identification squad - for a Central League club that is 7 of 10 in the grade. 

Where is the form for these players coming from?  7 wins 7 loses, vs 9 wins, 3 draws and 2 loses from the Ole players.

Seems like one youth system is working and the other, not so much, yet? (New club).

Lower Hutt doesn't seem to have a Reserve grade team in Capital Prem like Ole, so no depth either?

Oh - after reading the article it seems the camp is in Wellington - that might explain the overload of Wellington-based players?

My Ashburton/Ole boy, Ryan Feutz didn't get a call - so I'm pretty dark on it.

PS: Jesse Randall and Oskar van Hatrick are good players.

Aye it's a long way to travel from Porirua to Wellington so that must be it!

Getting paid to be here
700
·
970
·
over 6 years

GK wrote:

There seem to be a lot of Lower Hutt City - pseudo - Phoenix Academy players in the identification squad - for a Central League club that is 7 of 10 in the grade. 

Where is the form for these players coming from?  7 wins 7 loses, vs 9 wins, 3 draws and 2 loses from the Ole players.

Seems like one youth system is working and the other, not so much, yet? (New club).

Lower Hutt doesn't seem to have a Reserve grade team in Capital Prem like Ole, so no depth either?

Oh - after reading the article it seems the camp is in Wellington - that might explain the overload of Wellington-based players?

My Ashburton/Ole boy, Ryan Feutz didn't get a call - so I'm pretty dark on it.

PS: Jesse Randall and Oskar van Hatrick are good players.

Most of the Lower Hutt City players play in Cap 1, not the Central League team. Make of that what you will.

WeeNix
920
·
980
·
about 7 years

GK wrote:

There seem to be a lot of Lower Hutt City - pseudo - Phoenix Academy players in the identification squad - for a Central League club that is 7 of 10 in the grade. 

Where is the form for these players coming from?  7 wins 7 loses, vs 9 wins, 3 draws and 2 loses from the Ole players.

Seems like one youth system is working and the other, not so much, yet? (New club).

Lower Hutt doesn't seem to have a Reserve grade team in Capital Prem like Ole, so no depth either?

Oh - after reading the article it seems the camp is in Wellington - that might explain the overload of Wellington-based players?

My Ashburton/Ole boy, Ryan Feutz didn't get a call - so I'm pretty dark on it.

PS: Jesse Randall and Oskar van Hatrick are good players.

Napier are winning that league, maybe they should take more Napier guys. Oh, that's right, they have an average age of 26. Largest number of Ole boys are also too old for U17. Most of their U17 CL starters are at the camp.

LHC are coming 7 out of 10 because their oldest player is barely 20 and average age is <18. 4 regulars are 16. To quote one of them "we are legit just kids in a men's div". Add to that the likes of Hillis, Hamilton and van Hattrick (sic) missed a few games through injury, them and a couple others due to Panda Cup trip, U20 WC and Pacific games. Not to mention that if one of those narrow losses was a win they'd be third, 

LHC "reserves" are in Cap 1 and are all U17. And sitting 4th, only 5 points behind leaders and 3 behind second, kids who haven't started shaving in a men's league.

As for camp being in Wellington, it's to spread the pain with a large % being Wellington based. Last camp was in Auckland. And in case you are wondering why so many Wgtn players are at the camp, I should point out that most of them are from other places and have moved to Ole or Phoenix for football development.

WeeNix
920
·
980
·
about 7 years

GK wrote:

 ...

PS: Jesse Randall and Oskar van Hatrick are good players.

Love the typo BTW ;)

WeeNix
390
·
910
·
about 11 years

is it really that hard to understand that most are based in Wellington because of Ole and Nix? 

NCR played wouldnt have passports either being imports

WeeNix
920
·
980
·
about 7 years

Most of the Lower Hutt City players play in Cap 1, not the Central League team. Make of that what you will.

Which of the LHC players have not played CL this year?

Kennet, who's only 15 and behind Jones and Paulsen, hasn't. 

Who else?

Getting paid to be here
700
·
970
·
over 6 years

ClubOranje wrote:

Most of the Lower Hutt City players play in Cap 1, not the Central League team. Make of that what you will.

Which of the LHC players have not played CL this year?

Kennet, who's only 15 and behind Jones and Paulsen, so hasn't. 

Who else?

Let me rephrase. Most of the Lower Hutt City players have played the majority of the winter in Cap 1. I believe Oskar, Henry, Harry and Alex are the only four to have played significant Central League minutes.

WeeNix
920
·
980
·
about 7 years

ClubOranje wrote:

Most of the Lower Hutt City players play in Cap 1, not the Central League team. Make of that what you will.

Which of the LHC players have not played CL this year?

Kennet, who's only 15 and behind Jones and Paulsen, so hasn't. 

Who else?

Let me rephrase. Most of the Lower Hutt City players have played the majority of the winter in Cap 1. I believe Oskar, Henry, Harry and Alex are the only four to have played significant Central League minutes.

Yep, (understood what you meant) but who of the others (if any) have none?

Pretty sure Max, Kris, Adam and Oldie have some, but Finn and Blake?

Getting paid to be here
700
·
970
·
over 6 years

ClubOranje wrote:

ClubOranje wrote:

Most of the Lower Hutt City players play in Cap 1, not the Central League team. Make of that what you will.

Which of the LHC players have not played CL this year?

Kennet, who's only 15 and behind Jones and Paulsen, so hasn't. 

Who else?

Let me rephrase. Most of the Lower Hutt City players have played the majority of the winter in Cap 1. I believe Oskar, Henry, Harry and Alex are the only four to have played significant Central League minutes.

Yep, (understood what you meant) but who of the others (if any) have none?

Pretty sure Max, Kris, Adam and Oldie have some, but Finn and Blake?

Everyone except Callum has played at least one (1) minute.

Starting XI
1.3K
·
2.8K
·
about 9 years

ClubOranje wrote:

[quote=GK]

LHC are coming 7 out of 10 because their oldest player is barely 20 and average age is <18. 4 regulars are 16. To quote one of them "we are legit just kids in a men's div". Add to that the likes of Hillis, Hamilton and van Hattrick (sic) missed a few games through injury, them and a couple others due to Panda Cup trip, U20 WC and Pacific games. Not to mention that if one of those narrow losses was a win they'd be third, 

That doesn't really explain how Wests won the league 2 seasons ago with a team with average age of 18 (and largely the team that went on to win the National League with Eastern Suburbs) and also finished 2nd last season and are only 1 point of the top at the moment - maybe its the difference in academy philosophies? 

Marquee
1.1K
·
7.6K
·
almost 13 years

Now lads don't forget it is a Talent Identification Camp not NZF U17 squad camp. Players from other areas (inc those mention may have already been scouted)  I know the NZF coaches travel.

GK
Phoenix Academy
100
·
410
·
over 10 years

Blew.2 wrote:

Now lads don't forget it is a Talent Identification Camp not NZF U17 squad camp. Players from other areas (inc those mention may have already been scouted)  I know the NZF coaches travel.

Please Bruce, the lads were only just getting started. And everyone has misspelt van Hatrick, just the one t-ease.

Sorry about the raw nerves all - just wondering about the level of quality from this U17 cycle - as asked by another five tantrums ago.

Was also wondering, as mentioned above - if there were others being looked at when the camps were in Auckland or heaven forbid - Christchurch/Ashburton legit footballing hotbeds. 

In the name of the Sumner, the Nelsen and the Holy Sigmund, Amen.

Woof Woof
2.7K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

GK wrote:
 

In the name of the Sumner, the Nelson and the Holy Sigmund, Amen.

Who's that guy?

WeeNix
920
·
980
·
about 7 years

ClubOranje wrote:

Let me rephrase. Most of the Lower Hutt City players have played the majority of the winter in Cap 1. I believe Oskar, Henry, Harry and Alex are the only four to have played significant Central League minutes.

Yep, (understood what you meant) but who of the others (if any) have none?

Pretty sure Max, Kris, Adam and Oldie have some, but Finn and Blake?

Everyone except Callum has played at least one (1) minute.

Thanks Andrew. Not up to your usual "stat man" standard of player-a had x-starts, y-appearances and z-minutes, but hey-ho, it's all I asked and good enough ;)

I know all Ole lads, Jesse and Jacko have all CL minutes, how do the Billy from Neilson, Waibop and AK players fare in equivalent leagues?

Early retirement
3.1K
·
34K
·
about 17 years

There were players outside that list involved anyway. Chris Marsh tweeted the Keeper group and there were 5.

Legend
11K
·
22K
·
about 9 years

[/quote]

Please Bruce, the lads were only just getting started. And everyone has misspelt van Hatrick, just the one t-ease.

Sorry about the raw nerves all - just wondering about the level of quality from this U17 cycle - as asked by another five tantrums ago.

Was also wondering, as mentioned above - if there were others being looked at when the camps were in Auckland or heaven forbid - Christchurch/Ashburton legit footballing hotbeds. 

In the name of the Sumner, the Nelsen and the Holy Sigmund, Amen.

[/quote]

It's a pity you made the spelling correction.

WeeNix
920
·
980
·
about 7 years

coochiee wrote:

[/quote]

Please Bruce, the lads were only just getting started. And everyone has misspelt van Hatrick, just the one t-ease.

Sorry about the raw nerves all - just wondering about the level of quality from this U17 cycle - as asked by another five tantrums ago.

Was also wondering, as mentioned above - if there were others being looked at when the camps were in Auckland or heaven forbid - Christchurch/Ashburton legit footballing hotbeds. 

In the name of the Sumner, the Nelsen and the Holy Sigmund, Amen.

[/quote]

It's a pity you made the spelling correction.

Muphry' Law.  But what correction?

Getting paid to be here
700
·
970
·
over 6 years

Hard News wrote:

There were players outside that list involved anyway. Chris Marsh tweeted the Keeper group and there were 5.

Injury replacement. But it's definitely not a squad influenced by the location of the camp.

GK
Phoenix Academy
100
·
410
·
over 10 years

[quote=Hard News]

There were players outside that list involved anyway. Chris Marsh tweeted the Keeper group and there were 5.

Injury replacement. But it's definitely not a squad influenced by the location of the camp.

[/quote

Cheers for the info above - I don't care where the players come from - just that they are the best.

- you guys answered my question in two sentences - this is what happens when you live in your frontal cortex rather than your limbic system. 

- I also find it amusing how a common language can divide us - with no facial expressions or voice intonation - you can't see my eyebrows going up in down as I type.

Best of luck to the U17 squad.

WeeNix
920
·
980
·
about 7 years

I'll just park this here

Oskar van Hattum

WeeNix
920
·
980
·
about 7 years

Oops..wrong button

I'll just park this here

Oskar van Hattum

Henry Hamilton

Matt Garbett

Marko Stamenic

Adam Hillis

Harry Bark

Highlight clips from a few of the U17 camp attendee

Edit to add...

Billy Check

RR
·
Bossi Insider
9.8K
·
34K
·
almost 16 years
WeeNix
390
·
910
·
about 11 years

so OFC are currently holding a youth tournament, why is there no NZ team involved? Yet India and Estonia are? 

Getting paid to be here
700
·
970
·
over 6 years

so OFC are currently holding a youth tournament, why is there no NZ team involved? Yet India and Estonia are? 

What value would an under-18 tournament hold for a New Zealand team right now?

WeeNix
390
·
910
·
about 11 years

probably more value than a ID camp! Often hear that our players dont have enough international experience. U17 could have gone some games before their world cup for the purpose of the tournament we could have called them u18. 

We sent a 3rd string team to Samoa for south Pacific games. Realistically how many of that team will play in qualifying and Olympics. So that tournament survived little purpose.

Starting XI
550
·
2.4K
·
over 14 years

so OFC are currently holding a youth tournament, why is there no NZ team involved? Yet India and Estonia are? 

What value would an under-18 tournament hold for a New Zealand team right now?

Australia just announced friendly's with England, Brazil and Korea in the UK for there U17. Hope NZF finds some friendly games for this lot before the WC.
WeeNix
920
·
980
·
about 7 years

so OFC are currently holding a youth tournament, why is there no NZ team involved? Yet India and Estonia are? 

What value would an under-18 tournament hold for a New Zealand team right now?

Panda Cup was U18. Good experience for the U17 (potential) squad.

Agree though this one probably not at the right level.

Starting XI
1.5K
·
4.9K
·
almost 16 years

so OFC are currently holding a youth tournament, why is there no NZ team involved? Yet India and Estonia are? 

Solomons who have also qualified for the FIFA u-17 finals are also not participating.

https://www.oceaniafootball.com/oceania-four-mark-historic-openers/

https://www.oceaniafootball.com/youth-tournament-helping-paint-the-bigger-picture/

https://www.oceaniafootball.com/vision-2026-leading-development/

The inaugral "OFC Youth Development Tournament" for u-18 sides features OFC representatives New Caledonia, Tahiti, Papua New Guinea and host Vanuatu, as well as Estonia from Europe and India from Asia.

"Organised in partnership with UEFA through the UEFA Assist Programme the main aim of this tournament is to provide players, coaches and referees in our region with the necessary tool that will enhance their performance on off the field at international level."

OFC Head of Education & Development Giovanni Fernandes "says each part of the event – the competitive environment, the knowledge exchanges, the inter-confederation relationship building – will contribute to the overall objectives of the OFC Football Development Strategy 2026.

“The bigger picture we talk about relates to the 2026 vision of having two OFC nations qualify for the FIFA World Cup. We want to leave a legacy which will see OFC Member Associations being competitive in OFC and FIFA competitions.

OFC President Lambert Matlock: “At this moment we find it difficult to match up with the international teams outside Oceania. I think we need to accept that there is a deficiency in capacity between the majority of Oceania nations and countries from outside the region....

“But we have to keep trying to bridge the gap.”

“Having UEFA onboard through the UEFA Assist programme is really significant to us and incredibly important for Oceania football.

“Initially the project was aimed at helping those nations in OFC which had already qualified for a youth world cup. But we wanted to go further and give opportunities to more nations.

“I’m really pleased the initiative has allowed us to give inter-confederation exposure to a wider audience.”

Hoped to become a regular event.

OFC also see it as helping bridge the gap between their regional u-16 and u-19 finals.

So it's not really aimed at u-16 or u-17 sides.

India have entered their u-19 side preparing for the upcoming AFC U-19 Championship and the South Asian Football Confederation Championship.

Estonia were also available to add a European element and have been forging ties with OFC, their senior team having toured in 2017.

Starting XI
550
·
2.4K
·
over 14 years

Any news on the U17 build up games?

Getting paid to be here
700
·
970
·
over 6 years

Royz wrote:

Any news on the U17 build up games?

Team leaves NZ on Oct 13 (or close to that) and has its first WC match Oct 27, so you'd bet on a couple (at least) v other competing teams in that fortnight.

WeeNix
920
·
980
·
about 7 years

Royz wrote:

Any news on the U17 build up games?

Team leaves NZ on Oct 13 (or close to that) and has its first WC match Oct 27, so you'd bet on a couple (at least) v other competing teams in that fortnight.

Ecuador and Nigeria 

Would be nice to get USA as well, but doesn't seem that likely.

Trialist
31
·
64
·
about 5 years

How are they able to be competitive with just two games prior to tournament. Surely the team should be playing half a dozen games against central or northern league teams prior to leaving. How does there preparation compare to the men’s u20 team?.

Marquee
4K
·
5.5K
·
almost 12 years

The same as the U20s. Arguably better if you include the panda cup.

Getting paid to be here
700
·
970
·
over 6 years

Palau wrote:

How are they able to be competitive with just two games prior to tournament. Surely the team should be playing half a dozen games against central or northern league teams prior to leaving. How does there preparation compare to the men’s u20 team?.

As far as I can recall, the 2019 U20 team didn't play any games against local sides during its various camps – and it never had anything close to its final XI available during any of them.

They had two games in Poland pre: the World Cup – and keeper Michael Woud didn't even play in those.

The U17s have played games v clubs during some of their camps (different strokes for different coaches – plus they have 99% of their players on hand).

They also got three internationals at the Panda Cup, something the 2019 U20 team didn't.

It is less than ideal that they will have done nothing together from mid-July until mid-October. A camp in the school holidays (which are the fortnight before departure) might have been useful.

Early retirement
3.1K
·
34K
·
about 17 years
Marquee
4K
·
5.5K
·
almost 12 years

a lot of comments on FB about this being a Lower Hutt team... with that representation they must be the best age group team in the country!

Does look bad without context of knowing about the academies etc and going by results at the national school championships.

Phoenix Academy
59
·
230
·
over 11 years

Who missed out from last squad any bolters 

Getting paid to be here
700
·
970
·
over 6 years

charger1 wrote:

Who missed out from last squad any bolters 

CB Nicholas Milicich and LB Robert Sabo went to the Panda Cup in May (18 man squad, 19 after an injury replacement) and didn't make the World Cup squad.

Third GK Callum Kennett, MF Otto Ingham, RB(?) Harry Bark, and MF Ben Old have come in to join the other 17 from that tournament.

GK Joseph Knowles (who's eligible for the next U17 cycle, as is Kennett), DF Joel Clissold, MFs Hayden Aish, Billy Check, Jackson Manuel, Ryan Verney and FWs Riley Bidois, Blake Driehuis and Stephanos Georgiou were named in the squad for the last camp in July and didn't make the World Cup squad.

You’ll need an account to join the conversation!

Sign in Sign up