All Whites, Ferns, and other international teams

2012 OFC Nations Cup Solomon Islands

896 replies · 67,803 views
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

Stevo wrote:

Mark "Extreme Sports Glory Hunter" Watson: "Last time I checked, cannibalism still exists in parts of PNG...I mean really,  2-1?????...NZ should be beating them 10-0...I'm still not convinced about soccer in NZ..."



We're not related, by the way. Firstly, it's "Papua New Guinea", not "PNG". We don't usually call "New Zealand", "NZL". No, New Zealand should not be beating Papua New Guinea 10-0 for the simple fact that they were an excellent team, coached by an excellent and highly decorated coach. Perhaps the All Blacks could demolish "cannibals" and that would be more to his liking. I find Mark's comments disappointing but unsurprising; that's the mentality of some folks in our country, sadly, when it comes to football. David Muta, Samuel Kini, Koriak Upaiga, Mike Foster, Kema Jack and Leslie Kalai have overcome all sorts of adversity to achieve the results they've achieved in Honiara and an ignorant, ill-informed, comment like that completely removes these people from their performances - it's debasing, particularly the reference to cannibalism. I'm sure if a foreigner looked at our track record of obesity, heart disease and child abuse then lamented, "So why aren't we beating these people - they're all unfit?! I mean really...?!", we'd feel they'd been somewhat uncharitable. 

Sorry, that's my brain explosion for the evening - time for bed..!

GGW
Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

Sorry Gordon.  He did call Papua New Guinea correctly.  But he's still an arsehole.

 

http://content.radionetwork.co.nz/weekondemand/radiosport/41900.mp3

 

PS: The Solomons vs NZ was "brutally boring"...yet he loved a 9-6 game of rugby...and you should have heard him after the Bahrain match.  "I love football-this, football-that".  GLORY HUNTER!

 

 

Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

No worries. To be expected, I suppose. 

GGW

Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

Gordon, what players from the other teams do you think could play in the a league? Thanks.

Good commentary and comments here.

Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

Great goal from Totori last night.

Seems like PNG improved a lot under Farina (will he stay there, btw?). Shame their qualifying journey lasted for 5 days only. Would be great to see Nations Cup in this format being held every two years, would surely boost Oceanic football.

 

 

Semis

NCL vs NZL ... another tough matchup for All Whites, but I think they will prevail. Win by a goal, with Caledonians score. 1-2.

SOL vs TAH ... my pick is Tahiti, they are having great tournament and I think they can beat hosts. Game is at 2 am here so I might watch it. :)

 

Surely, there is great Third Round ahead of us.

 

Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

Just saw Totori's goal on the highlights on Sky Sport. Jeeezusss! What a strike!

People like Coldplay and voted for the Nazis. You can't trust people.

Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

Just saw Totori's goal on the highlights on Sky Sport. Jeeezusss! What a strike!

 

The new Ian Hogg!

Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

Was a great strike, feel the context of the game does need to be considered though


Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

mitch_f.hr wrote:

Great goal from Totori last night.

Seems like PNG improved a lot under Farina (will he stay there, btw?). Shame their qualifying journey lasted for 5 days only. Would be great to see Nations Cup in this format being held every two years, would surely boost Oceanic football.

 

 

Semis

NCL vs NZL ... another tough matchup for All Whites, but I think they will prevail. Win by a goal, with Caledonians score. 1-2.

SOL vs TAH ... my pick is Tahiti, they are having great tournament and I think they can beat hosts. Game is at 2 am here so I might watch it. :)

 

Surely, there is great Third Round ahead of us.

 

 

Yeah, I think everyone's been pleasantly surprised by PNG, I certainly expected to be pretty decent, but they've been much better than that, and certainly deserved more than a solitary point.

I hope Farina stays there, they seem to be on the right track.

Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

This competition has been a real eye opener for me in regards to how good many of the Oceania teams are. There is a lot of potential in the OFC and it would good to see it fostered and tapped.

I am particularly impressed with their ability to maintain energy levels in these sapping conditions. Perhaps we should be doing more training in the region ourselves!

GGW's commentary been great to listen to. Miles is entertaining, although a bit "off the beam" sometimes!

Who has been dragged in to do the commentating on the Sky coverage? I may have to keep listening to the OFC coverage and mute the TV.

 

IMG_0660.jpeg 950.07 KB
Rise up, Wellington!
Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

It was still Gordon and Miles commentating on Sky yesterday, doubt that it will change for the rest of the games.

Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

sanday wrote:

Gordon, what players from the other teams do you think could play in the a league? Thanks.

Good commentary and comments here.



I quite like the look of Olivier Dokunengo (NCL), George Gope-Fenepej (NCL), Marius Bako (NCL) and Bertrand Kai, also New Caledonia. Perhaps what they lack is a bit of express pace as witnessed yesterday with Benjamin Totori. We all know that this quality is usually the one that makes or breaks a player at the highest level. Technically? No issues with those four.

Incidentally, at the Match Day -1 Press Conference today, Ricki Herbert squashed rumours that Benjamin Totori had been signed by the Wellington Phoenix for next season. I think David Muta of Papua New Guinea is more than capable of stepping up to the A-League in pure technical terms but I suspect the boat may have sailed on his chance. Koriak Upaiga, Papua New Guinea, is an interesting left back, while Judikael Ixoee, who played football in the French Third Division is an exciting talent. Tahiti skipper Nicolas Vallar came through at Bordeaux as a youth player and he looks accomplished at this level, but maybe lacks that spark in terms of pace to take it up a notch. 

There is some exciting talent out there. I could keep writing but will leave it there for now.

GGW
Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

playwithFire wrote:

Was a great strike, feel the context of the game does need to be considered though



Yes, that's important to remember. Solomon Islands had their full strength side out (minus Alick Maemae and Judd Molea, not selected for the tournament, injury/form). New Zealand accepted short term discomfort in favour of long term gain, so expect that to pay dividends in the final two matches. 

There is a growing belief that Tahiti may be capable of toppling the host nation here tomorrow and set up an All Whites v Tahiti final, a scenario that would most likely see the local fans back the Kiwis over their cross-Pacific rivals. An intriguing prospect, 18,000 New Zealand supporters at Lawson Tama..? 

Local fans do love an underdog, but they respect teams that get the ball down and play good, exciting, expansive football. They'll cheer any play that has aesthetic appeal.

Cheers,

GGW
Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

sanday wrote:

Gordon, what players from the other teams do you think could play in the a league? Thanks.

Good commentary and comments here.





There is some exciting talent out there. I could keep writing but will leave it there for now.

GGW

 

Please, keep writing, it's quite interesting.

 

This is a football forum after all.

We will never fully decide who has won the football.

Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

Azevo wrote:

sanday wrote:

Gordon, what players from the other teams do you think could play in the a league? Thanks.

Good commentary and comments here.





There is some exciting talent out there. I could keep writing but will leave it there for now.

GGW

 

Please, keep writing, it's quite interesting.

 

This is a football forum after all.

Agreed. The state of Pacific football is fascinating - in some regards its almost like the final frontier for football globally (along with South and Central Asia I guess). Plus the A League clubs are ideally placed to pick talent up from there so its interesting as an All Whites fan, a Phoenix fan, and a football fan in general. GGW's insights are greatly appreciated!

People like Coldplay and voted for the Nazis. You can't trust people.

Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

The island players would count as foreign players in the a-league right? Makes it hard for them

Calling all fans in Japan, come down and support the mighty nix in Osaka

http://www.facebook.com/WellingtonPhoenixClubMembersSupportersGroupOsaka

Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

They would,

 

it would be quite an interesting thing to see what would happen if a bunch of players from the Islands were able to go professional.

We will never fully decide who has won the football.

Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

detoxin wrote:

The island players would count as foreign players in the a-league right? Makes it hard for them

We have a winner. The Phoenix have to step up here and prove their cause to the rest of Oceania by looking at one or two players from the OFC Cup. The Phoenix would look good to the rest of the OFC by signing up a few of the Island players.

 

Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

Shauneboy wrote:

Pretty pleased with the result today. An under strength squad, difficult conditions and a tough team to play at home. 

 

While I want us to qualify for every FIFA tournament going, I am pleased to see there seems to be an improvement in island football which means nz are being given a real test. I cannot see us ever being allowed into the Asian confederation, so development and strengthening of Oceania football can only be a good thing. I would like to see more regular games against Oceania countries, even if it means initially we are onl? able to put out nz or aus based teams. I think it would also be good to see more players from this confederation in the a- league. Surely strengthening the Oceania confederation by having good players from the islands in the Phoenix is better than scrabbling around Australia or elsewhere to boost the squad when there is potential to look closer to home. (assuming they are as good, or have thpotential to be as good, as anything else on offer.)

NZ isn't going to Asia anytime soon if the team is unable to beat the Solomans. I fear what the outside world think of the result. The Aussies will want to play other OFC nations instead of NZ!

 

Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

Fitzy wrote:

I would love to see a really strong OFC nations cup in the coming years, and also would prefer it to be held away from NZ every time. The level of support in the solomons has been great, realistically we would never get those kinds of crowds, and I actually like that the playing field is somewhat levelled by the conditions. 

On top of that, I think it would be fantastic if an island nation could qualify for the confederations cup. The world cup is another matter, but imo I don't think it would be that big of a deal for NZ to miss out on the confeds cup, and the benefit it might bring to a country like the solomons could far outweigh what it might do for us.

 

Travelling is good. NZ would miss big $$ by not playing Confederations Cup. Aussies used to rely on that money many years ago to stay solvent.,

Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

Is anyone else thinking that this "Zachsta" is the old Dingo's Diego Son?!?!?!

Permalink Permalink
almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago
Big Pete 65 wrote:

Azevo wrote:

They would,

 

it would be quite an interesting thing to see what would happen if a bunch of players from the Islands were able to go professional.

There have been several from French Polynesia who have played professionally in France over the years - most famously Christian Karembeu from New Caledonia who arguably had the most illustrious career of any player in Oceania history ahead of Wynton Rufer or any Aussies such as Kewell. A World Cup winner with France and Champions League winner (Real Madrid) and Oceania Player of the Year. (Karembeu was eligible to play for New Caledonia since he grew up there before moving to France as a teenager).

Other island footballers who played professionally :

Pascal Vahirua (Tahiti):  Played for twenty years in France, mostly for AJ Auxerre in French top flight in the 80's and 90's. Vahirua appeared for the French national team at Euro 1992 and qualifying for World Cup 1994 (22 games for France). Spotted by the Auxerre manager whilst holidaying in Tahiti.

Marama Vahirua: younger cousin of Pascal who has played professionally in Fench top flight since age 16: Nantes, Nice, Lorient, currently Monaco. Former France u-21 international.

Gerald Forschelet (Tahiti): Former Cannes, Bolton Wanderers, Neuchatel Xamax and Charleroi midfielder, still playing in lower Belgian leagues.

Reynald Temarii: former OFC President and Tahiti international (recently in FIFA strife) played in France from 1988- 1990 for Nantes.

Felix Tagawa (Tahiti international): Brisbane Strikers, Adelaide United Aussie NSL 2003, 2004

All of the talented Solomon Islanders like Bartram Suri, Henry Faa'rodo and Benjiman Totori who have played in NZ, Australia and Tahiti have spent most of their adult lives as professionals -  they have been fulltime footballers with no other jobs usually e.g. I interviewed Bartram Suri in Nelson once and he was living in Hotel Nelson and paid to play for Nelson. 

THE GREATEST UNKNOWN LEGEND OF OCEANIA FOOTBALL: ANTOINE KOMBOUARE (NEW CALEDONIA):

New Caledonia- born pro in Europe 1982- 1998 who won everything in France 1990-1995 with Paris- Saint Germain (Ligue 1, Cup)  Also played for Nantes, Sion (Switzerland) and Aberdeen (Scotland). At the PSG, he became famous for a winning header he scored in the dying seconds of a UEFA Cup quarter final against Real Madrid, in the 1992-93 season. The header qualified PSG for the next round. Kombouaré had already scored a decisive goal in similar circumstances against Anderlecht in the previous round. His habit of netting tie-deciding headers earned him the name of "Casque d'Or", which means "Golden Helmet" in French. In 1994-95, during a UEFA Champions League quarter final against Johan Cruyff's FC Barcelona dream team, he captained Paris Saint-Germain to a resounding and unexpected 2-1 win which qualified the French side for the semi-final, which they lost to AC Milan.

Kombouare has had the greatest managerial career of anyone from Oceania, managing French top flight sides Strasbourg, Valenciennes (French second div. champions) and Paris-Saint Germain 2009 until January this year when he was controversially fired with PSG on top of the league and widely regarded to be playing their best football for decades (PSG's chairman connived to replace him with former Chelsea manager Carlo Ancelotti). PSG appeared in two French cup finals during his tenor, winning once and qualified for the Europa League.

Isn't it amazing we haven't heard of this guy in New Zealand when he's an absolute football legend?

John Gope-Fenepej (New Caledonia): Played for Nantes in France, Bolton on loan and Creteil in France.

Three members of the current New Caledonia team currently play in the lower divisions in France e.g. Joel Wakanumune plays for Chambery, an illustrious French lower league club. In the 2010–11 season, Chambéry became the first amateur club in Coupe de France (French national cup) history to defeat three Ligue 1 clubs (Monaco, Brest, Sochaux), before losing in the quarterfinals.

 

 Kombouare - PSG manager 2009- 2012

     

    Kombouare - PSG player 1990- 1995
      I've always thought that had Tahiti been able to play it's best some of the Nations Cups won by NZ and Aussie could of had very different outcomes. Even this event is missing Forschelet and Vahirua, two players who would walk into the team and even NZ when they were at their peak.
      Supporter world's best and worst football teams: Waikato/WaiBop, Kingz, Knights, Phoenix, The Argyle, The Whites & the All Whites

      Permalink Permalink
      almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

      Game day fire up? Not much noise about the game anywhere


      Permalink Permalink
      almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

      Unbelievable amount of rain last night from about 5pm until after I went to sleep.  Worse than I have ever seen in Wellington. The local river seemed to have risen by a good couple of metres when I drove over it last night.

      Will be interesting to see how the ground coped with it.

      Pretty cloudy at the moment.  Although Wednesday proved the weather can change pretty quickly here.

      Game day.  Fire up!!

      Permalink Permalink
      almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

      New Zealand vs New Caledonia:

      Played: 26

      NZ Wins: 15

      NC Wins: 10

      Draws: 1

      Goals: NZ 57, NC 42



      Recent Meetings:

      September 2008: NZ 3 NC 0 (in Auckland)

      September 2008: NC 1 NZ 3 (in Noumea)

      Only Australia have beaten us more often than New Caledonia - although they haven't beaten us since October 1976, and only 1 of their wins has been outside their own country (October 1968 at Newmarket Park)

      Permalink Permalink
      almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

      The commentary on the stream cut out for about a minute. I enjoyed not hearing Miles.


      Yellow Fever - Misery loves company

      Permalink Permalink
      almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

      Stevo wrote:

      Is anyone else thinking that this "Zachsta" is the old Dingo's Diego Son?!?!?!

      Yeah,I was actually thinking the same thing. Same sort of tone,and message given to us lowly nzers. 

      Fired up for the game,the pitch may be in a bit of a state so that could make things even harder. Fairly nervous. Annoyingly I have work at 5 so have to watch it when get home later tonight. 


      Allegedly

      Permalink Permalink
      almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

      Patrick wrote:

      The commentary on the stream cut out for about a minute. I enjoyed not hearing Miles.

      Im guessing your watching the stream atm, whats the pitch looking like? Futbol24's live scoring has Tahiti 1-0 up, think Solomon Islands can come back to win?
      Permalink Permalink
      almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

      1-0 to Tahiti at half time, and they're well worth the lead.  Goal came from a well-worked set piece.

      Solomons haven't created a great deal, although Naka should have equalised but managed to put the ball over from inside the six-yard box.  Tahiti have missed a couple of good chances on the break with the Solomons playing a very high line.

      Ryans Rovers - pitch is holding together well enough, but certainly starting to shows some signs of wear.

      Permalink Permalink
      almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

      Azevo wrote:

      They would,

       

      it would be quite an interesting thing to see what would happen if a bunch of players from the Islands were able to go professional.

      There have been several from French Polynesia who have played professionally in France over the years - most famously Christian Karembeu from New Caledonia who arguably had the most illustrious career of any player in Oceania history ahead of Wynton Rufer or any Aussies such as Kewell. A World Cup winner with France, European Champonship winner and two time Champions League winner (Real Madrid) and Oceania Player of the Year 1995, 1998. (Karembeu was eligible to play for New Caledonia since he grew up there before moving to France as a teenager).

      Other island footballers who played professionally :

      Pascal Vahirua (Tahiti):  Played for twenty years in France, mostly for AJ Auxerre in French top flight in the 80's and 90's. Vahirua appeared for the French national team at Euro 1992 and qualifying for World Cup 1994 (22 games for France). Spotted by the Auxerre manager whilst holidaying in Tahiti.

      Marama Vahirua: younger cousin of Pascal who has played professionally in French top flight since age 16: Nantes, Nice, Lorient, currently Monaco. Former France u-21 international.

      Gerald Forschelet (Tahiti): Former Cannes, Bolton Wanderers, Neuchatel Xamax and Charleroi midfielder, still playing in lower Belgian leagues.

      Nicolas Vallar (Tahiti) a defender at SCO Angers , at Montpellier Hérault Sport Club and FC Sète . He now plays for FC Penafiel , in Portugal.

      David Grossman (Tahiti) : defender at FC Lorient 1992- 1998 (French Ligue 1 champions 1995), SCO Angers 1998-2001, Olympique Vannes 2003-2004, Olympique Saumur 2004-2007        

      William Bambridge (Tahiti) : Stade Rennes (Ligue 1) 1930's        

      Claude Carrara (Tahiti): FC Toulon 1965-70, Tahiti national team          

      Patrick Appriou (Tahiti): Olympique Marseille 1986- 88; played in the semis of the Europoean Cup-Winners Cup against Ajax 20/04/88. Olympique Ales (France) 1988-1990.

      Reynald Temarii: former OFC President and Tahiti international (recently in FIFA strife) played in France from 1988- 1990 for Nantes.

      Felix Tagawa (Tahiti international): Brisbane Strikers, Adelaide United Aussie NSL 2003, 2004

      All of the talented Solomon Islanders like Bartram Suri, Henry Fa'arodo and Benjiman Totori who have played in NZ, Australia and Tahiti have spent most of their adult lives as professionals -  they have been fulltime footballers with no other jobs usually e.g. I interviewed Bartram Suri in Nelson once and he was living in Hotel Nelson and paid to play for Nelson.

      The Masi cousins from Fiji: Esala and Manoa Masi played for some years as professionals in the old Aussie National Soccer League: Esala for Gippsland Falcons 1995-97, Woolongong Wolves 1997-2000, Newcastle United 2000-2004. Johor FC Malaysia 2005 and various state league clubs; Manoa Masi for Gippsland 1995-97.

      THE GREATEST UNKNOWN LEGEND OF OCEANIA FOOTBALL: ANTOINE KOMBOUARE (NEW CALEDONIA):

      New Caledonia- born pro in Europe 1982- 1998 who won everything in France 1990-1995 with Paris- Saint Germain (Ligue 1, Cup)  Also played for Nantes, Sion (Switzerland) and Aberdeen (Scotland). At the PSG, he became famous for a winning header he scored in the dying seconds of a UEFA Cup quarter final against Real Madrid, in the 1992-93 season. The header qualified PSG for the next round. Kombouaré had already scored a decisive goal in similar circumstances against Anderlecht in the previous round. His habit of netting tie-deciding headers earned him the name of "Casque d'Or", which means "Golden Helmet" in French. In 1994-95, during a UEFA Champions League quarter final against Johan Cruyff's FC Barcelona dream team, he captained Paris Saint-Germain to a resounding and unexpected 2-1 win which qualified the French side for the semi-final, which they lost to AC Milan.

      Kombouare has had the greatest managerial career of anyone from Oceania, managing French top flight sides Strasbourg, Valenciennes (French second div. champions) and Paris-Saint Germain 2009 until January this year when he was controversially fired with PSG on top of the league and widely regarded to be playing their best football for decades (PSG's chairman connived to replace him with former Chelsea manager Carlo Ancelotti). PSG appeared in two French cup finals during his tenor, winning once and qualified for the Europa League.

      Isn't it amazing we haven't heard of this guy in New Zealand when he's an absolute football legend?

      Frederic Piquionne : New Caledonia-born West Ham team-mate of Winston Reid, prev. with Stade Rennes, Monaco, Lyon, Portsmouth; one France cap.

      Benjamin Longue (New Caledonia): SC Bastia, France (Ligue 1) 1998-2005, CA Bastia (fourth tier) 2005-2008

      John Gope-Fenepej (New Caledonia): Played for Nantes in France, Bolton on loan and Creteil in France.        

      Marek Aucher (New Caledonia): Stade Laval (France Ligue 2 ) same team as Eugene Dadi (ex-Wellington Phoenix)                

      Vincent Xati Taua (New Caledonia): In Italy 1998 to date. Striker played for third and fourth tier sides Cavese, Benevento, Vibonese and Teramo. Currently at Isernia (fourth tier Italy). Cousin of Christian Karembeu.      

      Three members of the current New Caledonia team currently play in the lower divisions in France e.g. Joel Wakanumune plays for Chambery, an illustrious French lower league club. In the 2010–11 season, Chambéry became the first amateur club in Coupe de France (French national cup) history to defeat three Ligue 1 clubs (MonacoBrestSochaux), before losing in the quarterfinals.

      KOMBOUARE YOU TUBE CHANNEL: http://www.youtube.com/topic/cHit39oEleA/antoine-kombouar?feature=relchannel

       

       Kombouare - PSG manager 2009- 2012

         

        Kombouare - PSG player 1990- 1995

          Big Pete 65, Christchurch

          Permalink Permalink
          almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

          Pitch looking much better than any of us expected it to be. It's not a whole lot worse than it was for our game against Fiji. The day inbetween the last games and today's games seems to have given the ground staff time to run repairs.


          Yellow Fever - Misery loves company

          Permalink Permalink
          almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

          Tahiti hold on to win 1-0.  Solomons had plenty of the ball in the second half, but didn't create many chances.

          Permalink Permalink
          almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

          Oh good, I wasn't looking forward to facing Totori again in the final.


          Ramming liberal dribble down your throat since 2009
          This forum needs less angst and more Kate Bush threads



          Permalink Permalink
          almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

          All Whites starting line up (3-5-2) v New Caledonia: Gleeson (gk), Sigmund, Vicelich, Smith (c); Bertos, McGlinchey, Killen, Barbarouses, Lochhead; Wood, Smeltz.

          Permalink Permalink
          almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

          Surely with 5 in the midfield we won't be allowing New Caledonia to waltz straight through.


          Yellow Fever - Misery loves company

          Permalink Permalink
          almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

          Bullion wrote:

          All Whites starting line up (3-5-2) v New Caledonia: Gleeson (gk), Sigmund, Vicelich, Smith (c); Bertos, McGlinchey, Killen, Barbarouses, Lochhead; Wood, Smeltz.

          Happy with that. I think the 3-4-3 has been a terrible choice for this tournament particularly with the lack of running/conservation of energy policy our players seem to be taking. Will be interesting to see exactly how the central midfield players form up, I like the Idea of Kosta dropping deeper. Only question mark for me is whether Brockie should have been first wide player selected and then add one of Lochhead or Bertos. He just seems in better form.

          Permalink Permalink
          almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

          Spoonley?

          Permalink Permalink
          almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

          Patrick wrote:

          Surely with 5 in the midfield we won't be allowing New Caledonia to waltz straight through.

           

          You would think so.......



          Permalink Permalink
          almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

          playwithFire wrote:

          I feel like Killen didnt offer enough on defence or shielding when he played there. Two shielders and one attackive would work but thats not what we have there. I'm guessing it will be something like this:

                          Spoonley
               Sigmund Vicelich  Smith
                               Killen
          Bertos    McGlinchey     Lochhead
                       Barbarouses
                     Smeltz    Wood

          Xavi, Inneista and Messi work OK, no "shielders" in there. I like the fact that McGlinchy and Kosta are both busy players even though they are not going to pull off any traditional NZ sliding tackles. I think busy players are better defensively that holding midfielders who don't move much anyway. I thought Killen worked pretty well against Fiji, his passing was fairly good.

          I'm guessing that McGee will follow the ball more, Killen deeper and Kosta pushing a bit higher. I think you will usually see two at more or less the same depth though, not sure if that is what you mean from that formation.

          Permalink Permalink
          almost 14 years ago · edited over 13 years ago

          Also not sure how Barbarouses, Mcglinchey and Killen will operate? 

          I feel like Killen didnt offer enough on defence or shielding when he played there. Two shielders and one attackive would work but thats not what we have there. I'm guessing it will be something like this:

                          Gleeson
               Sigmund Vicelich  Smith
                               Killen
          Bertos    McGlinchey     Lochhead
                       Barbarouses
                     Smeltz    Wood

           

          Edit: How the hell did Spoonley make it onto that teamsheet?? 


          Permalink Permalink